Recognizing excellence in the profession is one of the most important activities of the American Political Science Association. The association's Annual Awards Ceremony and Luncheon began at noon on Thursday, September 3, at the 2009 Annual Meeting in Toronto. The luncheon was for award recipients and their guests by invitation. The ceremony was open to all registrants beginning at 12:45 p.m.
APSA DISSERTATION AWARDS
Gabriel A. Almond Award
The Gabriel A. Almond Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of comparative politics.
Award Committee: Kanchan Chandra, chair, New York University; Forrest D. Colburn, CUNY–Graduate Center; and Ellen M. Immergut, Humboldt University Berlin
Recipient: Lisa A. Blaydes, Stanford University
Dissertation: “Competition Without Democracy: Elections and Distributive Politics in Mubarak's Egypt”
Dissertation Chair: George Tsebelis, University of Michigan, and Leonard Binder, University of California, Los Angeles
Citation: This excellent dissertation analyzes the role of elections in contemporary Egypt. By probing the role of electoral competition in a non-democratic regime, it makes a distinguished contribution to the analysis of the internal dynamics of authoritarian regimes. Blaydes argues that elections should not be viewed as a threat to this authoritarian regime but instead as a source of its resilience. Elections provide a means of resolving distributional conflicts—particularly those regarding the spoils system—amongst and between the ruling regime and the “rent-seeking elite,” as well as providing some means of (albeit limited) informational exchange and claims making on the state for the broader citizenry. The combination of sources (Arabic newspapers and interviews, political science, and area-specific sources) and methods (interviews, quantitative methods, some formal models) is truly impressive. Moreover, the thesis considers a wide range of dimensions and actors in the analysis, addressing the benefits to authoritarian regimes in holding elections (Chapter 2), how the regime manages distributive expectations via elections (Chapter 3), how infrastructure is provided (Chapter 4), budget cycles (Chapter 5), voting (Chapter 6), elites (Chapter 7), and the role of dissident groups, such as the Muslim Brotherhood (Chapter 8) and liberal intellectuals (Chapter 9), as well as external actors (Chapter 10). This is the most detailed and thorough study of the functional benefits of elections in a single country that we are aware of, and that too in a country that has been difficult to incorporate into comparative politics until now. This dissertation represents a milestone in the study of both authoritarianism and Egyptian politics.
William Anderson Award
The William Anderson Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of state and local government, federalism, or intergovernmental relations.
Award Committee: Nancy Burns, chair, University of Michigan; Ricardo Ramirez, University of Southern California; and Kim M. Williams, Harvard University
Recipient: Alison Post, University of California, Berkeley
Dissertation: “Liquid Assets and Fluid Contracts: Explaining the Uneven Effects of Water and Sanitation Privatization”
Dissertation Chair: Jorge Dominguez, Harvard University
Citation: Post's dissertation advances compelling reasons to rethink big debates about infrastructure privatization in developing countries. The empirical evidence strongly supports a novel yet intuitive theoretical claim. At the same time, the practical implications of the findings—which are laid out quite lucidly—could not be more pressing. In all, Post weaves together empirical, theoretical, and policy commentary into an insightful and well-researched narrative about human access to potable water and sanitation.
Edward S. Corwin Award
The Edward S. Corwin Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of public law.
Award Committee: Lisa Conant, chair, University of Denver; Doris Marie Provine, Arizona State University; and James R. Stoner, Jr., Louisiana State University
Recipient: Mark Massoud, Stanford University
Title: “Who Rules the Law? How Government, Civil Society, and Aid Agencies Manipulate Law in Sudan”
Dissertation Chair: Malcolm Feeley, University of California, Berkeley
Citation: Mark Massoud is the winner of the 2009 Edward S. Corwin award for the best doctoral dissertation completed in the field of public law within the past two years. In his thesis, titled “Rights, Law, and Development in Sudan,” Massoud contributes to our understanding of the role of law and human rights ideals in struggling states. Even in one of the world's most failed states, the thesis shows that law can be strategically employed by a variety of actors including colonial administrators, political and military leaders, opposition parties, tribal and customary authorities, international NGOs, and the international community.
Drawing on Arabic and English sources from colonial archives, libraries, and interviews in Britain, Egypt, and Sudan, Massoud reveals that law and human rights ideals can be important symbolic resources, but not always in the beneficial ways that are often assumed. The Corwin Award Committee, composed of Lisa Conant, Doris Marie Provine, and James R. Stoner, Jr., was particularly impressed with how Massoud linked themes important to public-law scholarship and the socio-legal studies movement, recognizing the importance of legal institutions, while working within the broader tradition of socially embedded law. Methodologically sophisticated, the thesis recognizes the significance of the investigator's own presence in the observation of events, and the importance of alerting the reader to the writer's position in the study. The author's pursuit of this project, with over a year of field research in Sudan, demonstrates courage and tenacity in the face of difficult and often tragic circumstances.
Harold D. Lasswell Award
The Harold D. Lasswell Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of policy studies. The award is supported by the Policy Studies Organization and the APSA Organized Section on Public Policy.
