Tacitus has long been acclaimed the enemy of tyrants. Dylan Sailor puts that reputation to the test, asking what it is that has earned the historian his subversive credentials. He is profoundly sceptical of the claims Tacitus makes for the political significance of his works. The historian's image as a dangerous (and endangered) critic of power is, he argues, an effect of the text — a pose carefully crafted over the course of his literary career. The senator who flourished under six successive emperors was no subversive force and was in no danger from those in power. What Tacitus really feared was not persecution by the regime, but being seen as its creature. Hence his efforts to convince his readers of his autonomy and authenticity. S.'s book is an ambitious intervention in Tacitean studies which is sure to refocus scholarly attention on the historian's self-presentation.
The first chapter seeks to explain Tacitus' works as a predictable product of the prestige culture of the Roman élite. S. sees élite discourse under the Principate as obsessed with autonomy, claiming that independence from the Princeps (epitomized by the outright defiance of the Stoic ‘martyrs’) was the measure of social worth. He insists that Tacitus' historiographical project should be seen as an attempt to construct a literary analogue to the displays of independence and authenticity that earned the ‘martyrs’ their privileged place in the cultural pantheon. But it seems misguided to attempt to explain an oeuvre as idiosyncratic as Tacitus' in terms of social determination. In any case, S.'s sociology of the Roman élite — which is based almost entirely on extrapolations from Tacitus' texts — is unconvincing. It is untenable to claim that success in the cursus honorum could not bring real distinction because it implied the Princeps' favour (24, 34), that ‘writing a history that appeared to have its contents determined by the princeps’ power [i.e. was not overtly subversive of some “official version”] was useless for purposes of gaining literary prestige' (41) or that any historical work that was not proscribed ‘stood in constant, implicit need of apologia for its own existence’ (47, 253). The problem is that S. — elsewhere a critical reader of Tacitus' construction of his own career — has here accepted at face value Tacitus' tendentious perspective on the economy of prestige in his society. There were more paths to success than the historian would like to admit. But we do not have to accept S.'s analysis of élite society in its entirety to see that Tacitus is invested in his image as an alienated critic of the Principate — and that this might be a hard sell given his obvious political success.
The following four chapters trace the development of Tacitus' self-presentation over the course of his historiographical career. Ch. 2, on the Agricola, highlights that work's focus on the circulation of glory in both Rome and Britain. It argues that Tacitus diagnoses a ‘crisis of representation’ in Roman culture — a crisis which has lasted into the Trajanic period despite the best efforts of the new emperors — and ambitiously offers his own work as a solution.
Ch. 3 focuses on the preface to the Histories, analysing how it seeks to persuade the reader that historiography and politics are inextricably linked. Tacitus suggests that it is impossible to write good history under the Principate because political enslavement inevitably provokes a response that is emotional and therefore — regardless of whether it is favourable or hostile to the regime — always pernicious to good historiography. But he also hints that the Histories will be a unique exception, because of its author's ability to stand outside the relations of reciprocity (positive and negative) that have been the ruin of other historians.
Ch. 4, still on the Histories, traverses a wider range of passages, including Otho's two speeches to the Praetorians, the destruction and restoration of the Capitol, and the Jewish War. Although the readings are united by an interest in failures of signification — particularly of the signifying power of the city of Rome — the arguments are more diffuse than in other chapters and less obviously connected to the agenda of the book as a whole. Its most important claim is that Tacitus represents the Principate as entailing the loss of the meaning written into Rome's urban fabric and suggests that this meaning can only be recuperated within the alienated perspective provided by his own text.
Ch. 5 on Ann. 4.32–8 (the ‘second preface’, the prosecution of Cremutius Cordus and Tiberius' speech on the rejection of divine honours) is a return to strength. S. argues that this programmatic triptych plays a pivotal rôle in giving the work the ‘impression of political consequence’ and its ‘status as an endangered book’. He makes much of Tacitus' failure to articulate the precise utility of historiography under the Principate (4.33.2), suggesting that this hints that the real purpose of the work is unspeakable, and so makes it appear far more politically significant and dangerous to its author than it can ever have been. He also argues that Tacitus has both exaggerated the significance of Cremutius' historical works for his downfall and given Cremutius a surprisingly guarded (and so Tacitean) final speech in order to make him paradigmatic of the dangers of historical writing. He presses readers not to take these intimations of the regime's hostility at face value, but rather to see them as a rhetorical device by which the successful senator seeks to create an impression of political independence.
This is a long book. Its 300-odd pages offer many interesting and often provocative readings of foundational passages with which every reader of Tacitus must grapple. Yet this reader could not help feeling that it would have been even stronger had it focused more narrowly on the ‘alienation effect’, for that is where its real pay-off lies. This book will make all readers of Tacitus look more closely — and more critically — at the strategies by which the historian constructs himself as a subversive critic of power.
