In her book In the Wake of Medea: Neoclassical Theater and the Arts of Destruction, Juliette Cherbuliez sets out to constitute violence as central to the neoclassical French theatre, in contrast to the common rhetoric that touts a lack of violence as one of French neoclassicism's most distinctive characteristics. Cherbuliez doesn't mean just any violence, though—she defines an invented subtype of violence that she christens “Medean violence” after the figure of Medea, whose status as the eponymous heroine of the play considered to mark the beginning of French neoclassicism (Corneille's 1634 Médée) justifies this special regard. Medean violence in Cherbuliez's work refers to violence that originates outside the social order, and is unintelligible to and therefore unassimilable by it, but also constitutes that social order by defining what is outside or beyond it. Most contentiously, Medean violence can never be eradicated. “Tragedy's role,” Cherbuliez suggests in her Introduction, “might not be to evacuate violence but to help us see the impossibility of its leaving us” (8).
Despite setting herself the paradoxical task of proving an impossibility, Cherbuliez makes the majority of this case very well; her careful attention to the central role that violence plays in neoclassical French tragedy—even as it is banished from the stage and relegated to description, the common reason for viewing it as peripheral—is well supported and quite convincing. Her establishment of Medea's violence as connected with her foreignness and therefore constitutive of the social order is likewise well proved. Her notions regarding the impossibility of violence's elimination, predicated as they are on knowing the whole of the future, are really more artistic and rhetorical flourishes than provable claims, and thus need not be considered when assessing the strength of her central argument. The problem, however, is that Cherbuliez manages to prove all of this, which is supposedly the central project of her book, within the Introduction and first chapter, leaving her primary argument with nowhere to go throughout the rest of the volume.
Indeed, the chapters that follow (which, Cherbuliez states in her Introduction, may be read in any order) treat other themes that, although insightful, often have very little to do with Medean violence as she has established it. The connections to this central theme are both slight and strained, often inadequately proved, and have the feel of an afterthought. In Chapter 4, “Flying toward Futurity: Spectacularity and Suspension,” which offers the most important contribution to the study of neoclassical theatre writ large, Cherbuliez makes a brilliant argument tying together early modern (or premodern, as she calls the period in question) notions of historical temporality with the mechanical practices of staging machine plays that gives striking insight into neoclassical cosmologies and their onstage representation. Medean violence appears nowhere in this chapter; in fact, violence of any sort is barely present, and Cherbuliez is able to loop this supposedly central theme into the chapter only by noting the conspicuousness of its absence: “the words of the gods . . . [are] misleadingly silent . . . in their elision of Médée's habit of regicide” (173). Instead of an exploration of Medean violence, this chapter offers a cogent and revelatory exploration of the mutually constitutive relationship of representation and culture, thoroughly grounded in the worldviews of seventeenth-century France.
This chapter is just one representative example of the work that Cherbuliez does in this book: it is good, insightful, and important, but fundamentally unlinked. The impression In the Wake of Medea leaves is of a neoclassical scholar with many contributions to make to this area of study, but not of a unified monograph. The central through line feels more like an attempt to shoehorn the author's numerous ideas into some semblance of a standalone book than an overarching idea expressed through each of the examined case studies. It is hard to come away from this book without thinking that, in this case, the scholarly tendency to award increased preference and prestige to monographs over journal articles or contributions to edited volumes has done this author a disservice.
Each of the chapters in this book has something unique and original to contribute, but that contribution may or may not be best advertised by being lumped under the umbrella of “Medea” or “Arts of Destruction.” For the scholar of neoclassicism, the entire book is worth acquiring, albeit for different reasons in each chapter. For the scholar of Medea, several chapters—but not all—will offer insight: the Introduction alongside the first, second, and fourth chapters. Those who are interested in scholarly explorations of violence will likewise find everything except Chapters 2 and 4 useful. Most important, though, scholars of topics not referenced in the title or blurb will find their subjects explored at length in a single chapter: ekphrasis and intertextuality underscore problems of periodization in Chapter 2; the figure of Hercules and theories of stage presence are explored in the third chapter; neoclassical scene design and machine plays interweave with culturally specific approaches to temporality in the fourth; the fifth treats Racine's Athalie alongside the linguistic evolution of the term “catastrophe”; and a certain performative acceptance of the early modern notion of a unified historical plane, embraced throughout the book, comes through especially clearly in Chapters 2 and 4.
In short, the book has a wider audience than that for which its publication format gives it credit, and potential readers should not take the promises of that format at face value. As long as you go in knowing what to expect, In the Wake of Medea offers highly insightful selective reading.