Award Committee: Michael Howlett, chair, Simon Fraser University; Victoria Hattam, New School University; and Andree E. Reeves, University of Alabama in Huntsville
Recipient: Michael Schoon, Indiana University
Dissertation: “Building Robustness to Disturbance: Governance in Southern African Peace Parks”
Dissertation Chair: Elinor Ostrom, Indiana University
Citation: Michael Schoon's “Building Robustness to Disturbance: Governance in Southern African Peace Parks” examines complex governance systems related to protected areas in South Africa. In particular, he focuses on two International Peace Parks with very different histories and track records on biodiversity protection. His study combines information about a wide range of local disturbances with rigorous methods, fieldwork, interviews, and outstanding policy analysis to find that each park's governance system performs effectively in some instances but that this performance is varied across problem types. Schoon's dissertation is an impressive analysis that addresses an important contemporary issue with a creative and rigorous approach.
Helen Dwight Reid Award
The Helen Dwight Reid Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of international relations, law, and politics. The award is supported by the Helen Dwight Reid Educational Foundation.
Award Committee: Rawi Abdelal, chair, Harvard University; Audie Klotz, Syracuse University; and Allan C. Stam, University of Michigan
Recipient: Jessica Chen Weiss, Yale University
Dissertation: “Powerful Patriots: Nationalism, Diplomacy, and the Strategic Logic of Anti-Foreign Protest”
Dissertation Chairs: David A. Lake and Susan Shirk, University of California, San Diego
Citation: We have unanimously selected Jessica Chen Weiss (Ph.D., University of California, San Diego) as the winner of this year's Helen Dwight Reid Award. Her dissertation, “Powerful Patriots: Nationalism, Diplomacy, and the Strategic Logic of Anti-Foreign Protest,” builds effectively on scholarship about nationalisms, social movements, foreign policy, and international relations to explain how authoritarian governments are both constrained domestically and enabled in foreign relations by anti-foreign sentiment within their own societies. In an original and insightful analysis, Dr. Weiss develops a theory of anti-foreign protest that emphasizes the incentives authoritarian governments have to cultivate a nationalist movement to gain bargaining leverage with other countries. While scholarship on the ability of democratically elected governments to claim domestic, electoral constraints in international diplomacy has tended to assume that authoritarian governments lack such commitment devices, Dr. Weiss shows that anti-foreign social movements can serve similar purposes.
Dr. Weiss applies her theory primarily to the foreign relations of the Chinese government, whose practices within China and abroad are central to world politics. The Chinese government, Dr. Weiss shows, has played a delicate game by sometimes cultivating anti-foreign sentiment within a nationalist movement whose strength has ebbed and flowed during the past 30 years. The delicacy derives from the fact that the official ideology of the ruling Communist party does not rely explicitly on nationalism, which could not only enhance the legitimacy of the government within China but also potentially serve as an alternate narrative for a new regime. Although Chinese leaders have traditionally viewed independent social movements as a threat to regime stability, they also have found anti-foreign sentiment to be an effective commitment device when dealing with other major powers, including Japan and the United States. Dr. Weiss thereby resolves the empirical puzzle of why the government cracked down on anti-Japanese protests in 1990 and 1996, but tolerated and even encouraged them in 1985 and 2005. Similarly, the Chinese government permitted anti-American protests in 1999 and 2003, but repressed them in 2001. Her compelling answer is that China's bargaining position at those particular moments was strengthened by a vibrant nationalist movement.
The research for this dissertation is impressive. Dr. Weiss collected and evaluated both quantitative and qualitative data collected over a year's worth of field research comprised of interviews, as well as from an analysis of government documents, media coverage, and Internet archives. The dissertation is a model of mixed-method research, analytic theory building, and nuanced analysis of the Chinese political and social context. In sum, Dr. Weiss illuminates in her dissertation one of the most important dynamics in world politics: the risky, but strategic, balance between the Chinese government's efforts to manage its domestic legitimacy and strengthen its bargaining position in world politics. Hers is a most impressive contribution to our knowledge of nationalist movements, authoritarian governments, and international relations.
E. E. Schattschneider Award
The E. E. Schattschneider Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of American government.
Award Committee: Marie Gottschalk, chair, University of Pennsylvania; Samuel Popkin, Russell Sage Foundation; and Keith W. Reeves, Swarthmore College
Recipient: Traci Burch, Northwestern University
Dissertation: “Punishment and Participation: How Criminal Convictions Threaten American Democracy”
Dissertation Chair: Jennifer Hochschild, Harvard University
Citation: Traci Burch's dissertation, “Punishment and Participation: How Criminal Convictions Threaten American Democracy,” is a fresh, original, and provocative analysis of the problem felon disenfranchisement. Burch artfully and convincingly demonstrates how having a criminal conviction is a more significant factor in depressing voter turnout among offenders and ex-offenders than formal legal barriers to voting. Since people with convictions are concentrated within certain racial groups and certain geographic areas, mass imprisonment is creating a troubling phenomenon that Burch calls “concentrated disenfranchisement.”
