“A book about sickness and health and how one dealt with it as a patient, a healer and health administrator in the Ottoman Middle East in the early modern period”; this is the best depiction of the book and its intention as it is aptly portrayed by the author. And indeed, she successfully manages to bring to life a broad picture of the existence of people in the early modern period of the Ottoman Empire, dealing mainly with health issues such as affliction, misery and disease, their treatment and death.
The book is written on two levels. The more important is the social one, in which it examines Middle Eastern cultures and societies from a medical point of view. The other layer is the story of Middle Eastern medical institutions and medicines. They deal mainly with issues such as: the varieties of medicine which existed in the area, where did they originate from, where was medicine practiced, who were the patients and who were the practitioners? Therefore, it can be said here that the book tackles mostly the social history of Ottoman medicine and as such is effective, significant and of great magnitude, and a much needed piece of research that is “of assistance” to readers, academics as well as the general public and it is rendered in a very intelligent and “user friendly” form.
The introductory chapter refers to “the marriage of medicine and society”. It deals with the sophisticated historiography of medical history that elucidates the need for a social history of medicine. Hence it contains a discussion on the lack of the “invisible Middle Eastern ill in scholarship”. This allows the author to portray her aims whilst defining the book and its scope. The introduction also prepares the reader for the task of appreciating what goes on “behind the scenes”, of the importance of writing the book and having a clearer understanding as to why they should read it. One good reason is that the writer charts the gaps in our knowledge and our grasp of Ottoman health and medicine in a way that has never been done before. She does it by adhering to a framework of topics, thus facilitating the scanning of a wide spectrum of discussion on medical themes.
The first chapter, “Medical pluralism, prevention and cure” explores the various medical traditions that influenced the Ottoman medical system such as Galenic humoralism, religious and folkloristic medicine. The chapter also discusses the different types of medicine that existed in the early modern Middle East. It tries to elucidate medical theories (or etiologies) as well as actual therapeutics (clinical reality) such as medical dietetics, materia medica, and surgery.
Chapter Two, is entitled “In health and in sickness: the integrative body”, it deals mainly with the combined aspects of Ottoman medicine, emanating from the approach of cooperation between the various medical traditions that were operating in the Middle East during that period. This is attributed to the holistic recognition of all medical systems such as those of the physical, emotional, spiritual and ecological elements. The balance of every individual is what really matters in order to keep him healthy. And indeed the author attempts and succeeds in demonstrating how all medical traditions endeavour practically to treat the whole individual concentrating not only on the symptoms, but also on the causes of the illness. She does so by raising awareness of a few test cases integrating all senses (music), belief (religion), water and health and illnesses as being to a great extent much more effectual than physical conditions. These emphasise the psychological, philosophical and theological approaches which were most apparent. In general this chapter helps the reader to understand the merits of wellbeing and health and hence the importance of preventive medicine. These two chapters discuss treatment as both symbolic and instrumental intervention; it shows that both practitioners and patients shared responsibility for the treatment. This teaches us that medical theory and practice were widely disseminated in the community and were not held only by the professionals; consequently, laymen shared medical language with the healers.
The third chapter, “‘Feed the hungry, visit the sick and set those who suffer free’: medical benevolence and social order”, introduces us to the way in which Ottoman society organised its healthcare and institutions, that is charity as financial and legal mechanisms of building and running hospitals and medical aid. The interests, benefits and disadvantages on both sides (the ‘givers’ and the ‘takers’) of these phenomena are dealt with in detail. By doing so the author discusses interesting social processes and aspects of Ottoman society, e.g. the way medical charity controlled people's loyalty and behaviour to society, (through moral and religious conventions, resources and obligations).
Chapter Four, “Spaces and diseases, diseases and spaces”, takes us to the locations and structure of hospitals in the Ottoman Empire, obviously focusing on urban space. The author uses this approach in order to study, and expose readers to, cultural and social aspects that are otherwise invisible; for example the perception of those buildings by local people as a reflection of competing with etiologic theories (that were at work in the Ottoman society) such as jinns, miasma, celestial causes, and contagion. This chapter shows that early modern Ottoman hospitals were the epitome of the humoralism and ecological concepts that were very much an important part of the Ottoman medical tradition.
The closing chapter is named after the two main topics it deals with: “Ottoman medicine – Ottoman? Successful?” For her final discussion the author makes use of issues that were analysed in the other chapters: such as the conflicting and various morals created by the combination of methods used to deal with health problems. It turns out that Ottomans chose their own, usually holistic, medical treatment, however complex. The last pages of the book are very interesting and highly stimulating to the reader. The book has a rich bibliography and a modest index.
This document beautifully portrays Ottoman medicine and healthcare by weaving together cultural, social, and political dimensions into a coherent picture of that complex system. It deals with the medical practice of the late medieval non-western society which controlled large areas of the Middle East for four long centuries. Therefore, it is an “eye opener” for the general public since it deals with various interesting facets of eastern medical tradition such as holism, nature and ecology, charity, health and social hierarchy, prevention and curative therapeutics, medicine power and social orders, dialogue between medicine and religious belief. Scholars and students of history, social history and history of medicine will benefit enormously from reading it.
