“This essay is too narrow to be of interest to a general audience. I recommend that you submit this manuscript to Politics, Groups, and Identities…”
Desk rejects, unfortunately, are too common for scholars of identity politics broadly defined. The epigraph is a sentence quoted from a desk-rejection letter that was received by a colleague who works on the intersection of social movements and Latinx activism. This manuscript was desk rejected from a top general-interest journal in the field. Indeed, the essay was an ideal fit for Politics, Groups, and Identities (PGI) because of its subject matter. It also could have been published in a top general-interest journal because it addressed a major theoretical question that advanced how scholars assess social movements. Too often, scholars of identity politics receive this message from gatekeepers that their work is too narrow and is better suited for a subfield journal. This, of course, reifies Jim Gibson’s claims that desk rejects are problematic. However, I seek to complicate this argument by adding specificity to his contention by using identity politics scholarship and scholars as an example. I also offer PGI as a model of how to reduce the number of desk rejects by being community-oriented, innovative, and thoughtful during the review process.
Gibson aptly notes that “Editors sometime offer the gratuitous advice to send the paper to a subfield journal—although the standards for what should be published in a general versus subfield journal are not completely undetectable from the papers that are actually published in the journal and are virtually never explicitly articulated by the journal itself.” PGI directly benefits from this kind of desk rejection. We have had the fortunate opportunity to publish several papers based on the “gratuitous advice” that a general journal was not a neat fit for a particular manuscript. However, although we have been on the receiving end of numerous outstanding papers because of this advice, I and others recognize this as a major problem in our discipline.
As president of the Women’s Caucus for Political Science (WCPS) in 2018, I coauthored a letter in direct response to the immediate-past editors of American Political Science Review (APSR) who claimed that the journal did not receive high-quality submissions from women and underrepresented minorities, among other issues. This letter was inspired by the editors’ presentation during the WCPS at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association (APSA) in fall 2018. In this letter, we asked for the APSR editors to address the paltry number (and proportion) of articles by women; the near exclusion of work about gender; and how this marginalization is symptomatic of, contributes to, and reinforces the devaluing of women’s expertise in ways that sideline them in important decision-making processes in the discipline. We asserted that a journal that has failed to publish a meaningful number of articles that address the politics of race, gender, sexuality, and other forms of marginalization, inequality, and diversity is not excellent and neither does it reflect a general interest in the field.
As social scientists, we called for the use of empirical evidence and multivariate analysis as a way to understand the sources of and possible solutions to many types of inequities in publishing, such as desk rejects. Indeed, scholarship on identity politics and papers that are written by women and underrepresented minorities have disproportionately low representation in top general-interest journals in political science. Desk rejections may be one reason for this. Whereas other scholars have noted that there is a gender publication gap (Djupe, Smith, and Sokhey Reference Djupe, Smith and Sokhey2018), we have little understanding of an ethno-racial publication gap. There is a critical need to use social science methods and techniques to examine whether there is a disproportionate effect on this editorial discretion on this population and scholarship in order to establish best practices to mitigate sources of publication biases.
Instead of arguing for more desk rejects, I assert that editors should send out papers for review and give deserving essays repeated reviews. I helped to develop a publishing-as-mentoring ethos at PGI—one that rejects the “sink-or-swim” conceptualization of publishing (Brown, Sinclair-Chapman, and Smole Reference Brown, Sinclair-Chapman and Smole2019). My role as lead editor is to publish the best scholarship that falls under the journal’s scope. My mission is to be a proactive editor who ensures that papers receive a fair and transparent review process. This often means that good manuscripts will receive an additional round of reviews in order for the author(s) to improve the argument or the presentation of a theoretical development or to bolster the methodology. Admittedly, this adds time and resources to the review process, but it ultimately produces much-improved manuscripts. This type of proactive measure has been recommended to reduce the gender submission gap (Brown and Samuels Reference Brown and Samuels2018), and we suspect it mitigates the ethno-racial publishing gap as well. Publishing as mentoring may put more stress on the system, but the publication and review process is that much better for this approach.
To bolster our reviewer pool and build capacity for this publishing-as-mentoring approach, we started to enlist new reviewers from untapped pools of scholars. The WomenAlsoKnowStuff.com database is an excellent source of scholars who are listed by expertise. This pool includes women who often are not asked to review manuscripts, such as professors at community colleges, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, and liberal arts universities. Several of the women that I contacted from this database welcomed the opportunity to review manuscripts from PGI, indicating that they seldom are asked to assess papers for publication. Furthermore, a small number of our first-time reviewers subsequently became authors and now have articles in our journal. I urge other editors to look outside of their networks to find reviewers for their journal. Women Also Know Stuff and People of Color Also Know Stuff are fruitful databases to expand the reviewer pool.