Burch's work on the impact of mass incarceration on political and civic participation has enormous implications. It suggests that mass imprisonment may be rapidly cleaving off wide swaths of people in the United States from the promise of the American Dream, which some contend has served as a kind of societal glue holding together otherwise disparate groups. This is an engaging, far-reaching, yet disciplined dissertation that will leave an enduring mark on how we understand mass incarceration and its wider impact on American politics and society.
Leo Strauss Award
The Leo Strauss Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of political philosophy.
Award Committee: Roxanne L. Euben, chair, Wellesley College; Cristina Beltran, Haverford College; and Tommie Shelby, Harvard University
Recipient: Robert Alan Sparling
Dissertation: “Johann Georg Hamann and the Enlightenment Project”
Dissertation Chair: Edward Andrew, University of Toronto
Citation: The committee is truly delighted to award the Leo Strauss Prize for the Best Dissertation in Political Philosophy (2008–09) to Robert Alan Sparling. “Johann Georg Hamann and the Enlightenment Project” is a remarkable piece of scholarship as well as a fascinating intellectual journey through the seemingly impenetrable mind of Johann Georg Hamann (1730–88). Sparling carefully contextualizes Hamann's thought within the philosophical debates of his own time, explaining his unique method of discursive exchange and the heavy doses of irony and parody that characterize it. Providing one of the first systematic studies of Hamann's thought from the perspective of political philosophy, Sparling shows the German thinker engaged in a protracted attack on Enlightenment views of the scope and authority of reason in political life. Against the spirit of the age, Hamann asserted that there is indeed a place for the sacred in public life, that revelation and faith cannot be replaced or neutralized by a universalizing and sovereign reason.
Sparling is not content, however, to make Hamann's thought accessible to contemporary political theorists—a demanding task in its own right. In painstaking detail and with admirable clarity, he at once shows how Hamann anticipates many postmodern critiques of the Enlightenment and demonstrates his work's contemporary significance to current debates, particularly those over liberal toleration and public reason.
The dissertation is extraordinarily learned, carefully researched, powerfully argued, and elegantly written. With exquisite care, Sparling unpacks the meanings behind Hamann's many elusive and often obscure references and allusions, reconstructing his ideas and arguments to illuminate the many philosophical commitments (including deep disagreements with his friend Immanuel Kant) of a thinker who was, in many ways, hostile to philosophical methods of establishing conclusions. While characterized by a genuine intellectual generosity, the dissertation is far from hagiographic: Sparling offers charitable readings of Hamann's disparate texts while maintaining a healthy critical distance from his subject. The members of the committee feel strongly that this thesis will form the basis of a first-rate and important book.
Leonard D. White Award
The Leonard D. White Award is given for the best doctoral dissertation in the field of public administration.
Award Committee: Laura S. Jensen, chair, Virginia Tech University; Terri R. Jett, Butler University; and Herman Schwartz, University of Virginia
Recipient: Zachary Oberfield, University of Wisconsin–Madison
Dissertation: “Becoming the Man: How Street-Level Bureaucrats Develop Their Workplace Identities and Views”
Dissertation Chair: Joe Soss, University of Minnesota
Citation: Oberfield's dissertation uses long-term survey and interview data on new police officers and welfare caseworkers in a mid-sized American city to examine the process of socialization into bureaucratic norms. He contrasts the relative degree to which self-selection, novices' own initial beliefs, and the structural constraints of their job create identities, behavior patterns, and views on citizen deservingness. Oberfield carried out a three-year long survey of over a hundred officer-cadets and new caseworkers, as well as semi-structured interviews. This alone is a remarkable achievement. While Oberfield's findings suffer from some weaknesses—in particular an inability to fully account for how self-selection into his two interview pools interacts with the differing degrees of autonomy/discretion involved in each job, the dissertation presents a nuanced exploration and explanation for the development of a bureaucratic consciousness and attitude changes over time. By doing so, he sheds light on how organizations reproduce themselves by reshaping the human raw material that comes their way.
APSA PAPER AND ARTICLE AWARDS
Heinz Eulau Award
The Heinz Eulau Award is given for the best article published in the APSR and Perspectives on Politics during the previous calendar year. Two Eulau Awards are presented, one for each journal. Committee members are asked to help make the selection from one journal or the other, and the chair is asked to participate in both decisions.
Award Committee: Kenneth A. Oye, chair, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
American Political Science Review Committee: Michael C. Desch, University of Notre Dame, and Thomas Romer, Princeton University
Perspectives on Politics Committee: Katharine H.S. Moon, Wellesley College, and Linda L. Fowler, Dartmouth College
Co-recipient: Roger Myerson, University of Chicago
Title: “The Autocrat's Credibility Problem and Foundations of the Constitutional State,” American Political Science Review 102 (February)
Citation: This article offers fresh insights into relations that lie at the heart of autocratic politics, with broader implications for governance. Roger Myerson considers relations among a leader and captains whose efforts the leader requires to attain and retain power. The leader may promise rewards for the efforts of captains and may be tempted to renege on such promises.
