Along the embankment of the Chicago River, where steamships once risked becoming mired in sludge as they ran a gauntlet of swinging bridges, people in the 2010s strolled or sat in riverfront cafes or took rides in water taxis. As Joshua Salzmann remarks in this broad-ranging book, Chicago's leaders, like counterparts in Rotterdam or London, recognized that central-city waterfronts have come to serve urban economies better as sites for “beauty, leisure, and culture” than as gritty aggregations of wharves, warehouses, and grain elevators (179). Having set a high standard with Daniel Burnham's 1909 Plan of Chicago, which envisioned railyards along the Lake Michigan shore giving way to Grant Park and its Beaux Arts museums, Chicago developed the flashy Millennium Park in the 1990s. The city then expanded this “green-space economic development” to its once-squalid riverfront (176). The resulting riverwalk, remarked Chicago Tribune columnist Mary Schmich, “quickly became one of Chicago's wonders, a peaceful place to watch the water, the boats, the birds, the skyscrapers and people from all over the world,” marred mainly—Schmich complained—by drunken raucousness at waterfront bars, on which the city relied to pay the federal loan that underwrote the improvement.Footnote 1
Nineteenth-century Chicagoans would have been mystified by Schmich's notion that the Chicago River could serve as “a refuge from the hubbub.” But they would have understood reliance on the federal government to underwrite waterfront improvement. Waterscapes such as Chicago's, Salzmann argues, have consistently served as “an asset for moneymaking,” a “form of liquid capital” (179). This pro-growth dimension has coexisted, often in tense ways, with arguments for treating waterscape as civic space and a community resource.
In the spirit of generations of Chicago historians, Salzmann begins with reflections over what it means for a city to offer a natural location for commerce, given that nearly all waterfronts—and certainly Chicago's—require arduous re-engineering. The resources of the Mississippi Valley enabled Chicago to emerge as “Nature's Metropolis,” in the phrase of environmental historian William Cronon, whose work underscores how all landscapes with which humans interact reveal urban influences with greater or lesser intensity. Whether made accessible to shipping through dredging, rechanneling, and embankment or into public and recreational space through filling and landscaping, the waterfronts of major metropolises amount to the most intense of manipulated landscapes. “To make the continent's resources exploitable,” Chicago promoters had to “transform the urban landscape, or the metropolis's nature,” Salzmann writes. “Above all, they had to radically alter the waterfront and waterways” (3).
Situated near the continental divide between the Great Lakes and Mississippi systems, the swampy terrain along the three branches of the Chicago River had long been recognized as a site for an inland port. The city's prospects hinged on a canal linking Lake Michigan to the Illinois River, as well as on dredging and piers to combat sandbars and erosion produced by lake currents. Such expensive public works brought the Port of Chicago to the center of debates over federal internal improvements. After Illinois drew upon private capital for the Illinois and Michigan Canal and upon federal aid for the Illinois Central Railroad, the harbor came to seem an indispensable and therefore natural locus for the continent's trade. In the book's first half, Salzmann connects the financial and technical aspects of the Port of Chicago with political and legal matters ranging from the relative authority of different levels of government to the leasing or selling of waterscape to enterprise. The Port of Chicago gave rise to two major Supreme Court rulings establishing waterfronts as “public spaces,” where government exerted permanent authority in the name of “the flow of goods and information” (80). Munn v. Illinois (1877) began in disputes over the stranglehold exercised by grain elevator operators along the Chicago waterfront. Illinois Central v. Illinois (1892) established harbors such as Chicago's as public trusts that government could not sell even to well-funded enterprises promising massive improvement.
The book then traces the transformation of the Chicago waterfront from entrepôt to amenity. The harbor drew the continent's railroads to Chicago. But in an episode of Schumpeterian creative destruction, railroads and rail-dependent industries pulled port traffic south toward the Calumet River and eventually into Indiana, where expanses of cheap land remained available. Railroads gained control of shipping lines and manipulated rates to serve their agendas. A careful observer of urban transportation trends, Daniel Burnham worked for years to build a constituency in favor of replacing the Lake Michigan waterfront's railyards and warehouses with parks, monuments, and museums. Long-standing waterfront interests, however, were reluctant to concede most freight functions to newer facilities capable of handling ever-larger steamships linked to railroads and trucking lines. Municipal Pier north of the river's entrance was conceived as an answer to the multimodal facilities taking shape around the Calumet. Soon after completion in 1915, it became clear that the pier would serve mainly as a site for recreation, the role of the renamed Navy Pier into the twenty-first century.
Salzmann touches only briefly on transnational trends, even though contemporaries viewed events at Chicago and throughout the Great Lakes/St. Lawrence system as part of a worldwide reorganization of waterways, with parallels, for example, up and down the Rhine and over to the Danube. Perhaps as a result, Liquid Capital shares the recent tendency to overemphasize the extent to which politics, law, and capital can create and mold markets. Contemporaries saw themselves as pressed to adapt harbors to new transportation technologies and to the demands of industry. Everywhere, inner harbor interests organized to protect traditional functions, which sooner or later diffused to more open spaces anyway. What stands out in Chicago's case is the foresight with which Burnham and his allies argued that all this presented opportunities worth embracing. Diffusion, of course, spread rather than solved port-related environmental degradation and social inequities. But it did offer an alternative vision of a waterfront “Forever Open, Free, and Clear,” in the inherited local phrase, that Chicagoans hold out to one another and that other cities struggle to understand and use.