Maintaining an active and responsive reviewer pool requires that editors cultivate a community of care for their reviewers. PGI has created a community of scholars—both authors and reviewers—who feel that they are part of a group that respects their scholarship, acknowledges and celebrates their accomplishments, and genuinely cares about people. Much of this is accomplished via our social media presence, where we publicly recognize our authors in meaningful ways. We connect PGI articles with current political phenomena to bring fresh eyes to manuscripts. We also celebrate an author’s or reviewer’s achievements—such as winning a book award, receiving tenure, or earning a national grant. People who feel appreciated by a journal are more likely to review for it. By not treating the publication process as entirely transactional, we cultivated a community of scholars who are endeared to the journal and actually want to review for us—they see reviewing for PGI as part of the broader mission of supporting diversity in the profession.
Maintaining an active and responsive reviewer pool requires that editors cultivate a community of care for their reviewers.
To maintain this community, we host parties—not receptions—at annual political science meetings. A PGI party is a must-attend event. For instance, our 2018 APSA party was held in a local speakeasy in San Francisco and our 2019 party was held on a rooftop balcony in Adams Morgan, overlooking the District of Columbia. Each venue featured a DJ and signature cocktails. Our 2020 Western Political Science Association party was scheduled to be held at a bowling alley with an arcade, photo booth, and DJ. Away from the stuffy environment of the conference hotel, PGI scholars are more relaxed and thus able to enjoy themselves without the added pressure of “being on.” Rather, they can be themselves in a semiprofessional environment that is more conducive for collegial networking and mentorship. These parties, by design, reinforce our community ethos as we seek to bring scholars together as people who do not see publishing as a zero-sum game in which gatekeeping is used to signal to the types of scholarship prioritized in the discipline. In this way, gatekeeping is used as a primary priority in the editorial process to cull scholarship that does not conform to traditional theoretical or methodological frames within political science. At these parties, I have been fortunate to meet and converse with would-be-authors who shared that they had a manuscript rejected by PGI but received thoughtful and insightful feedback. They wanted to come to one of our parties to engage with a crowd of scholars who provided these detailed reviews.
Another way that I work to maintain our reviewer pool is to award and recognize our reviewers. Like many other journals, PGI celebrates scholars who routinely review for us. We also ask scholars to join our editorial board if they have provided multiple reviews for us in the previous year. Previous scholarship notes that women are underrepresented on journal editorial boards and are less likely to be asked to join one—although they often are asked to review manuscripts (Kennedy, Lin, and Dickstein Reference Kennedy, Lin and Dickstein2001; Metz and Harzing Reference Metz and Harzing2009; Morton and Sonnad Reference Morton and Sonnad2007; Stegmaier, Palmer, and Van Assendelft Reference Stegmaier, Palmer and Assendelft2011). Being on the editorial board of a journal for women creates a role-model effect and reduces the gatekeeping efforts of editors who may not welcome the different scholarly perspectives that this group brings to the publishing process. Furthermore, being on an editorial board indicates that one is a leader in the field and recognizes the valuable expertise that a scholar possesses that will enhance the journal. More than serving as a peer reviewer, being a member of the editorial board indicates that the journal values one’s input for editorial decisions. This increases the profile of early- and mid-career faculty who will benefit most from this boost in status for tenure and promotion or marketability for hiring and promotions. For this reason, PGI’s editorial board is composed of both high-profile and up-and-coming scholars. Many of these up-and-coming scholars started out as peer reviewers but were asked to join the board after completing at least three reviews a year for the journal. This means that PGI has a large editorial board and an international advisory board, perhaps larger than most journals of its size. However, I am satisfied with this board size because it signals inclusivity, attempts to correct gender-based biases in the discipline, and offers junior and mid-career scholars an opportunity for advancement.
Finally, I personally and sincerely thank scholars for being part of the PGI community. This verbal or written thank you signals to scholars that the lead editor appreciates their efforts—as reviewer, potential author, or published author. Our journal is the premier journal in identity politics because of our reviewers and authors, and I am grateful for our community.
In summary, I present an argument against desk rejections via an identity-politics lens. Using PGI as an example, I have shown a spotlight on the specific challenges of desk rejects for scholars of identity politics or those from a marginalized background. PGI’s current desk reject rate is 6.09%, which accounts for submissions that are outside of the scope of the journal and those that do conform to our style guidelines. Our desk-rejection percentage is lower than many journals because we have an expanded reviewer pool, we diligently work to create a community of scholars who want to review for the journal, and we view publishing as a form of mentorship. For scholars who often are on the receiving end of desk rejections from general-interest journals, PGI is a welcome outlet for these papers. However, general-interest journals should attempt to mirror some of PGI’s best practices to broaden their scope and readership and to make the discipline more representative of twenty-first-century America.