Myerson examines the resulting trust and reassurance problem. Myerson assesses the implications of this reassurance problem for the performance of autocratic polities by combining classical methods of analysis with a game-theoretic model of agency incentive problems. Myerson also shows how institutional arrangements such as courts and councils mitigate the central problem of trust by allowing captains to share information and evaluate their leader's behavior.
This rigorous and subtle essay has implications for diverse political systems, including absolute monarchy, constrained monarchy, and oligarchy. It is likely to offer a fruitful structure for continuing examination of the evolution of political institutions.
Co-recipient: Michael L. Ross, University of California, Los Angeles
Title: “Oil, Islam, and Women.” American Political Science Review 102 (February)
Citation: This article is rich in theoretical and substantive insights. Michael Ross observes that women in the Middle East and North Africa have enjoyed less progress toward gender equality than women in other regions. He develops an economic explanation of this phenomenon that contrasts with more common cultural explanations.
Conventional wisdom attributes the status of women to those varieties of Islamic culture found in North Africa and the Middle East. Ross suggests that economic dependency on oil exports better accounts for variation in the status of women in these regions. He explains why women tend to be underrepresented in the work force of oil-based economies and how workforce representation affects political standing.
This article is a model of empirical social science with implications for theory and policy. It contributes to understandings of relations across economic and social phenomenon, and in so doing offers insights of value to all seek to improve the standing of women in developing countries.
Co-recipient: Elizabeth J. Perry, Harvard University
Title: “Chinese Concepts of Rights: From Mencius to Mao—and Now” Perspectives, March 2008
Citation: This article is an exemplary Perspectives selection. It addresses fundamental questions with significant implications for policy in a manner appropriate to specialists and non-specialists alike.
Perry argues that from classical times to the present, a principal criterion for judging Chinese rulers has been the promotion of economic welfare and security. In Mencius's words: “An intelligent ruler will regulate the livelihood of the people, so as to make sure that … in good years they shall always be abundantly satisfied, and that in bad years they shall escape the danger of perishing.” The influence of these ideas runs through the writings of Mao with his emphasis on the welfare of the peasantry as a test of effective governance. These ideas are also found at the core of the writings of the current regime. Perry makes a persuasive argument that when China's leaders address human rights they are recognizing indigenous interpretations of such rights.
Perry's study is in tension with conventional criticisms and common predictions on human rights in China. Because economic liberalization often leads to political liberalization, many foreign observers predict upheaval as an increasingly prosperous China fails to guarantee individual rights. Perry casts doubts on such predictions, noting that economic hardships in rural areas are the most likely sources of instability. Any analyst seeking insight into possible political consequences of the 2008–2009 economic crisis would be well advised to reflect on the implications this piece.
Finally, Perry offers more than the standard bromide on the dangers of applying the standards of one culture to another. She reminds readers that individual liberty is not the only benchmark by which Westerners judge their own societies, noting that values grounded in economic well being have deep roots in the liberal tradition. Indeed, she cites T.H. Marshall who emphasized that “social citizenship” with rights to economic welfare and security trumps “political citizenship” with emphasis on political participation as the highest manifestation of evolutionary citizenship.
APSA BOOK AWARDS
Ralph J. Bunche Award
The Ralph J. Bunche Award is given for the best scholarly work in political science published in the previous calendar year that explores the phenomenon of ethnic and cultural pluralism.
Award Committee: Linda Bosniak, chair, Rutgers University; Kerry L. Haynie, Duke University; and Taeku Lee, University of California, Berkeley
Co-recipient: Richard Iton, Northwestern University
Title: In Search of the Black Fantastic: Politics and Popular Culture in the Post-Civil Rights Era (Oxford University Press, 2008)
Citation: Throughout their history in the U.S., black Americans often have been denied full and equal access to the formal levers of political power. In this context, black political culture emerged as an important tool for expression and change. Iton interrogates the spaces of African American popular culture to show how culture—captured by Iton's concept of the “fantastic”—acts as a vanguard and a space (literal and imaginary) for seeding and mobilizing reform and change. Iton is both imaginative and dogged in his pursuit to reclaim culture as a potentially emancipatory site during moments of quiescence. This book is an important reminder that defining the boundaries of “black politics” so narrowly as to limit it to electoral politics places blinders on what we are able to discover and imagine about the possibilities of blacks as political actors.
Co-recipient: Julie Novkov, SUNY, Albany
Title: Racial Union: Law, Intimacy, and the White State in Alabama (University of Michigan Press, 2008)
Citation: Novkov employs a masterful and in-depth analysis of case law to give a rich and detailed portrayal of the vital role white supremacy played in the development of the state and its political, economic, and social institutions in the American South. By focusing on and filling in the context in just one state (Alabama), Novkov makes a compelling case for the role of the state in regulating interracial boundaries and safeguarding white citizenship and privilege through the force of law. Racial Union is an important contribution to the emerging and growing fields of race and American political development, and race and gender intersectionality.
