The study of television music has only recently become recognized as a cohesive academic field, with authors like Ron Rodman, K. J. Donnelly, and Philip Hayward producing monographs concentrating on music for the small screen.Footnote 1 For the most part, however, essays on the topic remain scattered, peppering scholarly journals across disciplines, and film music remains the dominant interest in screen musicology.Footnote 2 Television musicology, therefore, has ample room for expansion, particularly given the ever-developing artistry of the medium, as well as mainstream musicology's rising awareness of television's role in informing and reflecting social politics. Consciously limiting itself to programs produced in the United States, Canada, and Britain, Music in Television brings together diverse scholarly perspectives to illuminate the variety of research “channels” available for critically assessing the artistic and social impact of television music.
Editor James Deaville divides the book's ten chapters into two groups of five, the first half considering broad historical or theoretical stances, and the second presenting more specific case studies. Archival research, textual analysis, and critical theory are all well represented in this book, and the authors situate their work in response to some of the more widely acknowledged research in screen musicology, such as that of Rodman, Michel Chion, Daniel Goldmark, Claudia Gorbman, Kathryn Kalinak, and Philip Tagg.Footnote 3
The book's initial chapter, Deaville's own essay on the historiography of television music studies (“A Discipline Emerges: Reading Writing about Listening to Television”) covers the discipline's development from the turn of the twentieth century to the present, considering the writings of technological speculators and industry professionals as well as academics. He takes an interdisciplinary approach, referring to popular music studies, film studies, and cultural criticism, and includes work by non-academic writers such as Jon Burlingame, acknowledging the important contributions of journalists and dedicated fans. Deaville's essay highlights the influence of classical music and filmed opera in early television broadcasting, 1970s German scholarship on television music and subject identity, Philip Tagg's early work on musical semiotics, and the focus of scholarship in the 1980s on music television and music videos. It then traces the move towards studying music in narrative television, as well as theme songs, commercials and advertising, children's television, and popular music as underscore.
Two essays in the first half of the book address genre. Rodman's “‘Coperettas,’ ‘Detecterns,’ and Space Operas: Music and Genre Hybridization in American Television” considers the hybridization of police dramas, science fiction dramas, musicals, soap operas, situation comedies (sitcoms), and westerns. He examines music's role in this process, identifying musical codes—based on timbre, melodic structure, and style—that enable it. Whereas Rodman's essay covers an array of televisual and musical genres, Michael Saffle, in “Rural Music on American Television, 1948–2010,” more specifically provides a summary of the ways in which rural musical styles have appeared in variety shows and sitcoms. Saffle also considers the use and manipulation of rural music in television's postmodern age, using the shows Hannah Montana (2006–2011) and 30 Rock (2006–2013) as examples.
In contrast to Rodman's and Saffle's essays, which depend upon close readings and genre analysis, the essays contributed by Shawn Vancour and Colin Roust exhibit a preference for primary source analysis, foregrounding interviews and archival research. Vancour's essay, “Television Music and the History of Television Sound,” offers a framework for a thorough study of television sound, drawing on four research perspectives: prevailing technologies, industrial practices, textual forms, and consumption practices. He demonstrates this multifaceted approach through a brief overview of television sound in the 1940s and 1950s—a period he describes as a watershed. Most compelling is his coverage of the vernacular theorization of the field distributed through trade essays of the time. Colin Roust's essay, “Music in the Golden Age of Television News Documentaries at NBC,” focuses on NBC's news programs from the 1950s through the 1970s, and in particular on Lucy Jarvis's contribution to these productions. In 1961, Jarvis was commissioned by President John F. Kennedy to produce three television documentaries in the interest of diplomacy: The Kremlin (1963), The Louvre (1964), and The Forbidden City (1973). Roust's essay considers Jarvis's musical choices, influenced by her creative partners and the films’ composers, noting the importance of source music from the culture depicted in the documentary and the influence of composer style on each film's success.
Robynn Stilwell's “‘Bad Wolf’: Leitmotif in Doctor Who” (2005) begins the second half of Deaville's book. A case study of leitmotif in this relaunched BBC program, the chapter addresses recurring visual and topical motifs within its first season (such as the often subtle insertion of “Bad Wolf” into dialogue and set design), as well as musical themes tied to specific characters (such as the Doctor and his companion, Rose Tyler). Stilwell provides an overview of Doctor Who's history, narrative structure, and programming context, but the heart of her essay is her demonstration of how composer Murray Gold employs the Doctor's and Rose's themes throughout the season, ultimately bringing them together to reflect the personal growth that each character has inspired in the other. Immediately following Stilwell's chapter is Sean Nye's “From Punk to the Musical: South Park, Music, and the Cartoon Format,” which explores the punk aesthetic of South Park's (1997–) co-creators, Trey Parker and Matt Stone, and the series’ music as a form of postmodern irony and self-critique. Nye acknowledges not only South Park's tendency to satirize childhood innocence and the conventions of Hollywood musicals and popular music, but also demonstrates the tensions within the series surrounding race, religion, and identity. A useful addendum to this essay, included as an appendix to the book, is a transcript of Nye's interview with South Park composer Adam Berry, covering shifts in compositional practice across generations of television composers, as well as Berry's personal approach to composing for small screen comedy.
The final three essays consider the politics of gender, sexuality, race, and poverty in specific instances of music in television. Julie Brown's “Channeling Glenn Gould: Masculinities in Television and New Hollywood” explores the effect of Gould's television appearances—particularly in the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation specials Glenn Gould: On the Record (1959) and Glenn Gould: Off the Record (1959)—on the filmic depiction of “Oedipally compromised, weak masculinity” (184). Gould, a famously eccentric musician, served as an archetype of the queer male artist in post-classical Hollywood cinema, as Brown demonstrates in her reading of the films Five Easy Pieces (1970) and Fingers (1978). Norma Coates's “It's What's Happening, Baby! Television Music and the Politics of the War on Poverty” addresses the early use of popular music television as a public relations tool. The 1965 production It's What's Happening, Baby! brought together a racially diverse and gender-mixed cast to publicize job-training programs for low-income youth. Coates adeptly covers the political debates about the program, noting the ways in which negative responses, especially from members of the United States Congress, exposed tensions of race and class. Kip Pegley's “‘The Rock Man's Burden’: Consuming Canada at Live 8” outlines the contrasting images of Canada produced by the Barrie, Ontario, Live 8 benefit concert in 2005. International audiences who bought Live 8's DVD “were presented with a soft, acoustic Canada,” whereas those who attended the concert or watched it live from within Canada experienced a rock-focused event, laden with “hegemonic musical biases” that privileged white, male performers.
This collection of essays valuably demonstrates the variety of topics and scholarly approaches that can be pursued in and through television musicology. Although some of the essays attempt to do too much in too little space, and others stray into tangential (though always useful) material, they are well researched, with carefully considered methodologies and conclusions. Music in Television is an important addition to this field's bibliography, illustrating numerous avenues, both broad and narrow but by no means exhaustive, by which one can explore music for the small screen.
