Citizenship in India has been the subject of “contentious politics” for decades (Aminzade et al. Reference Aminzade, Goldstone, McAdam, Perry, Tarrow, Sewell and Tilley2001). Incorporating citizenship within the framework of Indian federalism and the role of federalism in responding to varied citizenship claims is not without challenges. Indian states, which constitute India’s federal framework, are central to the complex negotiations that have shaped ideas of citizenship in the country. It is not surprising, therefore, that the amendments to India’s citizenship laws have been fiercely contested not only by protestors on Indian streets but also within legislative assemblies in several state governments, which are the basic units of governance in India’s federal democracy.
The case of Kerala is illustrative. First, the Kerala government was the first state in India that passed a resolution in its Legislative Assembly demanding the repeal of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). Second, the state government challenged the national citizenship law in India’s Supreme Court. Third, the state government extended official support to the formation of a 620-km-long human chain from northern Kerala to the south on Republic Day that demanded the withdrawal of the CAA, thereby supporting the emerging democratic protests against it. Fourth, the state announced that it would not cooperate with the federal government’s initiative of maintaining a National Register of Citizens (NRC). The NRC had already rendered stateless 1.9 million citizens in the State of Assam, and the State of Kerala was determined to not repeat such a scenario. Each intervention is described briefly in the following subsections.
Legislative Resolution against the CAA
On December 31, 2019, Kerala’s Legislative Assembly passed an anti-CAA resolution, the first Indian state to not only register its opposition to the law but also to mobilize support of the opposition in the Assembly. When presenting the resolution, the Left-Front Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan stated that the controversial CAA was against the secular outlook and pluralistic fabric of the country and that it would lead to religious-based discrimination in granting citizenship, thereby contradicting “the basic values and principles of the Constitution.” The government’s view is that as long as the fast-track to Indian citizenship has been confined to Hindu, Parsi, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, and Christian citizens of Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, it is, in effect, a differential exclusion of the Muslims, who also are subject to state and non-state violence in the respective countries.Footnote 1
The Kerala Legislative Assembly is dominated by the Left Democratic Front, a political coalition led by the Communist Party (i.e., Marxist) of India. Nevertheless, the legislative resolution against the CAA found support from the opposition United Democratic Front, led by the Congress Party. Only one member—the lone legislator of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)—expressed his opposition to the resolution but did not vote against it. In doing so, he took a neutral stance,Footnote 2 indicating a rare political unanimity between the state’s opposing political coalitions.
Kerala Challenges the National Citizenship Law in India’s Supreme Court
Almost two weeks after the legislative resolution against the CAA, Kerala also became the first state to challenge the CAA in the Supreme Court (SC) on January 14. This drastically altered the Indian debates on citizenship, thereby opening up the opportunity for a legal battle against the decision of the federal government. In its lawsuit in the highest court of the country, the government sought to declare that the CAA is in violation of the right to equality (Article 14), the right to life (Article 21), and the freedom to practice religion (Article 25) of the Indian Constitution. Briefly, the CAA violates the fundamental rights and basic principles of secularism enshrined in the constitution. The Kerala government also sought direction to declare the Passport (Entry to India) Amendment Rules (2015) and Foreigners (Amendment) Order (2015) to be “ultra vires the Constitution of India and to be void.”Footnote 3
The government is confident in its legal position because it is clear that under Article 14 of the constitution, the state “shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India.” The head of the Left-Front government asserted that the lawsuit is the state’s responsibility to protect civil rights, contrasting the CAA, which is against the secular values of the Indian Constitution. The Supreme Court, which heard the petitions on January 22, 2020, stated that CAA procedures will not be suspended because the rules have not been framed. The Indian Union Muslim League moved the Supreme Court in June 2021 challenging the Central Government’s May 28, 2021, notification inviting non-Muslim refugees from Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Bangladesh and also the residents of the 13 districts of the Indian states (i.e., Gujarat, Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh, Haryana, and Punjab) to apply for citizenship. The Central Government defended its May 28 notification in the Supreme Court, claiming that it is only an “administrative delegation of power” vested in the Central Government “to the local authorities” and “has no relation whatsoever to the CAA,” opening yet another chapter of contentious politics of Indian citizenship, pending further hearings.
The Great Human Wall of Opposition against the CAA
On Republic Day 2020, Kerala witnessed the formation of a 620-km-long human chain from northern Kerala to the south that demanded the withdrawal of the CAA. With the active participation of women and children as well as various religious communities, the human chain literally became a human wall against the divisive and nonsecular politics of the federal government. Although the wall had the official support of the government, the opposition leaders who were left behind argued that the ruling Left-wing forces were trying to profit from it. Yet, many socially concerned individuals and groups—without having any alliance with the ruling Left—also extended their support, making the wall a great success.
No to Detention Centers
The Kerala government boldly announced that it would not cooperate with the federal government’s NRC initiative, which requires Indians to provide documentary evidence of having lived in India—an instrument that already has made thousands of Assam citizens stateless. Kerala also stated that it would not build any detention centers—again, a controversial subject in the context of CAA/NRC/NPR and its implementation in Assam, which had planned to build about a dozen additional detention centers. With the outright rejection of the federal government’s intention of constructing detention centers across states, Kerala took a bold step in favor of human rights in India.
Implications for Union–State Relations
Although it was the first, Kerala is not the only state to oppose the implementation of the CAA and the NRC. Eleven states, representing 56% of India’s population, have taken a stance that contradicts the Union government. However, their options for opposing or ignoring a law formulated by the Union government are limited under India’s federal arrangements, which are skewed in favor of the Central Government. Under these circumstances, the Kerala government’s approach to the Supreme Court is more prudent because Article 131 of the Indian Constitution allows the Court to hear disputes between the Union government and one or more states. While the matter is being heard in the Supreme Court, it will be difficult for the Union government to coerce noncompliant states such as Kerala to implement the CAA.
Although Kerala’s moves have been criticized for undermining the delicate balance between the Union government and Indian states, it is, in fact, a litmus test for the resilience of Union–State relations. Whether India’s federal framework, conceived of as a power-sharing arrangement, moderates the political agenda of the Union government or compels dissenting states to give in remains to be seen.