Gladys M. Kammerer Award
The Gladys M. Kammerer Award is given for the best political science publication in the previous calendar year in the field of U.S. national policy.
Award Committee: Paul Allen Beck, chair, Ohio State University; Anna L. Harvey, New York University; and Stephen Skowronek, Yale University
Recipient: Larry Bartels, Princeton University
Title: Unequal Democracy (Princeton University Press, 2008)
Citation: Unequal Democracy is an outstanding and timely study of how “politics matters” in accounting for the rising income inequality in America since the 1970s. Its examination of the political economy under different presidential administrations shows clear partisan differences since World War Two: working- and middle-class family incomes have fared better under Democrats, the rich better under Republicans; and unemployment is lower under Democratic presidents, economic growth higher, while inflation does not differ much by party. Despite such outcomes, Americans have elected more Republican than Democratic presidents during this time. The explanation for this puzzling voter inattention to their economic interests, provided mainly through intensive analysis of decades of American National Election Study data, is not that cultural and other issues trump economic issues. Instead, it results from voter “myopia” in focusing on income growth only in the presidential election year, the one year in the president's term when they do better under Republicans; greater sensitivity to income growth among middle- and upper-class voters than among the working class; Republican advantages in campaign spending; and greater attentiveness among senators, Democrats and Republicans alike, to the interests of their upper-income constituents than to lower-income Americans. More broadly, while the public may favor more equality in incomes in principle, they are not well aware of the realities of inequality, and their partisan and ideological predilections guide both their perceptions of this reality and their policy preferences. Specific case studies of public opinion on the Bush tax cuts of the early 2000s, the estate tax, and the minimum wage demonstrate a widespread lack of voter understanding of the issues involved, as well as the ability of minimum wage reform opponents to block policies that the public would support. The results from this study will be controversial—and, like income inequality, probably will be viewed through partisan and ideological lenses. Some may be dismayed for what they suggest about voter capabilities and influence in the operation of American democracy. Nonetheless, the care taken in the analysis, the rigorous application of controls and testing of alternative explanations, and the sheer comprehensiveness of the effort should compel everyone interested in understanding contemporary American national politics and policy, not only rising income inequality, to come to grips with the story told in Unequal Democracy. With it, Larry Bartels has provided a superb example of how social science theory and methods can be applied to illuminate the central issues of our time.
Victoria Schuck Award
The Victoria Schuck Award is given for the best book published in the previous calendar year on women and politics.
Award Committee: Aili Mari Tripp, chair, University of Wisconsin–Madison; Mala N. Htun, New School for Social Research; and Jane Jenson, University of Montreal
Recipient: Kristin Bumiller, Amherst College
Title: In an Abusive State: How Neoliberalism Appropriated the Feminist Movement Against Sexual Violence (Duke University Press, 2008)
Citation: Kristin Bumiller's In an Abusive State: How Neoliberalism Appropriated the Feminist Movement Against Sexual Violence was published by Duke University Press in 2008. It is a provocative study of how feminist advocacy to stop sexual violence in the United States has unwittingly resulted in state policies that have contributed to criminalizing a large section of American men who disproportionately represent ethnic minorities and immigrant groups. In a compelling and nuanced exploration of a difficult topic, Bumiller shows the consequences of our over-reliance on the courts and the social welfare bureaucracy as instruments to deal with sexual violence. She reveals the limits of state-based responses in lieu of broader reforms that would address the multiple social dimensions of the problem and criticizes the portrayal of sensational episodes of sexual violence in the media. Adopting a theoretically innovative approach and challenging conventional wisdom, the book significantly advances debates on sexual violence and is certain to influence policy in this area.
Woodrow Wilson Foundation Book Award
The Woodrow Wilson Foundation Award is given for the best book published in the U.S. during the previous calendar year on government, politics, or international affairs. The award is supported by the Woodrow Wilson Foundation.
Award Committee: Martha Finnemore, chair, George Washington University; Germaine A. Hoston, University of California, San Diego; and Eileen McDonagh, Northeastern University
Recipient: Jens Meierhenrich, Harvard University
Title: The Legacies of Law: Long-Run Consequences of Legal Development in South Africa, 1652–2000 (Cambridge University Press, 2008)
Citation: Democratization has been a major concern of political scientists, policymakers, and millions of people around the globe. Often observers assume that transitions to democracy entail demolishing non-democratic legacies in order to replace them with principles of equality, liberty, and rule of law. By contrast, this year's award winner, Jens Meierhenrich, shows how “rules of law” can be a crucial legacy of the non-democratic past. He brilliantly demonstrates how a heritage of faith in law can stabilize expectations and help citizens overcome security dilemmas and commitment problems, thereby producing remarkable democratic outcomes.
