Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T08:30:54.084Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Shear-thickening suspensions down inclines: from Kapitza to Oobleck waves

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 March 2023

Baptiste Darbois Texier
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille University, CNRS, IUSTI, 13453 Marseille, FranceUniversité Paris-Saclay, CNRS, FAST, 91405 Orsay, France
Henri Lhuissier
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille University, CNRS, IUSTI, 13453 Marseille, France
Bloen Metzger
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille University, CNRS, IUSTI, 13453 Marseille, France
Yoël Forterre*
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille University, CNRS, IUSTI, 13453 Marseille, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: yoel.forterre@univ-amu.fr.

Abstract

We investigate experimentally and theoretically the stability of a shear-thickening suspension flowing down an inclined plane. In a previous paper (Darbois Texier et al., Commun. Phys., vol. 3, 2020), we have shown that for particle volume fractions $\phi$ above the discontinuous shear-thickening fraction $\phi _{DST}$, long surface waves grow spontaneously at a flow Reynolds number much below 1. This motivated a simplified analysis based on a purely inertialess mechanism, called the ‘Oobleck waves’ mechanism, which couples the negatively sloped rheology of the suspension with the free-surface deflection and captures well the experimental instability threshold and the wave speed, for $\phi >\phi _{DST}$. However, neglecting inertia does not allow us to describe the inertial Kapitza regime observed for $\phi <\phi _{DST}$, nor does it allow us to discriminate between Oobleck waves and other inertial instabilities expected above $\phi _{DST}$. This paper fills this gap by extending our previous analysis, based on a depth-averaged approach and the Wyart–Cates constitutive shear-thickening rheology, to account for inertia. The extended analysis recovers quantitatively the experimental instability threshold in the Kapitza regime, below $\phi _{DST}$, and in the Oobleck waves regime, above $\phi _{DST}$. By providing additional measurements of the wave growth rate and investigating theoretically the effect of a strain delay in the rheology, it also confirms that the instability observed above $\phi _{DST}$ stems from the non-inertial Oobleck wave mechanism, which is specific to free-surface flows and dominates modes of inertial origin. These results emphasize the variety of instability mechanisms for shear-thickening suspensions and might be relevant to free-surface flows of other complex fluids displaying velocity-weakening rheology.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Rheograms and experiments at low $\phi$ to characterize the Kapitza instability. (a) Image of the cornstarch grains. (b) Rheograms of the aqueous cornstarch suspension for various volume fractions. Solid lines: Wyart–Cates rheology with $\eta _s = 0.91\,{\rm mPa}\,{\rm s}$, $\phi _0 = 0.52$, $\phi _1 = 0.43$ and $\tau ^\ast = 12\,{\rm Pa}$. The region where $\mathrm {d}\tau / \mathrm {d}\dot {\gamma }<0$ is highlighted in blue. (c) Sketch of the set-up used to characterize the instability below $\phi _{DST}$, and a typical picture of the Kapitza waves ($\phi =0.33$, $\theta =2^\circ$, $Re\simeq 37$). (d) Spatio-temporal plots showing the transverse displacement of the intersection between the laser sheet and the flow surface, at the top and at the bottom of the incline ($\phi =0.33$, $\theta =2^\circ$, $Re\simeq 37$). (e) Reynolds number of the flow, and amplitude of the perturbation at the top, $\Delta h_1$, and at the bottom, $\Delta h_2$, of the incline ($\phi =0.36$, $\theta =3^\circ$, $Re\simeq 28$). The black dashed line indicates the instability threshold $Re_c$. Plots (d,e) are reproduced from Darbois Texier et al. (2020).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Experiments at high $\phi$ to characterize the Oobleck waves. (a) Sketch of the set-up used for $\phi >\phi _{DST}$, and a typical image of Oobleck waves ($\phi =0.45$, $\theta =10^\circ$, $Re\simeq 1.14\simeq 0.2\,Re_{Kap}$). (b) Image of the flow surface intersected by the laser sheet (same conditions as in a). (c) Reynolds number of the flow and amplitude of the perturbation $\Delta h_1$ and $\Delta h_2$ (same conditions as in a). The black dashed line indicates the instability threshold $Re_c$. (d) Normalized wave amplitude $\Delta h/h_0$ as a function of $x$ (same $\phi$ and $\theta$, $Re/Re_c=1.05$). The growth rate is measured over the region highlighted in blue.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Sketch of the notations. (b) Velocity profiles of the base flow for the Wyart–Cates rheology with the parameters obtained from figure 1(b) and for various volume fractions ($\tau _{b,0}/\tau ^\ast =2$).