This is a much needed, critically engaged book. The authors offer a timely, insightful, and meticulously substantiated analysis of what it means to be an anthropologist of the Middle East and North Africa in the United States. They also provide a welcome argument in favour of a critical, engaged anthropology and a critique of an anthropology complicit with imperial power and hierarchies.
Chapters 1 and 2, “Becoming a Scholar” and “Making It through Graduate School” tell a more general story about anthropology and its recent transformations in the US. Whereas Chapters 3 through 5—“Navigating Conflicts on the Job”, “Building Disciplinary Institutions” and “Dis/engaging the War on Terror”—are more focused on the situation of MENA anthropology in relation to the US involvement in the region and related domestic conflicts—most importantly the Israel-Palestine conflict, followed by the war on terror.
A non-American reader may wonder why the overall rather exceptional situation of US anthropologists adds up to unmarked “anthropology” in the book title. Many of the tensions and conflicts addressed by the book are closely related to their location at the heart of the US empire: the intersection between US imperial policies and the Palestine-Israel conflict, the pressures against critical research about regions affected by the US empire, as well as the problems teachers face due to donor power, the commercialization of education, and right-wing groups that try to monitor university teachers. One issue seems characteristic of anthropology in many places around the world, however: a generational shift whereby anthropology is gradually becoming less male-dominated and less uniformly ethnically European—and at the same time more politically engaged. Deeb and Winegar document and analyze this shift very convincingly, although I would have been interested to hear more about the way class plays into the professional formation of region-related anthropologists as well.
At one side of the shift stands the statement of a senior anthropologist: “That's my politics, it's not my anthropology” (122). Especially for white male anthropologists of older generations a distinction between politics and science was part of their researcher's ethos. The authors, in contrast, title their book Anthropology's Politics, and show that the ethos of unpolitical anthropology was facilitated and naturalized by bourgeois male white (in the specifically American sense of whiteness meaning descendants of European settlers) privilege. Anthropology in the US (and likewise in western Europe) remains a largely—yet no longer exclusively—bourgeois and white discipline, but it is no longer male-dominated, and structural racism and gender privileges have become increasingly challenged. This has major consequences.
Anthropology's Politics was published shortly after the American Anthropological Association (AAA) held an intensively debated membership vote about whether it should join the boycott, divestment, and sanctions campaign against Israeli academic institutions. The boycott motion was narrowly defeated, receiving 49.5 percent of the votes. That such a motion could make it to a membership vote in the first place tells of a generational sea change among US anthropologists, shifting from the tradition of the privileged observer (typically bourgeois white male, as anthropologists mostly were until the late twentieth century) to a new tradition of the engaged participant-observer (paralleled by increasing numbers of women and region-related scholars in the discipline).
The authors point out that this shift was reflected by institutional stances of the AAA much earlier in regard to the Americas, but that it has taken longer for critical stances in regard to the Middle East and North Africa to gain institutional recognition in the AAA. Indeed, why has it been easier for anthropologists to speak out about politically contentious issues in the Americas than in the Middle East for so long? The US has strong imperial interests in both regions, and resistance against the US empire is prominent in both regions as well. The authors highlight the inconsistency of this differential treatment, but do not quite explain its causes. Also, why is there so much more pressure against academics who speak about Palestine, but also so many young academics who want to do research in Palestine despite the career risks involved, while there is nothing on a similar scale on Kurdistan, The Sudan, West Sahara, Iraq, or the Armenian genocide? This is not to reiterate the claim that Israel is being singled out for critique. Maybe it sometimes is, but it has also repeatedly been singled out for unconditional support by powerful political actors. Which is peculiar. More anthropological de-familiarizing of the taken-for-granted importance of this conflict over others would have been interesting.
The centrality of the struggle over “compulsory Zionism” (as the authors call it) in the book also tells of the polarized situation in the US. Anthropology's Politics is welcome proof that a strong countercurrent against imperial interests exists in US academia. The authors give space for the voices and views of anthropologists of different ages, backgrounds and positions. At the same time, they do not shy away from deconstructing arguments and views they see as inconsistent, nor do they hesitate to show their support for what may be called the anti-imperial current in US anthropology and politics. At the heart of the empire, this may be the only stance that does justice to anthropology's commitment to study and take seriously humans on their own terms. And still, reading this book does make me sometimes feel uneasy about the degree of American political and societal polarization of which this book is also an outcome and a part.
Methodologically, the book is stunningly meticulous and carefully substantiated. The authors have spoken with over one hundred US-based MENA anthropologists and other MENA researchers from different generations, and combine these interviews with their professional experience (a participant observation indeed) and extensive archival research. In my own research, I have probably never produced anything even half as well researched—but then I would also not have to worry about politically motivated attacks on my work. This is telling of the asymmetries of the debate. Authors who challenge the compulsory Zionism so common in the US, have a burden of proof that authors making other kinds of arguments do not have. In order to be taken seriously, they must provide methodologically flawless and exceptionally substantial evidence. And Deeb and Winegar do.
