The purpose of the present symposium was to evaluate Perestroika's impact. Since the American Political Science Review (APSR), the American Journal of Political Science (AJPS), and the Journal of Politics (JOP) were all targets of criticism in the movement, whereas other national and regional association journals such as Perspectives on Politics and Political Research Quarterly were not, I looked for change in the former. Comparable data on the past contents of the APSR and AJPS had already been published, so I focused my recent surveys on those two. This focus implies no judgment as to the relative prestige of these journals. They pretend to represent the discipline as a whole and are paid for by all association members, and these are sufficient reasons to address their editorial biases.
I wish that Perestroika could claim credit for the founding of Perspectives, but my understanding is that Perspectives was conceived (if not yet in publication) before the Perestroika movement began. I suspect that Perspectives would easily win a popularity contest among Perestroikans over the APSR, AJPS, or JOP, but the Perestroika movement did not found or shape Perspectives, so it falls outside the scope of my comments. If Perestroika played a bigger part in the launching of Perspectives than I have understood, I would certainly like to know. As it is, other than creating a more supportive environment for qualitative and problem-driven research, I am not sure that Perestroika did much to promote Perspectives.
Even if Perspectives has risen to the august status that its current editor claims for it, its existence does not blunt my criticism of today's APSR. Perspectives was not intended to introduce a methodological division of labor with the APSR, such that it would carry qualitative research while the APSR would favor quantitative work. The establishment of Perspectives therefore offers no excuse for the methodological biases of the APSR and no reason why political scientists should be complacent about the latter.
To clarify, it is not my understanding that the APSR's collective editorship at UCLA was designed to facilitate methodological pluralism. A collective editorship has the potential to realize that aim, but its main objective in this case was apparently to render the editorial task more manageable. If I am mistaken in this belief, I invite those who participated in the formation of the joint editorship to correct me, but at least one person privy to the process told me that methodological pluralism was not a key issue in the switch to multiple editors. Indeed, when the editors held an open forum at the first APSA convention after they took over, they had little to say about the journal's methodological orientation. Several of us attended that meeting to impress upon the new editorial team our expectations of fair treatment for qualitative work, but there was little mention of this goal in the editors' prepared remarks.Footnote 1 In any event, whether methodological pluralism was part of the original intent behind a collective editorship or not, this aim is not realized in the journal's pages, and this confirms that Perestroika has not had the impact that many of its adherents had hoped for.
To be honest, I expected to find more diversity in the contents of the APSR and AJPS than I did after more than a decade of contention over their editorial policies. The results of the recent surveys came as a surprise.
