Priya Srinivasan's recent book puts into conversation dance history, transnational politics and culture, and constructions of race, citizenship, and gender among dancers from the late nineteenth century, to the present day practice of Bharata Natyam (an Indian classical dance form) on the U.S. West Coast. An ambitious undertaking, Sweating Saris draws from historical, ethnographic, performance studies, feminist, and political methods of inquiry.
Srinivasan's book chronicles the receptivity and influence of Indian dance forms and artists' labor within both the U.S. dance world and broader American society at large, from 1880 to the present day. Offering archival evidence, historical and feminist analysis, and attention to power and national policy, the author argues that public reactions to and treatments of Indian dancing bodies in the United States to a large extent paralleled, and perhaps even preceded, exclusionary U.S. political and race policies toward Asian Americans and their paths to political and cultural citizenship. While at first glance, readers might subsume the struggles of these artists as merely one example of the effects of larger projects of racialization, Orientalism, and cultural hegemony in turn-of-the-century America, the author's presentation of persuasive data and careful analysis in the construction of her argument calls for a reexamination of dance history as a commentary on, and often a precursor to, broader race and political dialogues through U.S. history.
Srinivasan uses two key phrases to make important contributions to the fields of dance history and ethnography, among others: First, through “bodily archive,” she implores the academy to recognize the contributions of subaltern, oppressed, and lost historic figures in the tacit, embodied constructions of modern dance forms in the United States and other “Western” contexts. She convincingly argues that despite the dearth of written histories and recordings of their work, the bodily labor of nautch girls and nachwalis, early Indian dancers, musicians, and artists who traveled to the United States and were put on public display as exotic Oriental human artifacts, made intellectual, ethical, and political contributions to American performance genres through their embodied performances, or “bodily archives” in the public sphere. Well-studied foundational figures of modern dance, such as Ruth St. Denis, are presented in a new light as recipients and receptacles of the bodily archive of early Indian dancers in the United States. While these forbearers of modern dance mostly did not undergo direct pedagogic training from Indian artists, Srinivasan contends that their often brief, cursory, and problematic interactions with Indian artists imprinted their own intellectual and creative processes in nondiscursive ways, creating a legacy of kinesthetics that is organically connected to Indian and Asian art forms and that lives on in contemporary American dance today.
A second key phrase, “unruly spectator,” is at times engaging, and at other moments, cumbersome. It is nevertheless important in understanding Srinivasan's ethnographic method and identity. The author describes her own relationship to Indian dance as a lifelong practitioner and insider to the tradition; she beautifully narrates the difficulty of remaining true to ethnographic modes of inquiry while simultaneously desiring to remain privy to—and protect—the matrices of relationships and affection between students and teachers and disciplinary tactics that, while seemingly severe in a Western, discursive interpretation, are fundamental to dance pedagogy. In these moments, Srinivasan invokes a particular writing voice, as “unruly spectator,” to draw attention to the deep ambivalence of “ethnography-at-home” scholarship. This reviewer wonders, however, if further analyses of the visceral, embodied dilemmas of the ethnographic experience housed within the body of the “unruly spectator” might have served to parse this commentarial persona further, rendering it more accessible to ethnographers and theorists contemplating ongoing debates about ethnographic subjectivity and reflexivity.
The immense detail, the careful deployment of scholarly and personal narrative, and the dexterity of weaving history and ethnography together in Sweating Saris results in a beautiful and critical piece of scholarship for those interested in Asian American embodied practices. Srinivasan's adept interdisciplinary study is an essential read for those exploring transnational embodied practices across historical periods and ideologies. Its most important contribution, perhaps, is its framing of Bharata Natyam and other dance forms not as staged events subject to the gaze of spectators, but rather as continuous forms of physical, intellectual, interpretive, and performative labor that contribute to the honing of (personal, national, and cultural) identity, both in the public domain and within practitioners' bodies. Here, the author continues ongoing efforts in the fields of dance and performance studies to attend to kinesthesia as a quintessential aspect of human experience, and demonstrates the intellectual opportunities of this analytic perspective for South Asian studies, Asian-American studies, and other humanistic disciplines.
