Anna Clark's revised version of her Oxford thesis examines Republican Rome's ‘divine qualities’, a slightly unnecessary coinage (designed to remove ‘the pejorative connotation of “abstraction” or “abstract”’ (27)) for what are often called divine personifications. Such gods, with names like Salus or Fides, can be slippery entities. C. attempts to nail the problem by using (rather distracting) small capitals to distinguish divine qualities from the ordinary meaning of the word to which they give concrete form.
The book deals predominantly with the last three centuries B.C., looking at the introduction of divine qualities, the ways in which they were presented at Rome, their topographical impact, their iconography, and (in a particularly engaging discussion) their onstage life, primarily using Plautus (ch. 3). C. sweeps away longstanding assumptions that divine qualities were not ‘proper’ gods, that they were worshipped differently to ‘traditional’ deities like Jupiter or Diana. On the contrary, C. emphasizes, divine qualities were perfectly capable of attracting cult in the ‘normal’ way. Like other gods, they played a key part in the Roman state, and like other gods could have quite different meanings in different contexts. For ordinary folk too they were no mere abstractions. C. is not particularly concerned with the private cult of qualities, but rather ‘qualities that received public cult in Rome’ (vii), yet she shows how these qualities are found in any number of private spheres and easily could have extended her discussion here.
Ch. 4 shows how the foundation of competing cults of divine qualities in the late second and early first centuries B.C. physically reshaped the topography of the Forum and Capitol. This chapter also provides an interesting discussion of numismatic iconography in a period when coins were becoming an ever more important means of getting across messages to a wider public. Throughout her study, C. examines how ideas (and the manipulation of ideas) operated as a factor in defining Roman cultural, social and political identity (see e.g. ch. 6 on libertas). C. has mastered a wide range of evidence, and most of her work is carefully argued from the sources, so it is a pity that she commits the common sin of ascribing to Festus an entry in Paul the Deacon's epitome (59); and had she looked at it she would have noticed that the butchered text does not support her statement that the Aventine temple of Libertas was vowed in 246 B.C. by Sempronius Gracchus. Elsewhere (109, following Skutsch) she quotes Festus in Müller's edition; Lindsay's should be preferred.
C. raises and goes some considerable way towards answering many problems on the subject of divine qualities. Although certain issues will demand further exploration (why the development of interest in them? why was one quality exploited for divinisation, but not another? why were some male, others female?), her book provides an excellent contribution to the recent outpouring of work on Roman religion.
