Kurt Weill, Moss Hart, Gertrude Lawrence, Ira Gershwin, Sam H. Harris, Albertina Rasch, Danny Kaye. What a dinner party! In the months prior to 23 January 1941, just such a dinner would have been possible as these theatrical greats engaged in the creation of a landmark Broadway musical, Lady in the Dark. The dinner parties could have continued with frequency until mid-1943 when this unique show, an unprecedented musical exploration of Freudian psychoanalysis and the dilemmas of women in the workplace, closed after an impressive 550 performances. There is little doubt that Lady in the Dark sped the progression of American musical theatre not only by furthering the integration of song, dance, character, and theme, but also by reflecting the deep and continued influence of European thought on this most American of theatrical genres. Weill was German, Lawrence British, Gershwin, Hart, Harris, Rasch, and Kaye all were of recent European Jewish heritage—“American musical,” it seems, was and is something of a misnomer, yet Lady in the Dark is quintessentially, undeniably American. It also serves as a reminder of the theatrical melting pot and what “immigrants” contribute to culture and, more important, to revealing what being “American” means.
In that spirit, Bruce D. McClung's “Lady in the Dark”: Biography of a Musical argues in eight well-organized chapters (and a brief Prologue and Epilogue) that in its original production this musical was “controversial and its form revolutionary” (xv). In addressing such “timely issues as the role of women in the workplace, the validity of psychoanalysis, and the problem of delayed marriage,” the show's culturally diverse creators demonstrated “how vividly social history can be read through the lens of the American musical theater” (xvii). Personal history comes into play too, not only in the experiences of the musical's central character, brittle and sophisticated magazine editor Liza Elliott, but also in librettist Moss Hart's own experiences with Freudian psychoanalysis, which inspired the show's creation. Beginning with Eugene O'Neill's emergence in the 1910s, nonmusical American drama was profoundly influenced by Freud's theories, but Lady in the Dark was the first musical to delve into that realm centrally, establishing a theatrical vocabulary for using song and dance to reveal the subconscious motivations of characters. Rodgers and Hammerstein's “Dream Ballet” in Oklahoma! (1943), staged two years after the premiere of Lady in the Dark, underscores the far-reaching impact of the Weill–Gershwin–Hart musical in expanding structural options and deepening the revelation of character.
In “Genesis,” McClung's most engaging chapter, he turns to early 1930s America to trace the lives and separate creative paths of Lady in the Dark's creators. In the process, he reveals not only the events that brought them together for this particular project, but also their individual struggles to negotiate professional obstacles posed by the Great Depression, as well as their “outsider” status as “immigrants” and the frequently conflicting demands of Broadway and Hollywood. Other chapters explore Weill's score, Gershwin's lyrics, and Hart's libretto in depth, the show's turbulent out-of-town tryout, the ultimate triumph of its opening night and Broadway run, the subsequent national tour, and the rare revivals (including the execrable 1944 Paramount film version, as well as radio, television, and studio productions). In a particularly well-constructed chapter, “Cultural Context,” McClung explores the complex societal issues roiling America at the time of the show's creation, all of which served to make Lady in the Dark “unrepeatable” (166), a reflection of an extraordinary “cultural shift” (143) as Depression-era values receded and the cataclysm of World War II forever changed American society.
McClung establishes a template for future single show “biographies” and, at the same time, provides a pleasurable read for theatre lovers. Brushing aside scholarly questions regarding the seriousness of musical theatre (which he rightly takes for granted), McClung reveals the inner workings of a complex and innovative musical, while never neglecting its legacy in the history and evolution of the form. The book also provides an amusing portrayal of backstage Broadway circa 1941 and the idiosyncratic geniuses who populated it. The show's original creative team and stars are presented warts and all: egos clash, demands are made, changes are fought over, ruffled feathers are smoothed, and the show progresses along its often bumpy road to theatrical legend. Other extraordinary personalities enter McClung's detail-studded narrative, including Ginger Rogers battling with director Mitchell Leisen during the making of the lavish film version that, inexplicably, dropped much of the Weill–Gershwin score, and Judy Garland appearing memorably in a 1950s radio adaptation. Lawrence's performance is similarly preserved in an abbreviated radio version, as is Ann Sothern's in a 1954 color television adaptation, opera great Risë Stevens's in a 1963 studio cast album, Julie Andrews's in the 1968 Lawrence screen biography (Star!, featuring an extended sequence from Lady in the Dark), Angela Lansbury's in a 1969 concert version, and Maria Friedman's in a 1998 Royal National Theatre of Great Britain cast recording. Despite such luminous ladies recreating Liza Elliott, Lady in the Dark has never been given a Broadway revival and is otherwise rarely performed. McClung makes a compelling argument that social norms, particularly those regarding psychoanalysis and the dilemmas facing professional women central to this musical, changed so significantly and so rapidly during the war years that by the time Lady in the Dark ended its national tour this cutting-edge work suddenly seemed quaintly dated, a poignant reminder of the ephemeral nature of theatre and the vast changes in American life between the Depression and the end of World War II.
McClung's text is supported by fifty black-and-white illustrations including production stills, designs, press coverage, and glimpses of Weill's score, as well as copious notes, a select bibliography helpfully divided into categories focusing on the show's creators, and a discography. There is even a brief Epilogue in which McClung imagines a dreamlike chance meeting with Gertrude Lawrence on a train platform. Although one might prefer the aforementioned imaginary dinner party with all of the show's creators, McClung's entertaining study is the next best thing.
