Aaron Ritzenberg's The Sentimental Touch extends a growing body of criticism that has recast our understanding of American sentimental writing in recent years. In so doing, he joins Julia Stern, Kristin Boudreau and Hildegard Hoeller in broadening our conception of American sentimentalism beyond its traditional formulation as a mid-nineteenth-century domestic genre written by and for women by identifying the tradition across a vast historical, cultural and generic spectrum.Footnote 1 Ritzenberg formulates his argument in tension with theorists of sentimentalism such as Ann Douglas and Lauren Berlant, who contend that sentimental literature disempowered middle-class women by giving them a false sense of agency in a system that actually subjugated them. Following Jane Tompkin's assertion of the social and political work effected by sentimental literature, Ritzenberg offers a critique of these theories. He shifts the debate, however, away from the tired question of sentimentalism's complicity with or subversion of dominant nineteenth-century ideologies by casting the genre's efflorescence as a symptomatic response to economic conditions.Footnote 2
Ritzenberg reads the legacy of literary sentimentalism as a reaction formation against the managerial form of capitalism that achieved hegemony in America between 1850 and 1940. He argues that one of sentimentalism's central tropes – the interpersonal touch that communicates what words cannot – was part of the philosophical underpinnings of the first half of the nineteenth century which persisted in later non-sentimental works as a kind of nostalgic antidote to the increasing atomization of capitalist society. He traces the endurance of the sentimental touch from the height of sentimentalism in Uncle Tom's Cabin through texts by authors such as Mark Twain, Sherwood Anderson and Nathanael West, who self-consciously distance themselves from the sentimental tradition.
Ritzenberg's contribution to American literary history is the attention he brings to the central impact that America's particularly managerial iteration of capitalism had on cultural development. He traces the legacy of the sentimental touch through a sea change in the United States economy which saw the small, family-owned business give way to a new economic dominant as the nineteenth century drew to a close. Businesses were increasingly organized by massive bureaucracies maintained by complex managerial hierarchies. Ritzenberg argues that sentimentalism rose to prominence in the context of the earlier economic model, and that the endurance of its central tropes signals a cultural resistance to the later economic structure.
In Ritzenberg's scheme, sentimentalism's emphasis on manners and the legibility of bodies was a reaction to the new dynamics of the emerging marketplace. Class anxiety over the fact that status was no longer determined solely by birth resulted in the belief that value corresponds, if not to pedigree, then to outward signs and behaviors. The literary trope of the sentimental touch was thus just one of many facets of a culture that wanted to believe in the communicative value of appearances. As the burgeoning marketplace gave rise to vast managerial structures, however, behavior became less legible as the average American's workplace became more impersonal. As Ritzenberg puts it, “If the sentimental body was transparent, legible, and intimate, the managerial body is opaque, mysterious, and unlocatable” (7). With this development, the sentimental touch fades from literature as a hermeneutics of suspicion takes root first in realist and later in modernist literature. Ritzenberg's point, though, is that the sentimental touch doesn't disappear altogether. Instead, it persists as “a marker of intimate human contact” that “represents a literary desire to resist a cultural change in which human closeness gives way to corporate organization” (7).
Max Weber, Adam Smith and Karl Marx undergird Ritzenberg's understanding of the interaction between economic developments and cultural forms. For these theorists, he notes, “changes in the organization of capitalism signaled not just economic change, but changes in social relations” (5). Ritzenberg's attention to the ways that shifting American social relations produced new literary forms and tropes manifests itself in provocative close readings that interrogate the relationship between history and culture. Cultural forms are not treated like self-conscious reactions to historical developments here – instead, Ritzenberg performs a kind of immanent critique that acknowledges the way culture is both embedded in and reacts to its socioeconomic moment.
Each of the four chapters of The Sentimental Touch gestures toward broad generic characteristics while focussing on a single representative text. The first chapter, on Uncle Tom's Cabin, clarifies the central features of sentimental literature, stressing the interlocking relationships between the legible body and the silent touch. He argues that the trope of the legible body and its sentimental touch is central to the text's politics because Stowe uses it as a counterforce to “the illegibility of the slave body – the body that, even when it appears white, is treated black” (19). Stowe thus mobilizes the conventions of sentimental literature to depict the institution of slavery as a perverse system that disrupts what was then seen as the natural structure of signification in American society.
In the remaining chapters, Ritzenberg identifies moments of unironic sentimentality in three texts that self-consciously distance themselves from the sentimental tradition: Huckleberry Finn, Winesburg, Ohio and Miss Lonelyhearts. He characterizes the raft in Huckleberry Finn as a bastion of domestic sentimentality continuously disrupted by the managerial world that surrounds it. Ritzenburg suggests that, Twain's critique of faux sentimentality notwithstanding, the silent moments of sympathy between Huck and Jim and the raft's meandering progress down the river constitute a sentimental resistance to a society increasingly obsessed with the management of time and the mechanization of social relations. Chapter 3 focusses on Winesburg, Ohio and argues that despite its criticism of sentimentality, it is a text centrally concerned with “touching” the reader, and does so through characters who touch each other. So despite the fact that the world in Winesburg, Ohio is one in which sentimental markers have ceased to operate – where tears are alienating or manipulative and sentimental touching can be read as sexual perversion – in the penultimate chapter, George and Helen come together with a silent touch.
The last chapter looks at Miss Lonelyhearts, a text that, unlike Huckleberry Finn and Winesburg, Ohio, doesn't outwardly criticize sentimentality as morally dubious. This is because it is set in a world so thoroughly affected by managerialism that it has cast off its moral sense entirely. And unlike the earlier texts, the sentimental touch ultimately fails here so that while Miss Lonelyhearts and Peter Doyle do share a sentimental touch, it degenerates into violence in the very next episode. Yet the sentimental touch retains its status as a symbol of resistance here for Ritzenberg because it is the only human moment in what he sees as an otherwise completely alienated text.
The Sentimental Touch makes a great contribution to American literary criticism concerned with sentimental writing. Its novel attention to the legacy as opposed to the roots of sentimentality enriches the field with a new perspective while also illuminating the connections between the Scottish moral sense philosophers and the underlying commitments of the sentimental worldview. The only shortcoming of the work is that Ritzenberg points to an intriguing aspect of sentimental literature that it neglects to fully explore – the fact that, while it was used to resist mechanized, managerial culture, it did so by making use of the literary conventions of sentimentality that themselves treat literature and our emotions as mechanized processes. This contention bears further development and clarification: does it constitute a theory of reading? A formal argument about narrative and affect? A critique of the political work of which sentimentalism is capable? These unanswered questions suggest further work to be done in the broad arena carved out by this impressive book.
