Ken Conca is an internationally renowned authority on the subject of global environmental politics and policy, and in this book he builds on his previous work by taking on the United Nations and arguing for a bold and ambitious framework that integrates pillars of that institution that have largely been left separate and estranged from one another. Specifically, the Charter of the United Nations rests on four legs: international peace and security, social progress through development, rule of law among nations, and human rights for all people. The problem is that the UN’s approach to addressing environmental challenges has drawn primarily on development and international law, while treating issues of peace and security and human rights as somehow unrelated to global environmental sustainability.
Conca’s writing is most powerful when he spells out the substantive linkages among these four legs of the UN mandate, articulating the ways in which, for example, environmental degradation is often caused by and, in turn, contributes to human rights abuses in places like Ecuador, Sierra Leone, and California. His discussion of the connections between the California-based Chevron Corporation and the environmental privileges that this state enjoys at the expense of people and ecosystems in Nigeria and Ecuador is disturbing and profound (p. 98). He makes a strong case, for example, that where we find the absence of (or serious threats to) human rights in any given nation, we also find the conditions that make it difficult for citizens to enjoy the rights of participation in decision making and governance around sustainable and socially just environmental policy and practice. Similarly, where he finds an absence of peace and security because of civil conflict, war, and/or widespread violence, Conca reports that nation-states and their constituent institutions are often taxed in ways that make it exceedingly challenging to enact or comply with international environmental-protection commitments and responsibilities. But the author goes further than simply making the point that these issues are inextricably bound together; he demonstrates that these missed linkages underscore how the UN is undermining its own ability to respond to the dictates of its mandate across all four legs.
How did this disconnect come about? Conca offers a rare window into the history of the United Nations with respect to the dominance of the “law and development” orientation and how it emerged, with particular attention to the rise of the idea of “permanent sovereignty over natural resources” (PSNR), which became central to the UN’s work in the wake of Global South decolonization and independence movements that took hold during the organization’s first two decades. PSNR was a demand made by former colonies in order to maintain control over the very ecological wealth that enriched the world’s former colonizing powers—resources to which the latter nations fought and still fight to maintain access. Thus, “rights” in this context became framed not as individual human or community rights but as a nation’s right to access and protect the ecological materials within its borders. The PSNR concept thus laid the groundwork and was a well-worn script by the time the Stockholm Convention and subsequent efforts sought to address key environmental issues in an increasingly globalized and dynamic world—a context in which the UN was ill-equipped to maneuver.
While Conca offers unflinching and sometimes harsh criticisms of the United Nations, he remains convinced that it is the best hope we have for addressing global environmental challenges, if only it can build on the important foundations it laid down decades ago, as the book’s title suggests. After all, the UN “is the only venue in which a sufficiently wide range of voices may be heard as we seek to forge a robust consensus on difficult environmental problems,” and “[i]t has been the most important catalyst for negotiating international environmental agreements among nations” (p. 2).
An Unfinished Foundation presents a solid and persuasive critique of the UN’s limited approach to linking the four pillars upon which it was founded, and in the Conclusion, Conca offers excellent proposals for addressing these limitations. Even so, there are some key topics around which I would like to have seen a bit more engagement. First, while the author is clearly attuned to the ways in which nationality, ethnicity, indigeneity, social class, race, and gender intersect with the UN’s mission and environmental politics more broadly, it would have been refreshing to see a closer examination of the ways in which these social categories come into play when various stakeholders seek to address (or evade) that mission. For example, throughout the book, there are mentions of these issues but there is less in-depth exploration of how, for example, gender and indigeneity have served as hurdles and opportunities for bringing together the four legs of the Charter. In spite of this, for scholars and readers with an interest in the field of environmental justice studies, the book provides a much-needed legal, historical, and policy framework for understanding why so many efforts to secure global environmental justice advances in international treaties have been limited or stymied.
My other concern with the book is a question for environmental politics more generally: Can we imagine ways of promoting and securing global peace and security, sustainable development, and environmental justice through a framework that does not rely so heavily on nation-states? The UN Charter is obviously predicated on the presence and strong role of states, and the book—as well as much of the field of international relations and environmental politics—takes the view that strong democratic states are necessary for achieving these goals. After all, again and again, we see an absence of peace, security, human rights, and sustainability most visibly in failed states. But that common wisdom in academic and policy circles seems to ignore one extremely important fact: The outcomes of state failure and human rights/environmental abuses are often committed by other state actors. In fact, Conca points out repeatedly that nation-states are among the primary perpetrators of massive human rights and environmental atrocities. For example, he cites Wolfgang Sachs, who once wrote that “the resource claims of core states collide with the subsistence rights of the periphery” (p. 109). And Conca’s discussion of California’s outsourcing of environmental and social costs to other nations that make its relative environmental and economic privilege possible also reflect this dynamic.
Those data seem like evidence for taking seriously the problem of democracies (core states) contributing to, if not producing, the instabilities, violence, and precariousness that lead to failed states, rather than viewing the central problem as an absence of democracies in our quest to secure a sustainable, peaceful, secure, and just future. So why do we assume that the best way to address problems that nation-states have caused is by working through and reinforcing the nation-state form? I do not have the answer, but I am certain that we have only begun to scratch the surface of what may be the defining challenge of twenty-first-century environmental politics. And Conca’s powerful book offers truly important clues as to why we need to ask this question.
