Political scientists have long viewed urban America as a site to explore fundamental questions of political power, democratic governance, and equity. Robert Dahl's Who Governs? (1961) is an exemplar of this approach in its contention that no one set of elites or political groups dominated New Haven politics, and thus its political system was widely permeable. Although Dahl later recanted his initial conclusion that politically “there is no discrimination against the Negro” (p. 295) in New Haven politics, it provoked generations of urbanists to challenge his pluralist presumption of race neutrality. In this vein, Leland Saito's The Politics of Exclusion deepens our understanding of how the city is a politically contested and racialized site of public policy, especially in cities like San Diego, New York, and Los Angeles.
Saito explores “how individuals and groups supporting race-neutral policies may in fact be contributing to policies that have racialized outcomes” (p. 4). As a sociologist and ethnic studies scholar, he analyzes a series of economic and political outcomes that demonstrate the fallacy of assuming that state-sanctioned racial discrimination has greatly lessened over time because it is an aberration of American democratic values. Instead, he joins scholars of the “systemic racism” approach to the study of race and public policy outcomes whereby [s]ystemic racism is not some unfortunate appendage to society that is largely eliminated. Racial oppression persists as foundational and integral to society in the present day” (Joe R. Feagin, as quoted by Saito, p. 4.) Saito's comparative racialization framework challenges two key assumptions: 1) the “model minority myth,” which assumes that the economic prosperity of some Asian Americans is proof that racial minorities with strong work and educational ethics can overcome barriers to opportunity, and 2) that whites are the constituent group who are most likely to be race neutral because they, unlike racial and ethnic minorities, are the least likely to presume that race always matters (pp. 10–2; 15–9).
The author spent more than a dozen years gathering and analyzing rich in-person interviews, participant-observation data, archival materials, planning documents, and a wide array of other references for his three cases involving economic and political outcomes. In the San Diego cases of Chapters 2 and 3 (pp. 32–98), he compares and contrasts how in the 1980s and 1990s, historic preservation advocates within the Chinese American and African American communities learned lessons that led to the respective establishment of the downtown Asian Pacific Thematic Historic District, as centered around the Chinese Mission building on Third Avenue and J Street, and the African American Historic District, as centered around the Clermont/Coast Hotel near Seventh Avenue and Island Avenue. The preservation coalitions of the Chinese Historical Society of Greater San Diego and Baja California, as well as the Gaslamp Black Historical Society, respectively, waged battles for the city's growth machine not to be “color-blind” or, rather, not to whitewash its historic preservation plans. Advocates succeeded in having the urban regime recognize the ethnic/racial heritages of each group and how each greatly complemented the San Diego Centre City Development Corporation's efforts to revitalize the tourist appeal of old downtown San Diego. But, Saito concludes, “the historic preservation was more likely to occur when it fitted the needs of the growth machine” (p. 65).
In Chapters 4 and 5 (pp. 99–157), Saito discusses New York voting rights advocates as they challenged color-blind presumptions of how to draw electoral districts that guarantee the descriptive and substantive representation of Asian American voters. The advocacy groups of Asian Americans for Equality and the Lower East Siders for a Multi-Racial District, despite their differences, agreed that historic Chinatown should not be divided into separate districts but, instead, remain intact as it was represented at the municipal, state, and federal (congressional) levels. However, the Districting Commission used color-blind assumptions, and instead of creating multiminority districts that joined Chinatown with Latino and African American neighborhoods, it combined Chinatown with predominantly white neighborhoods. The “race-neutral” willingness of whites to elect Asian Americans to Democratic Party posts did not materialize when it came to electing Asian American candidates (i.e., Margaret Chin or Fred Cheng) to higher office. When the court-ordered Charter Revision Commission was charged in the 1980s and early 1990s with ensuring the descriptive representation of Asian Americans on the City Council, as well as on other municipal bodies, the same color-blind logic did not hold but only exacerbated the divisions in the Asian American community (i.e., the lack of a unity candidate), while reinforcing the model minority myth.
In Chapter 6 (pp. 158–88), Saito turns to the San Gabriel Valley of Los Angeles and discusses redistricting battles that demonstrated “cooperation rather than conflict” (p. 158) among Asian American, Latino, and African American Civil Rights organizations. Changing population dynamics in the state of California gave minority communities differing incentives for multiracial coalition building versus ethnic solidarity—but Latinos, for all of the diversity, were clearly the largest ethnic minority. A fascinating division emerged in the drawing of this area's 31st Congressional District and the 49th State Assembly District. On the one hand, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund charged that the post-2000 redistricting plan drew lines that diluted the growing Latino vote. On the other, several Latino elected officials, as well as Asian American and black Civil Rights groups, asserted that the proposed district “went beyond race.” While the district was still predominantly Latino, it included significant numbers of Asian American and African American voters who elected some non-Latino officials (i.e., Congressman Howard Berman and Assemblywoman Judy Chu), but who had clearly advocated on behalf of Latino interests (pp. 184–5.) The author concludes that this was not a case where race did not matter, but rather ethnic/racial interests were only part of a larger progressive agenda.
In The Politics of Exclusion, Saito selects and expertly examines substantively rich cases where it is clear (after we grasp the complex details) that color blindness is ill-equipped to explain when, why, and how race matters, especially when minority advocates disagree. In that regard, he clearly goes beyond the old black–white racial paradigm and adheres to a nuanced “comparative racialization” approach that reveals the increasingly intricate policy interests of communities of color. He provides us with examples of both conflict and cooperation and, from a policy standpoint, adds to our substantive understanding of various outcomes when we literally draw racial or ethnic boundaries.
I wish, however, that Saito had been a bit more sociological and used his cases to better theorize the factors—for example, the when, why, and how conditions—under which we might expect race-neutral policy formulations to succeed and not succeed in fracturing effective multiracial coalitions. In his concluding chapter, he nicely extends his findings to the deracialized campaigns of Asian American and Latino candidates and refutes the myths of the model minority and white neutrality. I am just not fully certain of how to generalize his findings except to cases with similarly complex dynamics. Nevertheless, I strongly commend Saito for providing us with such rich case studies and conceptual insights, for his fascinating propositions greatly enable our theory building.
