In his latest book, Richard Duncan-Jones investigates the relationship between social rank and career success in Roman society and surveys the social bias of senatorial, equestrian and slave careers. The main thrust of the argument is based on statistical analysis. Overall, Power and Privilege demonstrates the extent to which the imperial government recognised social rank rather than merit in promotions to high-ranking senatorial and equestrian posts. Still, social advancement was possible across generations due to the economic demands of high rank and empire, patronage and the preference for experience over rank in some vital offices.
The monograph falls into three parts of uneven length. The eight chapters of Part I, examining ‘Social Status and Senatorial Success’, are at the core of the argument. Ch. 1 introduces D.-J.’s methodology, data and research question. In order to establish the impact of social rank on the career outcomes of senators, he has assembled an extensive database of 617 senatorial careers from the most junior senatorial post, the office of vigintivir, to the post of urban prefect. In order to allow for statistical analysis of the social polarities of senatorial promotion, D.-J. uses the hierarchy of the vigintiviri as a guide to the senators’ social status (social score) and grades their career outcomes (career scores) according to their last office (a useful overview of the classifications is provided in Appendix 1).
The following four chapters provide the findings of this study. The discussion is very dense. Helpfully, the monograph comes with seventeen figures (charts and graphs) and fifty-eight tables, which illustrate the arguments more concisely. With its focus on the patricians and their promotions, ch. 2 powerfully illuminates the strong relationship between social standing and career success. Its findings suggest that inherited social status, rather than experience or merit, was regarded as a key criterion for appointment and promotion. Ch. 3 reviews the implications for the cursus honorum posts at Rome, ch. 4 for service overseas. The latter contains an interesting discussion about the social biasing of proconsular appointments, while the social characteristics of military posts and the demands of balancing of social rank and military experience are highlighted in ch. 5.
The survival of the senatorial order depended on recruitment from outside Rome; this is reflected in ch. 6, an evaluation of the career successes of provincial senators, their chronology and origin; here, D.-J. highlights some notable patterns in appointment. Chs 7–8 then furnish insights into the chronology and sources of the senatorial data of this study. The material is grouped into three periods (Augustus to Domitian, Nerva to Commodus and Pertinax to Diocletian), each with different characteristics. Then follows an overview of the limitations of D.-J.’s material (selective information and inflated representation in cursus honorum inscriptions) as well as his selection criteria; the discussion concludes by demonstrating the high consistency and stability within this material (well illustrated in table 7.3).
Part II, ‘Equestrian Perspectives’, proceeds to equestrian careers. Two chapters discuss career structures and offices, the advantages of equestrian rank and entry into the Senate. Again, D.-J. demonstrates the importance of social rank for career outcomes. Chs 11–12 then survey literary sources for the economic role of equestrians (in banking, as tax-farmers or conductores) and for the conferment of equestrian rank on freedmen, soldiers and children. They largely resume D.-J.’s 2006 article ‘Who were the equites?’ (Studies in Latin Literature and Roman History 13, 183–223). The two chapters of Part III draw on literary sources to study ‘the Unprivileged’. D.-J. questions the self-reproducing capacity of Roman slavery (ch. 13), while underlining the importance of voluntary servitude (ch. 14). Unfortunately, he does not discuss the relevant recent work of Kyle Harper (e.g. Slavery in the Late Roman World (2011); JRS 98 (2008), 106–16); there is, however, a detailed discussion of eunuchs.
There are seven appendices. Appendix 7 contains D.-J.’s senatorial database; the others offer short explanations of methods, assumptions and sources of the senatorial chapters. Appendix 5 provides a discussion of some notable senatorial careers. The example of the three Caesonii is particularly noteworthy here, as it highlights the possibilities of social advancement across generations as well as the difficulties facing individual senators in their careers (167–9).
On the whole, in particular in his first ten chapters, D.-J. offers food for thought when he highlights social biasing in imperial appointments to high office in what is often considered to have been a meritocratic career system. These are significant findings; unfortunately, the structure of the book (there is no general introduction, and only the chapters come with conclusions) may hamper their accessibility to the non-specialist reader. I found it confusing that while this knowledge was required in the discussion early on, the chronological span and arrangement of the material are explained only in ch. 7. Also, some chapters draw on late antique material (e.g. in the passage on eunuchs, 138–41), while others do not, and it is not clear why. There is one misleading reference: table 3.1 on p. 26 should be table 3.3. Notwithstanding, this is patently an important monograph. It forces us to think hard about the hidden rules of career advancement, the social biasing of imperial appointments and the logic of career choices of the privileged few and the many underprivileged in the Roman Empire.