In developing his counterintuitive thesis, Meierhenrich synthesizes insights from law and political science to construct a theoretically rigorous and empirically robust analysis of one of the most important transitions of the twentieth century, the establishment of a democratic state in South Africa. He shows how the “rule of law” has two faces: rule of law may buttress non-democratic politics but subsequently play a crucial role in dismantling non-democratic institutions. Drawing on legal theory from the Weimar Republic, he traces the evolution of what he calls the “dual state” in South Africa. Yes, authoritarians have strategic incentives to disregard the law and rule by fiat (the “prerogative state”) but they also have an interest in maintaining some legitimacy for a normative structure of rational law (the “normative state”). How these two structures evolve through transition is of enormous consequence. Where rational law continues to play a role in decision making, democracy is easier to establish, regardless of whether or not the law is moral or liberal in content.
The theoretical framework Meierhenrich constructs to guide his analysis is eclectic and sophisticated, setting legal theory and sociology of law to work in tandem with insights about strategic bargaining. His empirics are extraordinarily rich and wide ranging. Deep historical analysis of South Africa reveals how the rule of law helped first to institutionalize one of the most undemocratic and inegalitarian of institutions—apartheid—and then to assist in its demise. Insightful comparisons to Chile and Weimar demonstrate the wide-ranging applicability of Meierhenrich's ideas.
APSA CAREER AWARDS
John Gaus Award and Lectureship
The John Gaus Lecture is given to honor the recipient's lifetime of exemplary scholarship in the joint tradition of political science and public administration and to recognize achievement and encourage scholarship in public administration.
Award Committee: Julie Dolan, chair, Macalester College; Frances Stokes Berry, Florida State University; and Norman Thomas Uphoff, Cornell University
Recipient: Larry O'Toole, University of Georgia
Citation: The American Political Science Association confers the 2009 John Gaus award on Laurence J. O'Toole, Jr., in recognition of a “lifetime of exemplary scholarship in the joint tradition of political science and public administration.” Dr. O'Toole is the Margaret Hughes and Robert T. Golembiewski Professor of Public Administration in the Department of Public Administration and Policy at the University of Georgia. He also holds the position of professor of comparative sustainable policy studies at Twente University, The Netherlands.
Dr. O'Toole is a prolific scholar who ranks among the most distinguished and productive scholars of his generation. As one of his nominators said of him, Dr. O'Toole has “been tireless in his efforts to demonstrate the centrality of issues related to public bureaucracy to core issues of effective government.” During his career, he has authored, co-authored, or edited 11 books and over 140 articles and book chapters. In addition, he has consulted with or conducted research for numerous government agencies, including U.S. Agency for International Development, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the U.S. Geological Survey, and the European Commission.
Dr. O'Toole had made seminal contributions to the study of policy implementation, intergovernmental relations, network analysis and policy change. He has also made lasting contributions in the area of comparative public administration, studying management and policy implementation in many countries throughout the world. As one of his nominators said of his work in comparative public administration, “His imprint on this body of research is unmistakable. So, too, is the influence of his ideas.”
Dr. O'Toole is the recipient of many awards and honors, including the American Society for Public Administration's Dwight Waldo Award (2005) for outstanding contributions to the public administration literature and the Charles Levine Award (2002), jointly presented by ASPA and NASPAA for outstanding instruction, scholarship and service in public administration. Additional honors include appointment as a fellow to the National Academy of Public Administration, appointment as a senior member of the Netherlands Institute of Governance, the Academy of Management's best article award in nonprofit management, the Joseph Wholey Distinguished Scholarship Award, and the William E. and Frederick C. Mosher Award.
Dr. O'Toole holds a Ph.D. in public administration and an MPA from Syracuse University and a BS from Clarkson University. He was instrumental in creation of the Public Management Research Association and served recently as its president. He also served previously as a co-editor for the Journal of Policy Analysis and Management its currently a member of its editorial board.
Hubert H. Humphrey Award
The Hubert H. Humphrey Award is given in recognition of notable public service by a political scientist.
Award Committee: Dale Rogers Marshall, chair, Wheaton College; Timothy A. Byrnes, Colgate University; and Isaiah Wilson III, United States Military Academy, West Point
Recipient: Catherine McArdle Kelleher, University of Maryland, College Park
Citation: The 2009 Humphrey Award recognizes a highly respected and influential path-breaker in the areas of international security and American foreign policy who has served with distinction in both academia and government. This year's award honors Catherine Kelleher, senior fellow at the Watson Institute for International Studies at Brown University and concurrently College Park professor at the University of Maryland.
In government Professor Kelleher served as President Clinton's deputy assistant secretary of Defense for Russia, Ukraine and Eurasia from 1996 to 1998. Catherine also served as the Secretary of Defense's representative in Europe and defense advisor to the U.S. ambassador to NATO in Brussels from 1994 to 1996. She was a member of President Carter's National Security Council staff in 1977 and 1978 and a professor in the Military Strategy Department of the National War College from 1980 to 1982.
Professor Kelleher's contributions to the improvement and advancement of political science have been equally significant. Catherine was the founder and first president of Women in International Security, an organization dedicated to developing career opportunities for women. She has served on advisory and research boards of institutes and non-governmental organizations in the United States and Germany, and served as a senior fellow of foreign policy studies at the Brookings Institution from 1990 to 1994, and director of the Aspen Institute in Berlin from 1998 to 2001. In 2005 she completed 15 years as vice chair of the Committee on International Security and Arms Control of the National Academies of Sciences, and directed annual policy dialogues with China, Russia, and India. Throughout her career she has always been a generous mentor to the next generation of scholars.
