This book proposes an intellectual, spiritual, and political history of eastern Turkistan in the 16th through 18th centuries. It is dedicated to a little-studied topic: the Afaqiyya, one of the branches of the Naqshbandi Sufi brotherhood, present mainly in Yarkand and Kashgar. The author used very rare 16th- and17th-century sources written in Chagatai, Farsi, and Uighur, especially some handwritten chronicles and hagiographies. Alexandre Papas, who has mastered several obscure languages, has an excellent knowledge of Orientalist works on this topic, especially those written in the 19th and early 20th centuries in Russian and in Western languages. He has also utilized other documents translated from Japanese and Chinese.
His research starts from an internalist principle: it explains the historic events according to dynamics specific to Central Asia, thanks to a precise analysis of the Sufi texts. It does not treat them as an outgrowth of some more general developments of Islam in modern times such as Islamic revivalism. Yet the author acknowledges that political and spiritual development in eastern Turkistan is inextricably linked to the region's frontier location. The book also demonstrates the interest that a better knowledge of this area, located at the periphery of the Muslim world, can raise. Turkistan, which neighbors several non-Muslim political centers and is viewed as a Muslim enclave, offers a case of the elaboration of a “sacred” legitimacy. The complex regional context is brought well to light: the Sufi brotherhoods of eastern Turkistan, which were under the Mongols' official suzerainty, had to find their place among Jungars, Mongols, Tibetans, and Chinese and were influenced by Lamaic Buddhism and Muslim India. Moreover, the author enriches his thought on the mystic phenomenon by comparing his sources with Christian medieval hagiographies and by mentioning the case of Shamil's imamat in the 19th-century Caucasus.
Papas advocates the thesis of the existence of an “ishanate,” a term he uses to define the political–spiritual institution created in the area between 1600 and 1760 by the Afaqiyya, also known as the “White Mountain Khwajas.” He defines the ishanate as a compromise regime between the caliphate and the secular sovereignty (sultanate or khanate), a form of utopist theocracy inspired by Sufi principles. Through analyzing local manuscripts, he demonstrates how this political project was elaborated and how two Naqshbandi branches gained influence and eventually seized power. He also defines the little-known historic moments between 1580, when the famous figure of this group, Afaq Khwaja, came to Yarkand, and 1754–59, when the Manchu dynasty Qing took possession of Turkistan. Papas emphasizes this exceptional historic moment when the saint held the temporal power; he underscores the importance, in Islamic thought, of the interaction between the exercise of power and religious legitimacy.
Papas then analyzes how a method he describes as utopian or even revolutionary was developed in order to seize and exercise power. The book aptly demonstrates the existence of a state ruled by Sufi masters and the importance of the political decisions inspired by brotherhood logic. By highlighting how a brotherhood can become the basis for state building, Papas also raises the question of the strong political character of the cult of saints. He reminds readers of the relevance of Genghis Khan's dynastic model in order to better understand the family and hereditary holiness in force in eastern Turkistan during the period covered in his study. He also analyzes the mutations of Sufi doctrine, which, once in power, became a mystical religion for the masses. Finally, he endorses the thesis that the history of mystic movements is also the history of their sociability: Sufi mysticism was also practiced by men who were not hermits and who took part in the social realities of the time, which is clearly demonstrated in this book.
This book is a valuable contribution to our knowledge of Central Asia, and especially of eastern Turkistan, which remains little known. It proposes an original and innovative reflection on Sufi mysticism and its ambiguous relation to political power. Thanks to the author's mastery of rare languages as well as his familiarity with manuscripts and the field as a whole, the book is an important contribution to new research on Islam and Sufism in particular.
