Rosemary Malague's An Actress Prepares: Women and “the Method” delivers a feminist analysis of the Method by examining the representative work of Lee Strasberg, Stella Adler, Sanford Meisner, and Uta Hagen. (Malague uses the term without scare quotes, with the notable exception of her title, at times in specific reference to Strasberg's Method and at others as a purposefully “generic label” [16].) Her study, which focuses resolutely on these teachers' practical pedagogies, pursues two aims: to expose the damaging gender biases endemic to the practices that gather under the name of Method acting, and to investigate the potential for recovering elements of Stanislavsky-derived techniques for feminist practice. Despite her strong regard for the Stanislavsky system from which these techniques proceed, Malague does not shrink from investigating those biases and their implications; in pursuit of recuperable elements, she also does the important work of differentiating among these representative techniques, isolating individual liabilities and strengths in strains of realist practice too often considered a monolithic whole. After exploring the ways in which these pedagogies both assume and produce gender difference, often in ways particularly debilitating—sometimes humiliating—to female subjects, Malague nonetheless suggests their potential utility for feminist praxis (197).
Malague accomplishes her analysis largely through a close reading of the four teachers' published texts (most of which recount illustrative classroom experiences), and, in some cases, videos, interviews, and biographies; she occasionally speaks of her own experience teaching or learning various techniques, but her analysis is largely historical. She frames the acting classroom as a particularly compelling (and underinvestigated) site of gender disciplining, a literal “embodiment of Judith Butler's oft-quoted depiction of gender as a ‘stylized repetition of acts’” (8). At times, Malague also touches on Method pedagogies' interaction with queer students, students with disabilities, and nonwhite students, but her focus returns quickly to gender—a category treated as a fairly stable binary. Malague is quick to note that even if “woman” has been revealed as a term inadequate for organizing identity, “as long as acting assignments are broken down into ‘men's roles’ and ‘women's roles,’ women do have a shared set of concerns” (3).
Malague situates her study in the context of existing feminist debates about theatrical practice, sketching canonical arguments that expose the problematics of realism and offering a brief primer on feminist performance strategies, before proceeding to analyze the work of American teachers who based their own theories on Stanislavsky's premises, and then went on to propagate those theories to generations of acting students via their disciples and training institutions. The first of these is Strasberg, whose reputation as a controlling, paternalistic figure Malague rigorously itemizes. Strasberg's own stories of his Method have him consistently encouraging the objectification of his female students—at times literally quieting or restraining them—but Malague's larger concern seems to be the extent to which Strasberg made students unduly dependent on him, both to extract from them “truthful” (and “truthfully” gendered) performances, and to act as sole arbiter of those performances' authenticity. After using Marilyn Monroe's infamous dependence on Strasberg and his wife, Paula, as a cautionary tale, Malague maintains that although some of Strasberg's foundational principles may hold benefit for actors, the paternalistic control so fundamental to his model must be discarded.
Malague characterizes Stella Adler (whose chair, Malague notes, “really did resemble a throne” [156]) as not invulnerable to a similar vanity, but finds much to admire in Adler's insistence on text analysis, research, and intellectual engagement as necessary for the actor, as well as her persistent focus on an actor's difference from her character, rather than an assumed, universalizing sameness (88). Emphasizing Adler's imperative than an actor investigate a character or play's historical, social, and cultural realities, Malague argues that Adler's critical approach “foregrounds the cultural contexts in which women perform the role of ‘woman’” (192). Her claim that Adler's technique “boldly reclaims the role of actor as thinker” (90) holds Adler sharply apart from Strasberg and Meisner, in particular; Malague reserves some of her most pointed criticism for Meisner's indelible demand that intellect and critical faculty not interrupt action that stems from “instinct” (112). Malague notes how consistently, in his own text and video, Meisner pushes male students toward heterosexual desire or angry confrontation and female ones toward objectification, weakness, or shame, remarking that “aggression and hysteria, respectively, are the instinctive responses Meisner cultivates and applauds”; in “his sincere efforts to restore actors to their pure instinct,” Malague argues that Meisner actually seeks “an ‘act,’ a repetition of longstanding social and cultural performances” that students must reproduce to his satisfaction (152).
The dangerous pitfall of student dependence on a gurulike teacher recurs throughout Malague's analysis of the representative Method techniques. The teacher–theorists who best avoid this trap, in Malague's eyes, are Adler and Uta Hagen, whose technique Malague finds the most promising for developing self-reliant actors who can helm their own performances and careers. Malague sees Hagen's consideration of students as potential colleagues—her efforts to “free actors from dependency on teachers”—as resonant with “a number of feminist pedagogical principles” (186). While Malague gives lengthy and detailed attention to the troublesome universalizing and complete identification with character required by Hagen's technique, she asserts that “[a] heightened awareness of gender could be accommodated by and within Hagen's practice—and should be” (187).
The book's last chapter uses Stanislavsky's figure of the “magic if” to propose a reimagination of Method training for women: if it can be recontextualized and repurposed, if elements can be extracted from their matrix and differently used and combined, Malague asserts that such techniques—particularly those of Adler and Hagen, though she isolates elements recuperable from each body of work—have something, even a great deal, to offer a feminist project. Malague's book is a valuable complement to existing feminist scholarship on theatrical realism in part because it focuses so completely and incisively on training; it will have particular resonance for critically engaged teachers and students committed to contending with, rather than renouncing, the problematic legacies of Stanislavsky's American interpreters.
