In the modern world, where economic power is so closely aligned with large national polities, military might, and territorial expanse, it is easy to forget that there was a time when a place as small, swampy, and politically fragmented as the Seven United Provinces of the Dutch Republic could be at the leading edge of the world economy. That these provinces could hold their own against aggressive nation-state neighbors up to 20 and more times their size is impressive, perhaps even mystifying. Yet when the English traveler Sir William Temple, composed his reflections on the Dutch Republic in 1673 he began by saying that the Dutch are “the envy of some, the fear of others, and the wonder of all their neighbors.” If the Republic was a puzzle to its contemporaries, it is no less so to us today. The mystery of how such a place came to play the starring role in what was for much of Europe a troubled century continues to intrigue historians.
Maarten Prak's new general history of The Dutch Republic in the Seventeenth Century offers yet another attempt to explain the phenomenon. And even if explanation ultimately remains elusive, his rich description of all aspects of Dutch seventeenth-century life offers the reader a feast. His story begins with a brief, but still complicated review of the arcane political wranglings of the medieval Low Countries, a history obscure enough to be new to almost all English readers. Yet it nicely sets the stage for what would otherwise be the incomprehensible political solutions of the “Golden Age” itself. The political narrative traces events up to the Peace of Utrecht in 1713, accompanied by a close examination of both the organization of the armed forces and the systems of public finance that paid their bills.
Although this historical contextualization offers valuable background information, it is the subsequent sections of the book that will be of most interest to readers of this Journal. Prak divides the remainder of his material into three sections: a first dealing with the emergence of a market economy, both at home and as instantiated in an emergent international trade network; a second focused on what we might call political economy, most particularly the distributional disputes—following closely on the heels of economic success—between elite authorities, craft guilds and tradesmen, and the laboring poor; and a final section devoted to the various cultural manifestations of a precociously urban society. Prak situates religious tolerance, the Dutch school of painting, and urban street demonstrations and riots, among other things, all within the common framework of the economic transformation for which the seventeenth-century Netherlands was most famous.
All this gives us a good picture of what happened and when. But historians trained in the various social science disciplines most want to know why things transpired as they did. Perhaps here Prak's book will prove less satisfactory. Ultimately his explanations hinge on a collection of multiple seemingly accidental moments. This is true across the spectrum of institutions for which the Dutch were noted, whether political, economic, or cultural. Indeed, such diverse manifestations as genre painting, religious tolerance, and urban social-welfare innovations, along with the preservation of strong local autonomy, a tradition of remarkable political compromise, and the establishment of a quasi monarchy that waxed and waned on a rotating basis, all emerge in Prak's analysis out of the various accidents of transmission from the medieval past in combination with the particular circumstances of the seventeenth century, most notably the protracted struggle for liberty from Spain and the threat of an increasingly aggressive France on the border. It is hard to build large theories of historical change out of such particularistic narratives. For better or worse, Prak does not attempt to do so. What he does do, and does well, is offer the reader a textured and full accounting of the circumstances that fashioned the “Dutch miracle” of the seventeenth century.
