According to the U.S. Census, there are more than 80,000 political subdivisions in the United States. These states, counties, cities, school districts, and other entities spend more than $2 trillion annually and hold financial assets of some $2.6 trillion, not counting pension funds. How these assets are overseen, managed, measured, and reported is the focus of Ben Finkelstein's book. The premise is that Main Street is different from Wall Street. Specifically, Wall Street's traditional focus on total return investment methods and performance standards is inapplicable to the management of public fund assets. This is because no uniform standard exists for public fund performance, and public managers must consider political issues and public perceptions, factors generally absent in the investment of private assets though ubiquitous for public fund managers.
The book is divided into two parts, aptly named “Main Street Philosophy” and “Technical Tool Kit.” The sum of these parts is a helpful guide to understanding and, for practitioners, applying, public sector investment policies and procedures suitable to both the public sector environment and the unique needs of each public fund. Finkelstein lays the groundwork by clarifying differences between Wall Street and Main Street, reminding readers of the central priorities that should drive the investment of public funds: safety, liquidity, and income. Along the way, this concise and readable guide addresses the importance of having and following an investment policy; defines the elements of such a policy and how investment performance should be measured; and he explains why risk management and risk avoidance are two different things.
The author devotes extra space to GASB 31, a sometimes-misunderstood accounting standard approved in the wake of the 1993 Orange County bankruptcy. This standard requires that holdings in government investment pools be reported at “fair value”, defined by Finkelstein as “the dollar amount at which a financial instrument could be exchanged in a current transaction between willing parties, other than in a forced or liquidation sale.” While acknowledging the sound intentions of GASB 31, the author believes its approval simply replaced the problem of insufficiently transparent asset values with another, by “shackling” public funds' budgeting process to market volatility and needlessly encouraging many public fund managers to invest in more conservative and lower-yielding securities, in order to avoid paper losses. (The imposition of fair value standards by GASB's sister organization, FASB, has been identified by some as a contributor to the decline in capital markets that occurred in 2008. Critics of fair value measures believe they exacerbate market distortions on both the upside and downside.)
Finkelstein contends that it is acceptable for a fund to incur paper losses, as long as the fund manager understands the meaning of such losses and is able to communicate this information to policymakers and the public. The author also takes time to advise practitioners on investing and reporting in the context of GASB 31, informing readers that GASB 31 is an accounting standard, not an investment guideline. Through this discussion, he empowers managers to accept the risk of paper losses and to reap the reward of higher income.
Even in the context of a conservatively-managed public fund portfolio, no discussion of public fund investment policy would be complete without a reminder of the role of diversification, and this book does not disappoint. The author addresses in detail the key concepts of average life and duration, and he also provides tutorials on their practical application. Readers also will benefit from Finkelstein's treatment of the important distinction between what is legal and what is suitable in the public fund realm. Suitability is a dominant theme throughout the book: what is permitted by law often is inconsistent with the priorities of safety, liquidity, and income. This notion leads the author to advise that each fund must establish its own, unique standard for measuring performance on the basis of suitability.
Finkelstein establishes a suitability test by posing five questions a public fund manager should ask:
• Do we have enough liquidity to pay obligations as they come due?
• Do we have an appropriate level of interest-rate risk?
• Is our portfolio diversified?
• Are our investments legal?
• Do we have an appropriate market rate of return?
“Any fund manager,” says Finkelstein, “who can state each of these affirmatively has established a portfolio that meets the standard of both suitability and performance unique to his or her fund.” He then examines each question in detail, providing abundant explanation for readers to appreciate the full context of each question.
In the book's second portion the author offers a practical, hands-on primer for those interested in understanding the world of public fund investing. Finkelstein achieves this by describing essential, real-world concepts in practice, featuring helpful tutorials on such concepts as public fund analytics, callable securities, and optimal maturities. This book is presented by the publisher as a first-of-its-kind guide to investing public fund assets, though no discussion of public fund investing is complete without acknowledging Girard Miller's volume entitled Investing Public Funds, which has become a reference standard for public fund managers. Finkelstein's work nonetheless should be required reading for not only public fund managers, but also business school students, journalists, and state and local policymakers.
