Conferences on ancient education are not so numerous that enthusiasts can afford to miss them, so having been forced to miss this one myself, I was very pleased when most of the papers were published, and even more gratified to find that they made such a substantial contribution to the subject.
Franco Bellandi and Rolando Ferri draw particularly on Italian and French strengths in philology, textual criticism and the study of sub-literary texts, to focus attention less on the theory or ideology of education, and more on education in practice across the Roman Empire. Several of the collection's essays investigate how Greek and Latin were taught, or how formal grammars served the interests of practical language-learning. Bruno Rochette traces the development of handbooks designed primarily to teach Greek-speakers colloquial Latin in the late antique East (which also managed to transmit a smattering of Latin culture). Rolando Ferri examines in detail the language of school colloquia, comparing it with that of documentary sources, and finds that although most bilingual texts seem to have been compiled (not always very competently) by Greek-speakers for learners of Latin, a few were compiled by Latin-speakers teaching Greek. Guillaume Bonnet, focusing on the Ars grammatica of Dositheus, further develops an argument of Louis Holtz, that surviving artes grammaticae were very practical tools, chosen and adapted by teachers to suit their own pupils. Michaela Rosellini investigates not how the needs of speakers affected school texts, but conversely, how the language of grammars affected everyday usage. Francesca Lechi, moving on from the study of language and grammar to rhetoric, considers the impact, which she argues was significant, of Greek rhetors on Latin language and education.
Annamaria Cotrozzi and Franco Bellandi take literary texts as their theme, analysing the schools and teachers of Petronius’ Satyricon and Juvenal's Seventh Satire respectively, and showing that both works tell us more than we realized about the state of education in the early Empire. Bellandi, in particular, highlights the, to the poet, painful dissonance between the intellectual prestige of grammar and rhetoric in his day, and the mercenary triviality of grammarians’ and rhetors’ lives. Turning to the later Empire, Andrea Aragosti discusses fragments of Plautus cited by the fourth-century commentator Calcidius, and Chiara Tommasi Moreschini, arguing that Martianus Capella is unjustly neglected as both a literary text and a source for ancient education, explores Martianus’ use of satire, allegory and encyclopaedism to make a serious protest against the decline of intellectual life in his day. Last but not least, Konrad Vössing moves from texts and teachers to institutions, and investigates the development of the university, taking Alexandria as a case study, and arguing that the idea and the development of anything modern scholars would recognize as a university are innovations of Late Antiquity. Presumably the scholars and teachers whom Vössing discusses would have disagreed indignantly with Martianus’ assessment of the state of high culture; the juxtaposition of the two essays points neatly to a complexity in views and practices of education in Late Antiquity which this volume does not have space to explore, but which is the subject of much current investigation by other scholars.
Scattered through the collection are tantalizing references to papers which were given at the conference but which do not appear here. The essays that do appear, however, make an important contribution to some neglected aspects of ancient education, and an elegant addition to some of the better known. Making new connections between literature and society, and texts and teaching practices, they fill in some gaps in our knowledge and refine our reading of the evidence. Scholars not only of education but of grammar, rhetoric and literary culture in general will find much to admire and to engage with throughout the volume.
