Janet Davis's excellent new book joins an expanding conversation about the place of animals in human history. In one historiographic strand, scholars have turned their attention to the ways that animals’ presence—and their autonomous agency—has changed history.Footnote 1 In a second strand, historians have analyzed how human thought about, and human action toward, animals has played a role in shaping past societies.Footnote 2 In her attention to the “gospel of kindness,” and to the myriad institutions through which this gospel was spread, Davis's book exemplifies the second historiographic strand. Within that tradition, her book joins a number of others that have examined the growth of the idea that we ought to treat animals kindly, either because it is good for us or because it is good for them, or both.Footnote 3 In spite of how Davis agrees and overlaps with such works, she also shows that there is more to say on this topic.
Davis's signal contribution is to call our attention to the ways that the “gospel of kindness” toward animals was woven into American exceptionalism and to projects of civilizational uplift both at home and abroad. In a book that spans over a century, from the antebellum period through World War II; and that takes readers through the streets of New York and Los Angeles; and abroad to Cuba, Puerto Rico, the Philippines, and India, Davis provides a densely researched and kaleidoscopic account of the multivalent ideology and practices of animal advocates. While the first American animal protection organization was not founded until after the Civil War (in 1866), the link between kindness to animals and human progress was forged during the Antebellum era. Preachers of the gospel during the Second Great Awakening emphasized free moral agency and human perfectibility. This theology gave rise to a variety of movements that sought to temper passion, restrain violence, and inculcate self-control. Among those that were most important in shaping a doctrine of kindness to animals were abolition and temperance. Borrowing from Raymond Williams, Davis argues that these forces created a “structure of feeling” in which kindness toward animals was an index of moral character.
In the hands of the animal protection organizations that sprang up in the postbellum nineteenth century, kindness toward animals was linked not just to moral character but also to “civilization.” Davis demonstrates this in her examination of the Women Christian Temperance Union's “Department of Mercy.” While best known for its temperance work, the WCTU embraced a range of related causes, including animal protection. Through the Department of Mercy, the WCTU opposed vivisection, promoted the protection of feather-bearing birds, and proselytized a program of “humane education” meant to inculcate values of stewardship and kindness among children. Promoting kindness was linked to civilizational uplift for the WCTU members who disseminated such education among African American schoolchildren in the South. Mercy activists particularly targeted the traditional subsistence-hunting practices of rural African Americans and poor whites, who they saw as living on the edges of civilization, dangerously close to barbarism.
Animal activists of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries considered kindness toward animals as not only Christian and civilized, but also as an especially American value. “Representations of animal cruelty and unassimilated difference in the United States were mutually constitutive,” Davis writes (116). Whether they were decrying the dog-eating Igorots from the Philippines, the cock-fighting pastime of Irish and Latino immigrants, the mule-beating of working-class men on the streets of America's burgeoning cities, or the “Mexican” bullfight that seeped over the border into California and Texas, animal advocates figured cruelty as a sign of essential otherness and lack of fitness for membership in the nation. At best, such incivility was remediable through a combination of education and prosecution; at worst it was a sign of irredeemable savagery.
By the turn of the century, kindness to animals was so successfully woven into what it meant to be a civilized American that there was no doubt but that it would become part of America's mission to the world. When the United States acquired overseas territories, many animal advocates opposed its imperial wars but seized what they viewed as fresh ground for spreading the gospel of kindness. Joined by temperance and other social reform organizations, Humane Societies and SPCAs landed in Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines, and American officials quickly incorporated American-style animal protection laws into colonial governance. Bringing animal protection to the colonies, Davis argues, “exposed the movement's paradoxical impulses” because animal advocacy promoted humane values while “circumscribing human freedom through programs of political, social, and moral control” (119). American efforts to crack down on cock fighting exemplify this contradiction, a fact seized upon by Puerto Rican nationalists who eagerly adopted the blood sport as a symbol of nationalist pride. Likewise, when Filipino lawmakers had a chance to draft a new constitution in 1935, they included a plank that withdrew the policing powers of the American-backed SPCA of the Philippines. Whether they promoted it or rejected it, both animal advocates and colonial nationalists recognized the “gospel of kindness” as a tool of assimilation.
In focusing on the connection between the gospel of kindness, animal advocacy, and programs of civilizational uplift at home and abroad, Davis brings fresh questions generated by imperial, borderlands, and transnational history to the study of animal protection. She convincingly shows how the treatment of animals became a measure of moral fitness, in turn linked to class, race, and national belonging. For students of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, movements for social reform have long been of interest, and questions of social control have dominated the scholarship. The question of how to judge those who promoted kindness to animals has likewise dogged much of the scholarship on such movements. Did they care for animals at the expense of human beings? Did they care more about protecting animals or about persecuting animals’ alleged abusers? Was it a deeply felt morality or the desire for social control that animated their animal-loving hearts? Were these groups, as Karl Marx once accused, the ultimate expression of bourgeois class identity? Davis is judicious about these questions. She believes her subjects when they say that they care about animal suffering, and she notes how animal advocates often espoused other progressive and humanitarian causes; but she does not look away when accusations of “cruelty,” and programs to ameliorate it, serve as instruments of oppression. The Gospel of Kindness is thus not only good history, but also a model of morally complex scholarship.