Professor Kelleher received a BA and DLitt from Mt. Holyoke College and a Ph.D. from MIT in 1967. She was an associate professor at the University of Michigan from 1973 to 1978 and a professor at the Graduate School of International Studies at the University of Denver from 1979 to 1983.
Her publications include more than 60 books and articles in English and German. She has taught and written extensively on conventional and nuclear arms control as well as on German, Russian, and European security issues. She has also been a leader in the design and implementation of programs to broaden education in security studies, both nationally and internationally, in universities and within the military. As a prominent example, Professor Kelleher founded the Center for International Security Studies at the University of Maryland.
She has been decorated for her public service by both American and German governments including the highest civilian award from Germany's Ministry of Defense, the Manfred Woerner Medal for outstanding services rendered to peace and freedom in Europe. Catherine has been active in APSA, ISA, the Council on Foreign Relations, and many other organizations, and served on numerous editorial and advisory boards.
Professor Kelleher has been an innovative academic, a dedicated public servant, and at times a prescient commentator on contemporary events. An argument she made in a 1995 Brookings publication rings as true today as when she first offered it over a decade ago. She said that extending the European zone of peace and stability as far east as possible will require understanding of “the benefits of security cooperation over unilateral national action and of the fundamental interrelationship of economic prosperity, political stability, and military security.”
Benjamin E. Lippincott Award
The Benjamin E. Lippincott award is given biennially to honor work of exceptional quality by a living political theorist that is still considered significant after a time span of at least 15 years since the original publication.
Award Committee: Jennifer Pitts, chair, University of Chicago; Joshua Cohen, Stanford University; and Uday Mehta, Amherst College
Co-recipient: Kenneth J. Arrow
Title: Social Choice and Individual Values (1951)
Citation: Kenneth Arrow's Social Choice and Individual Values is a classic of modern political theory. In this remarkable book, Arrow presents a dilemma for democracy. We would like democracies to meet two minimal conditions: to be both responsive to members as equals and to make rational decisions.
According to Arrow's celebrated and widely discussed impossibility theorem, they cannot be both. Arrow's theorem has been the subject of countless interpretive challenges, but the impact of his book is unquestioned. Arrow's argument transformed the study of politics. He launched the field of social choice theory, helped to establish the rational choice approach to the study of democratic politics, explored the foundations of interpersonal welfare comparisons as a way around his impossibility result, and, above all, presented a profound challenge that still haunts democratic thought: about whether our ideal of a democracy that is both rational and responsive is even coherent.
Co-recipient: J[..]urgen Habermas
Title: Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962)
Citation: J[..]urgen Habermas's Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, first published in 1962, has had a powerful impact upon political theory and a wide range of cognate fields—history, sociology, anthropology, literature—especially after its belated translation into English in 1989. The book's innovative integration of historical research and normative theory produced both an evocative portrait of the historically specific set of institutions that made up the eighteenth-century western European bourgeois public sphere and a compelling argument for public discourse as indispensable to democratic society. Habermas's influential conception of publicity, and his account of the public sphere as a force of social integration to rival those of the state and the market, has generated countless intellectual offspring and stimulated both empirical and normative challenges. With its vivid picture of the “force of the better argument,” it remains both a germinal text in the field of critical theory and a provocation for the critical study of contemporary democratic society.
Carey McWilliams Award
The Carey McWilliams Award honors a major journalistic contribution to our understanding of politics.
Award Committee: Susan L. Shirk, chair, University of California, San Diego; Peter Andreas, Brown University; and J. Nicholas Ziegler, University of California, Berkeley
Recipient: Fareed Zakaria, Newsweek International
Citation: Fareed Zakaria, in his roles as editor, columnist, television commentator, and book author, has had a deep and widespread influence on public understandings of some of the most central issues of contemporary politics and international relations, including the domestic sources of international influence and the ingredients of an effective democracy. Trained at Harvard as a political scientist and speaking and writing as a journalist, Zakaria contributes original insights about the core principles of politics while addressing real-world events and trends.
In the 15 years of his journalistic career, Fareed Zakaria has produced a huge volume of regular commentary on international affairs. His column appears weekly in Newsweek and Newsweek International, and biweekly in the Washington Post. Fareed Zakaria GPS, his weekly interview show on CNN, is the only hour-long in-depth discussion of foreign policy issues that can be found on American television.
Zakaria is not afraid to question conventional wisdom. Unlike other political commentators who adhere to a consistent line on the left or right, Zakaria's columns reveal an impressive political independence and intellectual objectivity. In a self-critical spirit, he sometimes acknowledges past mistakes of analytical judgment. He frequently criticizes American foreign policy, but he avoids the common syndrome of blaming Washington for every world problem. His analysis helps readers understand the complex political dynamics driving the foreign policies of other countries, particularly in the Middle East and Asia. One of his most influential essays, “Why They Hate Us” (published as a Newsweek cover story in October 2001) identifies the root causes of anti-Americanism as imbedded in specific features of the autocratic regimes in Arab countries from which terrorist organizations have emerged.
