John Nurser has been preoccupied for some four decades with the history, theory and practice of human rights since he first undertook and then published his doctoral thesis on Lord Acton. This concern found further expression in the author's founding and leadership of the organisation ‘Christianity and the Future of Europe’. In For All Peoples and All Nations Canon Nurser explores through meticulously conducted research the neglected, indeed the largely elided, role of Christian thinkers and activists in the development of human rights and their adoption into international law and global awareness. Nurser's goal is ‘to explore the contribution of the World Council of Churches to the establishment of a “global order” in the United Nations Organization that would give new authority to human rights’ (p. xiii). Needless to say, when now seen in the shadow of recent events, this project has gained a contemporary importance not, perhaps, foreseen when the author first set out on this task.
Those who have ever sought to analyse and summarise the successive drafting of declaratory statements and the preparatory documents drawn up by churches or international bodies will be aware of how difficult this can be, and that the published outcome will as like as not be virtually unreadable. John Nurser has therefore wisely chosen to focus his account around the life and contribution of a key individual, the American Lutheran educationalist Otto Frederick Nolde, whose role as international and inter-institutional mediator was decisive. This central figure is, however, set in a clearly expounded historical framework that traces the not unproblematic concept of ‘Christendom’ from its traditional and revised notions through to the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. Thus chapter 1 shows how a notion peculiar to its European context was universalised in the thought of such figures as J. H. Oldham and given a global remit as ‘world order’. The use of such terms as ‘New World Order’ by President George W. Bush resonates with this usage, albeit with differing intentions. In chapter 2, the author turns to O. Frederick Nolde, showing how a figure who exercised such quasi-diplomatic influence was the product of an American German Lutheran confessional background that gradually opened and liberalised its perspectives. Above all, Nolde was able to pursue an aggorniomento grounded in the revision of the theory and practice of Christian education rather than in church ministry or theological training. Nolde's career as agent in the development and adoption of human rights was underpinned by the support of his alma mater and later employer, the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia (LTSP) that permitted him extensive periods of secondment.
In part two, Nurser expounds in exhaustive detail the determination of church leaders, in the United States and the United Kingdom and European figures not assimilated into the Axis powers, to think out and prepare the ground for the implementation of a just and durable peace. The author has structured his book in eleven relatively short and topically focused chapters that explore and expound, in both wide perspective and intimate detail, the history of the discussions that first began after the First World War, and that then, during the Second World War, gained in urgency and intensity. It is unlikely that this account will be superseded in the foreseeable future. Canon Nurser has interviewed survivors and their close family members but, above all, it is his unremitting labour in the relevant archives in Australia, the United States and Geneva, besides the major research libraries, that leaves an indelible impression on the reader's mind. This is meticulous historical research of a high order. Each chapter of For All Peoples and All Nations is supported by copious notes, and it is to the credit of the publishers that the evidence base has been retained. A further service is provided by a twenty-page appendix which contains the texts of the major sources cited. The outcome is an indispensable resource for all those concerned with twentieth-century attempts by the Christian churches to respond in a positive yet critical way to global political crisis and the clash of ideologies.
Canon Nurser's findings may well be open to further stages of interpretation. Thus, whilst it is significant that the churches were capable of sustained critical reflection upon the political crises of Depression, the rise of the Third Reich and of Communism, and the Second World War in the context of imperial rivalry, this would not yet appear to be the case in the first decade of the twenty-first century and its ‘War on Terror’. Why should there now be a relative silence? Careful critical examination of the argument of For All Peoples and All Nations might help the reader begin to articulate and to answer such pressing contemporary questions.
