Although not strictly a scholarly, academic book, this is a generally well-written, informative account for the educated French reader of a seminal moment in modern Jewish history when, for the first time, emancipated Jews in Western Europe laid the foundations not only of modern Jewish philanthropy, as is indicated in the title of the book, but concomitantly and no less importantly, modern international Jewish solidarity. It focuses on the role played by six individuals, three of whom—Sir Moses Montefiore, James de Rothschild, and Adolphe Crémieux—were the founding fathers of Jewish philanthropic activism and three of whom—Salomon Munk, Louis Loewe, and Albert Cohn—were their erudite agents, advisors, and Orientalist guides to the Muslim world.
The event that united three wealthy Jewish notables with three penniless young immigrant scholars in what Şeni dubs “an improbable undertaking” was the Damascus affair of 1840, when members of the Jewish community of that city were accused of having murdered an Italian Capuchin friar, Father Thomas, and his native assistant to use their blood for ritual purposes. (This famous blood libel, alas, is still given credence in many quarters of the contemporary Arab world and is even the subject of a best-selling book, Fatir Sihyun, by former Syrian defense minister Mustafa Tlas.) In the first chapter, Şeni provides a brief sketch of the interplay of personalities of Crémieux, Montifiore, and Rothschild in the period leading up to the mission on behalf of the Damascene Jews, based primarily on the very thorough work of Jonathan Frankel, The Damascus Affair: Ritual Murder, Politics and the Jews in 1840 (Cambridge University Press, 1997). Her second, longer chapter offers biographical sketches of the young Orientalists, who in her words were “in search of destiny.” This and the following chapter, which deals mostly with Munk's early years in Paris, comprise a much more original contribution. Based upon letters, diaries, and the few biographies published mainly in the 19th century, she provides insightful comparisons and points to the important role of German-speaking Jewish academics in France. Şeni's biographical sketches of the three young scholars and some of their contemporaries offer a salutary corrective to Said's sweeping characterization of Orientalism that conflates the romantic and imperialistic with the academic. Scholarship for scholarship's sake was their ideal. Documents and libraries were their passion, not travel to exotic places. The critique of Said that runs implicitly throughout this chapter is summed up explicitly in the final paragraph.
Şeni devotes considerable space to distinguishing between the new 19th-century “philanthropy” and the older “charity.” She rightly connects the newer form of do-gooding with then current notions of humanitarian action and the duty of intervention, and she devotes much of Chapter 4 to an excursus on the Camondos of Istanbul, who were then known as “the Rothschilds of the East” and about whom she has coauthored with S. Le Tarnec a family history (Les Camondo: L'éclipse d'une fortune, Actes Sud, 1997). In this lengthy aside, Şeni compares the Camondos with Ottoman Greek philanthropists of the day, as well as with the philanthropic endeavors of Sultan Abdülhamit. She also goes into an extended discussion for the sake of comparison and philosophical clarity of humanitarianism in the second half of the 20th century in a discussion that ranges from Biafra to Doctors without Borders.
Şeni notes that although the Jewish philanthropists held generalized humanitarian views (and this holds most truly for Crémieux), they nevertheless focused most of their philanthropic efforts upon their co-religionists; their efforts, like those of the Greek neo-Hellenists, therefore had a national character. She tries to cast a broad theoretic framework in this chapter but lacks historical contextualization. Her distinction between the newer “philanthropy” and the older “charity” is actually that of Jewish sedaqa in its highest form as defined by Maimonides in the late 12th century. Furthermore, traditional Islamic waqf and Jewish heqdesh had more in common with some of the institutions of 19th-century philanthropy than she implies. Neither is it certain that Greek philanthropy “is much older than the Jewish.”
The final three chapters return to each of the philanthropists sketched in Chapter 1 and describe the particular trajectories of their philanthropic interests and activities. As with the first chapter, these final chapters and the epilogue cover little or no new ground, although they do highlight striking differences of personalities and rivalries that in no small measure reflected Anglo–French competition.
Like many other works of French “haute vulgarization,” this book is filled with piquant anecdotes and richly textured descriptive detail that makes enjoyable reading. Even the many excurses away from the six protagonists (e.g., the careers of other Jewish Orientalists, the lengthy section on Camondo, and the philanthropists of Istanbul) and the origins of modern Jewish philanthropy (e.g., her meditations on the possible connection between 19th-century actions and modern humanitarian interventions) are engagingly written and make for leisurely, if somewhat helter-skelter, reading. The author, by the way, is both an academic and documentary filmmaker; perhaps this explains the back and forth nature of the vignettes that constitute the book.
