For a few centuries now Muslim thinkers have been trying to make sense of how their traditional theologies square with the temper of modernity. The rise of science, technology and newer cosmological understandings of human origins have been especially challenging to traditional theology. Often such weighty matters are addressed in ad hoc fashion, with discussions veering from crude apologetics to forms of scientific reductionism that erase any meaningful place for theology. Nidhal Guessoum, an astrophysicist who cares deeply how we make sense of the modern cosmological features of life, ventures into a fairly polarized field in his audacious and appropriately titled book Islam's Quantum Question.
In the first part of the volume, the author reviews numerous examples of past and contemporary Muslim approaches to science. In Part Two, he provides us with readings as to how science and theology can possibly cohere in an Islamic key. Part Three offers proposals for how Muslims, in their encounter with modern science, can navigate the theological rapids within contemporary Muslim cultures. Well written, at times even entertaining, the outcome is a work that tries to construct a bridge between science and modern sociobiology, with hints at possible future pathways for a Muslim theology determined to engage with scientific developments.
Historians of Islamic science frequently dwell on the tension between medieval Muslim theologians and their philosopher adversaries to highlight the challenges of a reconciliation between science and religion. As exhibit number one, they present the challenge posed by the twelfth-century al-Ghazali, a critical admirer of philosophy as well as a strong advocate of Ash‛ari theology. The thirteenth-century Ibn Rushd (Averroës) defended the Hellenized Muslim philosophers against Ghazali's biting criticism. Guessoum, in part, follows this narrative with Averroës as his favourite. But here is the crucial difference between the medieval theology-versus-philosophy controversy and the way science and religion are entangled in the modern period. Medievalists in thrall to philosophy or theology espoused world views that overlapped considerably. Even though the medieval world picture dealt with the facts of nature, their principal interest was nevertheless in symbolic meanings. Even Muslim philosophers imagined Aristotle’s Ladder of Nature as a hierarchy, which turned a continuous scale of being into a chain of command. And these perceptions of nature were clearly speculative, not empirical.
Today science, and its fruit in the form of technologies, affect our bodies and lifeworlds in intimate and decisive ways. And our species might at some future date discover that science and technology had somatically altered us with unforeseen consequences in the longue durée. These contemporary scientific discoveries also furnish us with new narratives about human origins. That God does not create the world from the ‘outside’ like a potter is a view growing numbers of theists are embracing as they become more familiar with the story of science. The world’s temporal beginning is located within a cosmic story, theists admit, but their main point is that the world is dependent on God.
Guessoum is fully aware of these new trends in science and theology. With this background he does an impressive job in documenting the fallacies circulating in modern Muslim intellectual circles about the theory of evolution and the equally half-baked creationist narratives attempting to counter this theory. He rebuts these apologetics and then provides an account of evolution based on theistic grounds. But the theistic component is not essential to the explanation of evolution. Perhaps Guessoum’s theism is analogous to the medieval practice of turning facts into an allegory of the divine.
In the second part, Guessoum addresses some substantial issues with Islam's take on cosmology, intelligent design, the anthropic principle and evolution. These are vast topics, and the author does a remarkable job in both summarizing and examining the literature contributed by contemporary Muslim theologians, philosophers and scientists to the broader, secular, scientific debates. Guessoum is both honest and modest in his conclusions. While he is prepared to defend a modern cosmology, he is not sure that its materialistic philosophy is the only meaning one can derive. Therefore he pleads for an approach where ‘theistic principles’ find harmony ‘with the modern scientific methods and results’ (p. 217). Two requirements, he thinks as a believer, are needed to find conciliation between science and Islam: a new Muslim theology and a less materialistic cosmology where one can find some transcendent meaning and spirit in the universe and in its existence. Yet he is justifiably dismayed by the pseudo-scientific exegesis of sacred texts in order to produce an Islamic cosmology. He pleads for cosmology to be open and creative without being rigid in terms of a science-and-theology divide.
Guessoum is less clear when it comes to intelligent design (ID), and at least to this reader he appears to hedge. His refutation of ID as theory is quite robust after reviewing the key literature. But a reader is left to wonder what to make of Guessoum saying ‘it is instructive for Muslims to review this concept [the design argument] and to see to what extent the Muslim discourse and world view can accommodate itself with such approaches’ (p. 221). At the end, the reader realizes, he favours a notion of design as a ‘“vector” of continuous, evolving creation and not as a ready-made and detailed blueprint’ (p. 241). In other words, a concept of design, as he points out, is closer to evolutionary theory than thinking of creation as the work of divine providence or divine intervention. Does he think that design is a halfway station to mollify believers? This is after Guessoum acknowledges that Muslim theologians have disregarded Darwinian evolution.
I am less sure whether Guessoum's claim that contemporary Muslim writings favour design and reject Darwinian evolution, but at the same time paradoxically accept the common evolutionary scenarios of matter – such as the big-bang cosmology and the age of the solar system – can sustain scrutiny. If it were true, then accepting an evolutionary biological paradigm would have been easier to those selfsame Muslim thinkers. And if this paradox is so stark in contemporary Muslim discussions of science then it truly deserves serious detailed exposure.
With regard to the anthropic principle, the question whether the universe is fine-tuned for human existence, Guessoum shows that a superficial Muslim theology allows for what he calls ‘an ultra-anthropic principle’ because it places humans at the centre of the universe (p. 269). But most Muslim authors, he says, are loath to discuss the anthropic principle if it takes account of the evolution of the universe physically, chemically and biologically. Guessoum accepts that ‘evolution is an established fact of nature’ (p. 323). However, he follows the theistic evolution of thinkers like Teilhard de Chardin, which accepts ‘all the scientific parts of the theory but proposes a nonmaterialistic interpretation’ (p. 323).
Guessoum lays the groundwork for a theistic account of science, one that he hopes will resonate with a yet-to-be realized modern Muslim theology. One important caveat is in order. A new Muslim theology requires an epistemological overhaul, although many people imagine that a mere rereading of the Qur'an is in itself a substitute for theology. This is a tall order since much of Muslim theology is still immersed in a premodern knowledge tradition. It will require substantial revision of earlier theologies, as well as integration of modern disciplines into the conversation of Muslim theology, before the outcome Guessoum rightly desires is actualized. He is to be commended for starting a very serious conversation.
