The first of two book-length studies emerging from the ‘In Place of War’ research project at Manchester University, Performance Affects seeks to remedy the widely held perception that contemporary theatre and performance in conflict zones ought to be understood primarily in terms of the effects it has on community development or social change. Rather than denying the importance of impact, the study proposes an ‘affective turn’ (p. 118) in applied theatre practice and research, by which Thompson means paying more attention to the experiential, non-conceptual, non-hermeneutic, sensory, emotional and, in its broadest sense, aesthetic realms, alliances and transactions. The strength of the study stems from the sensitive, insightful and extremely self-reflexive observations from Thompson's work as a practitioner and participant in applied theatre projects in Sri Lanka and Rwanda. It is in these sections of the book that the author develops and demonstrates how the emphasis on affect rather than effect implies a methodological shift.
Documenting his own experiences as a theatre facilitator in a refugee camp in Sri Lanka, Thompson traces a fine web of interrelations and links between the involvement of external agencies in a seemingly local theatre project and the public ramifications and discourses of the war. In a passionately argued chapter on theories of trauma and storytelling, the author problematizes the too easy use of trauma as a paradigm for dealing with peoples' stories and narratives, thus implicitly assuming that telling stories must be a precondition for ‘healing’ or ‘relief’, whilst ignoring the culturally specific modes of coping. In the third chapter, national and alternative memorial sites of the genocide in Rwanda are investigated as places of performing and physically experiencing or evoking the painful history of the country. Thompson weaves together an analysis of theatre practices with observations on songs sung by prisoners, casual remarks in conversations with tourist guides, or placards on official museum walls.
His study is theoretically eclectic, and yet refreshingly non-presumptuous, assessing ideas from contemporary philosophers such as Levinas, de Certeau, Rancière, Deleuze, Gumbrecht, Ehrenreich and Butler with close reference to what the author considers valuable in discussing pertinent issues. At the same time, he challenges contemporary theatre and performance studies scholarship, be it in his reference, also in the book title, to Phelan and Lane's 1997 Ends of Performance (pp. 5–6) or in a critical reading of Schechner's braid of entertainment and efficacy (pp. 129–30). Thompson makes a consistent, sincere and timely argument. While the study has not in fact established a fully fledged vocabulary and set of tools for third parties to affectively and effectively understand and practise theatre in war-torn societies, it is an important first step in this direction.