Fareed Zakaria has also done great public service as an editor. Earlier in his career, while serving as managing editor of Foreign Affairs, his inclusion of unorthodox viewpoints and his graceful editing revitalized this premier foreign policy journal. Since 2000 he has been the editor of all the overseas editions of Newsweek International with 23 million readers around the globe.
In his three best-selling books, Fareed Zakaria develops more thoroughly than he can under pressure of weekly deadlines, his analysis of the connections between domestic politics and international relations. From Wealth to Power (1998) and The Post-American World (2008) have helped Americans understand their country's own history as a rising power and why the rise of new powers like China and India should not be feared if handled wisely. In perhaps his most influential book, The Future of Freedom, Illiberal Democracy at Home and Abroad (2003), Zakaria injected a more critical concept of democracy into the public discussion by forcefully arguing that the rule of law and social institutions independent of the state are even more important than elections.
We honor Fareed Zakaria for the contributions he has made as a working journalist, editor, and author by deepening public understandings of the political dynamics underlying some of the most significant and pressing foreign policy challenges of our times.
Charles E. Merriam Award
The Charles E. Merriam Award is presented biennially to “a person whose published work and career represent a significant contribution to the art of government through the application of social science research.”
Award Committee: Kathryn Sikkink, chair, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis; John R. Ruggie, Harvard University; and Leslie Vinjamuri, SOAS, University of London.
Recipient: Michael Doyle, Columbia University
Citation: Michael Doyle is currently the Harold Brown Professor at Columbia University in the School of International and Public Affairs and Columbia Law School. His published work and career represent a significant contribution to the art of government at both the national and the international level. Doyle's publications stimulated the growth of the field of democratic peace theory, which has had a profound impact on the policy world, in the United States, in other states, and in international and non-governmental organizations. Doyle can be credited with launching the current debate on the democratic-peace theory by reintroducing Kant's ideas to the modern audience, refining those ideas, and providing evidence for them. In his two part 1983 article in Philosophy and Public Affairs, Doyle wrote that the fact that liberal states have not engaged in war with one another was a “startling but less than fully appreciated” success of the modern era. In part through Doyle's work, the idea and its policy implications are now fully appreciated by both scholars and policymakers. Described by one scholar as “the closest thing we have to an empirical law in the study of international relations,” democratic-peace theory had such a widespread impact in the policy world because it provided social scientific support for democracy promotion policies long favored by some policymakers, but criticized by others as excessively idealistic. Democratic-peace theory serves as the theoretical underpinning for many of the democracy-promotion policies used throughout the world today, which are now justified as policies designed to enhance security as well as democracy. Doyle has also written extensively on peacekeeping, imperialism, intervention, compliance with international law, and international relations theory.
Not content only to influence policy through his writing, Professor Doyle has participated actively in the work of international organizations and professional associations dedicated to international studies. He served as assistant secretary-general and special adviser to United Nations secretary-general Kofi Annan. His responsibilities in the secretary-general's Executive Office included strategic planning, outreach, and relations with Washington. Secretary-general Ban Ki-moon appointed him a member and then he was elected alternate chair and then chair of the board of the UN Democracy Fund (UNDEF) for 2006–10. He has served as chairman of the Academic Council of the United Nations Community. He was the vice president and senior fellow of the International Peace Academy and is now a member of its board of directors. He has also served as a member of the External Research Advisory Committee of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the Advisory Committee of the Lessons-Learned Unit of the Department of Peace-Keeping Operations (UN), and is a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, New York.
Professor Doyle previously has taught at the University of Warwick (United Kingdom), Johns Hopkins University, and Princeton University. He was the director of the Center of International Studies of Princeton University and chairman of the Editorial Board and the Committee of Editors of World Politics. He delivered Tanner Lectures at Princeton, November 2006, on preventive self-defense. Doyle's publications include Striking First: Preemption and Prevention in International Conflict (Princeton Press); Ways of War and Peace (W.W. Norton); Empires (Cornell University Press); UN Peacekeeping in Cambodia: UNTAC's Civil Mandate (Lynne Rienner Publishers); Making War and Building Peace (Princeton Press), co-authored with Nicholas Sambanis; Keeping the Peace (Cambridge University Press), which he edited with Ian Johnstone and Robert Orr; Peacemaking and Peacekeeping for the New Century (Rowman and Littlefield), edited with Olara Otunnu; New Thinking in International Relations Theory (Westview), edited with John Ikenberry; Escalation and Intervention: Multilateral Security and Its Alternatives (Westview Press/United Nations Association), edited with Arthur Day; and Alternatives to Monetary Disorder (Council on Foreign Relations/McGraw Hill), which he wrote with Fred Hirsch and Edward Morse.