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Stability diagram $(Re,A)$ for (a) the kinematic branch, and (b) the inertial branch ($\theta =10^\circ$ and a plug flow profile, $\alpha =1$, is assumed for simplicity; see text). (a) Black line: Kapitza instability threshold ($Re=Re_{Kap}$). Red line: Oobleck waves instability threshold ($A=0$). (b) Dashed blue line: inertial branch instability threshold ($A=0$). (a,b) The green line indicates the Newtonian case ($A=1$). The coloured trajectories indicate the evolution of $Re$ and $A$ for various volume fractions and increasing flow rates (or basal stress $\tau _{b,0}$) ($\theta =10^\circ$, and the rheological parameters are those obtained from figure 1b). For most volume fractions above $\phi _{DST}$, the DST condition $Re = Re_{A=0}$ (i.e. $A=0$) is expected to be reached before (lower flow rate) the Kapitza instability onset ($Re = Re_{Kap})$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Dispersion relations of the two instabilities of the kinematic branch ($\theta =10^\circ$). (a,c) Kapitza instability ($\phi =0.33$). (b,d) Oobleck waves instability ($\phi =0.45$). (a,b) Temporal growth rate $\mathrm {Im} (\tilde {\omega }_1)$. Note the highly different scales of the $y$-axis. (c,d) Wave speed $\tilde {c}_1$. (a–d) The yellow circles indicate the theoretical growth rates, for $Re=1.05\, Re_c$ and at the wavelength observed experimentally, which are compared with measurements in figure 8(b).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Dispersion relation of the inertial branch ($\theta =10^\circ$): (a,c) $\phi =0.33$, (b,d) $\phi =0.45$. (a,b) Temporal growth rate $\mathrm {Im} (\tilde {\omega }_2)$. (c,d) Wave speed $\tilde {c}_2$. The yellow circle indicates the theoretical growth rates, for $Re=1.05\,Re_c$ and at the wavelength observed experimentally, which are compared with measurements in figure 8(b).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Destabilization threshold: comparison with experiments. (a) Critical Reynolds number $Re_c$ normalized by the Newtonian Kapitza threshold $Re_{Kap, Newt}=(5/6)/\tan \theta$ versus volume fraction $\phi$. (b) Critical basal shear stress $\tau _c$ versus $\phi$. The symbols indicate measurements. Their shapes encode the inclination $\theta$: $\diamond$ $2^\circ$, $\triangledown$ $3^\circ$, $\triangleright$ $6^\circ$, $\triangleleft$ $9^\circ$, $\circ$ $10^\circ$, $\triangle$ $22^\circ$. The error bars indicate the standard deviation of the measurements at a given $\phi$. The lines represent the predictions for the different modes (as labelled above the graph), i.e. the critical Reynolds number at which each iso-$\phi$ trajectory (see figure 4) reaches the $Re=Re_{Kap}$ or $Re=Re_{A=0}$ condition. (The black line is interrupted above $\phi \simeq 0.42$ since no steady flow verifies $Re=Re_{Kap}$.) The shear-jamming limit corresponds to the value of the basal shear stress when the flow first jams at $z=0$ (see (3.5)). Inset: basal shear stress $\tau _{b,0}= \rho g h_0 \sin \theta$ versus mean shear rate $u_0/h_0$ for different volume fractions obtained from Wyart–Cates rheological laws (dashed lines) and from direct measurements on the inclined plane (solid lines). The red line and black crosses highlight the condition $\mathrm {d} \tau _b / \mathrm {d} \dot {\gamma }=0$ for both sets of curves.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Wave speed and growth rate: comparison with experiments. (a) Wave speed $c_c$ normalized by the mean fluid velocity $u_c$ at the instability onset versus $\phi$. Inset: normalized wave velocity $c_c/u_c$ versus normalized speed of kinematic waves $c_{{kin}}/u_c$ at the onset. (b) Normalized spatial growth rate $\tilde {\sigma }$ versus $\phi$ for $Re/Re_c=1.05$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Role of a strain delay on stability. Stability diagrams $(Re,A)$ for (a) the kinematic branch and (b) the inertial branch ($\theta =10^\circ$, $\alpha =1$). (a) The grey and red domains indicate the unstable regions for $\gamma _0=0.1$. (b) The blue dashed line is the instability threshold (5.3) for $\gamma _0=0.1$. The coloured lines indicate the system trajectories for increasing flow rate at fixed angle (as in figure 4). The vertical dark lines indicates the Newtonian case ($A=1$). (c) Critical shear stress $\tau _c$, and (d) normalized wave velocity $c_c/u_c$ at the threshold, versus $\phi$. The symbols report the measurements presented in figures 7(b) and 8(c). The black and red lines indicate the predictions for the kinematic branch below and above $\phi _{DST}$, respectively. The blue lines show the predictions for the inertial branch. The colour intensities of the lines correspond to delay strains of $\gamma _0=0.05, 0.1, 0.2$ and $0.5$.

Figure 9

Table 1.Experimental data for surface destabilization of a flow of cornstarch suspension down an inclined plane.