The ethnographic literature of Altaic peoples published in the English language is still a comparatively light body of work. Until recently, the only monograph published thus far on the subject since the fall of communism and the opening up of the area to Western researchers was Vitebsky's largely personal account of his time living among the EvenyFootnote 1. This was a wanted addition to the libraries of many scholars working in the area but, written for a popular rather than an academic audience, it generated more questions than it provided answers.
Natasha Fijn's contribution to the field is, then, a welcome one. Her focus is on the micro-transhumant pastoralists of the Khangai Mountains in Mongolia. The subject of her PhD research, she spent almost a year living in two separate campsites – one in Arkhangai and one in Bulgan province. Rather than present her research in the chronological order that she experienced, the book is divided into ten chapters which serve to focus her prodigious research on specific themes including “social spheres”, symbolism and breeding of herd animals, enculturation, “tameness and control”, horses in Mongolia, annual cycles, “the domestic and the wild” and “the sacred animal”. If some of these research themes appear to be focussed upon animals rather than people, then one senses that Fijn would argue that is the result of a European rationalist perspective.
The author contextualises her ethnographic and auto-ethnographic research with reference to ethological studies as much as with anthropological and this approach is more than justified. There are few other cultures so dependent upon pastoralism, and no other nation which appropriates pastoralism, quite so much in its self-construction. Where some researchers may have sought to understand the culture from a position which placed the families being observed firmly in control of their animals and participating in a unidirectional, hierarchical association with their herds, Fijn recognises that the herd animals have agency of their own and incorporates them into her ethnography. What emerges is a picture which still paints the herders themselves at the centre, but which rightly depicts human-animals relationships as being mutually-dependent and in which communications can, and do, flow both ways.
Fijn makes good use of her background as a natural history filmmaker by issuing several short open access films on the publisher's website. These films are used to support key themes and points in the book, such as the herders’ naming of individual animals, and are referenced within the text. This kind of novel approach to anthropological publishing is to be lauded, making full use of recent developments in communication and technology to provide a more immersive presentation of her research which can only help to make it both more accessible to students and the public and to contextualise key points for academics who may wish to compare experiences.
By studying two families in rather different parts of the Khangai, the author obviously hopes to draw out general themes and patterns. The nature of prolonged field studies juxtaposed with the constraints of research project timetables means that it would be extremely difficult to have any more comparative research sites. Nevertheless, it is a statistical improbability that universal truths can be drawn from such a sample. Fijn's assertions that hay is routinely gathered (pp. 10, 187), that mutton is not consumed in the summer (pp. 91, 187) and that only old and weak animals are slaughtered for consumption (p. 198), for example, all run counter to the findings of my own research in the Khangai MountainsFootnote 2 as well as other ethnographer's research elsewhere in MongoliaFootnote 3. Such discrepancies could be explained as an effect of differing methodologies – where both Fijn and I have been reliant on translators, my work has been reliant upon interviews to build up a larger database of responses, Fijn's work allows for direct observation to correct errors which may creep into the answers provided through translational error.
One subject of research which helps to illustrate this point is the role of horses in the Mongolian psyche. It seems obvious to an outsider that horses are the most important domestic animal to Mongolians. When Fijn asked her study families which they thought was the most important though, she was told that it was sheep and goats (p. 152), this is the most common response that I have received as well. Sheep and goats are clearly more important economically and to seek the answer I was expecting I followed up the question by asking if horses were more important for status, but this was also answered in the negative. I'm convinced that this is a problem of language and communication through a translator as, it appears, is Fijn. Following her negative response, a whole chapter is dedicated to explaining why horses are important to Mongolians. Where the author uses her field observations these are persuasive arguments but when she allows herself to employ the archaeological record in her discussion her argument is weakened, confusing different archaeological cultures and monument styles (p. 157).
A repeated emphasis on the short days in winter in Mongolia and the long summer days (e.g. p. 175, 190) also seemed to illustrate the authors’ background more than her subjects. Mongolia has an extreme continental climate, but the seasonal changes in daylight hours are no more than is familiar to many Westerners – Ulaanbaatar lies on a similar degree of latitude to Budapest, Vienna and Seattle. This is perhaps related to a rather anomalous prologue, which is written in a somewhat different, travelogue, style to the rest of the book and seems out of place – more in tune with the popular approach of Vitebsky's volume than with the predominantly academic writing offered in this book.
In other places, Fijn's use of an auto-ethnographic approach provides welcome insights into Mongolian pastoralist culture, particularly when discussing the bonding between herders and their animals and the specific languages that have developed to facilitate communication between the separate human and non-human members of the herd (pp. 99–132). It also provides a necessary context for the reading of a subtext in the book. The majority of the individuals featured extensively in the study are women and children. This provides a fresh insight into attitudes and tasks not always accessible to male researchers but Fijn would have done well to acknowledge the potential weaknesses as well as strengths of her position in this regard. Stating that Mongolian women work harder than men (p. 189) may be true (certainly my own observations would not contradict it) but it may be a reflection of in-jokes and cultural expectations rather than fact.
In conclusion, this book is a significant contribution for those engaged in the study of East and Central Asian cultures, as well as those interested in pastoralists and human-animal relationships more generally. Fijn's work has already suggested new directions for my own research, supporting some theories and contradicting others – I predict that this will remain a key text in the area for many years to come.
