M. Mufakharul Islam's new work is a comprehensive economic history of Bengal during the colonial era, bookended by the Battle of Plassey in 1757 on one end and Independence and Partition in 1947 on the other. His contribution deserves to be welcomed in particular for the careful attention it pays to the regional peculiarities of the Bengali experience: it fills a gap in the economic-historical literature on British India between work that takes a subcontinent-wide view, often masking important dimensions of regional diversity, and work that focuses narrowly on the studies of cities, communities, or sectors, which do not always confront broader historical narratives. A regional history is necessarily a work of compromise on breadth and depth, but as Islam's book suggests, it has the potential to illuminate.
Individual chapters of the book (several of which are reincarnated articles) are primarily standalone treatments of major economic themes; these are arranged in loosely chronological order. Islam's general approach is to state the broad questions that unify a subliterature, to outline the views of participants in the debate, and then to offer his own assessment. He is admirably judicious as a referee, fair-minded in taking on the arguments of the Indian nationalists of the nineteenth century as well as apologists of empire without rancor, and carefully considered his own judgments. Nevertheless, his execution can be uneven; he sometimes fails to provide enough details on the underlying reasons for disagreement between scholars or full explanations for what seem like curt dismissals.
In broad terms, the author distances himself from colorful claims (that Bengal was on the verge of its own Industrial Revolution, for example, or that Bengalis were too effete to be effective entrepreneurs) in favor of a study of the structural causes of underdevelopment. British policy appears repeatedly throughout the story, less as a scapegoat than as a powerful influence shaped by too many interests other than Bengali welfare to have ultimately had a lasting progressive impact. The counterfactual appears to be a progressive interventionist Indian nationalist government, along the lines of Japan's during the Meiji Restoraton, though the political plausibility of such a world remains undefended.
After setting the context of Bengal's economy in the late medieval period (chapter 1) and the political intrigues around the Company's rise to rule and the beginning of the so-called economic drain (chapter 2), Islam deals primarily with agricultural issues (over eight chapters) and secondarily with industrial development (over two chapters). The final chapters constitute standalone assessments of the Famine of 1943 and the railway network. An oddly placed but fascinating appendix documents the changing views of Karl Marx over his lifetime about the impact of British rule in India, as his progressive and constructive interpretation gave way to one that was more pessimistic and cynical.
On the topic of agriculture, much of what makes Bengal unique was the complex trajectory taken by tenurial arrangements, agricultural commercialization, and land, credit and labor markets following the Permanent Settlement of 1793. This radical experiment saw the British create a landed gentry, endowed with property rights and tax rates fixed in perpetuity, for reasons economic (providing incentives for landlords to invest and for the emergence of a land market) as well as political and fiscal. The following century and a half proved the British wrong: Islam demonstrates that agricultural output growth was driven by the extension of land and not by improvement in yields (chapter 4) and the landlords largely failed to live up to expectations in playing a positive role in agricultural transformation (chapter 12).
Nevertheless, there were important substantive changes in the organization of agriculture in this period: Islam describes the baroque system of subinfeudation that arose, featuring long chains of intermediaries between a revenue-paying landlord and his rent-paying tenant (chapter 3) and documents trends in land transfers that saw the emergence of richer peasants and share-cropping (chapter 7). The portrait he paints of the commercialization of agriculture (chapter 9) emphasizes the heterogeneity of responses, with larger farmers responding freely to profit opportunities and only smaller ones “forced” into market production by their debt and rent obligations. British policy towards tenure itself shifted (chapter 8), with the enactment of increasingly tenant-friendly laws from the mid-nineteenth century onwards, and concerns about chronic indebtedness manifested themselves in credit market regulation and the creation of cooperative credit societies and debt settlement boards in the early twentieth century (chapter 10). Despite a credit crunch and falling prices, production remained steady through the Great Depression (chapter 11), though the author highlights links events of this period with the continued ascent of communalism, cleaving Hindu landlords from Muslim tenants.
In discussing industrial development, Islam begins with an analysis of the decline of traditional industries, primarily textiles (chapter 3). He is skeptical of deep structural or cultural explanations, noting that they could also be made of many other now-industrial nations in their past, and focuses on British policy, whether actively hostile (as in the case of trade barriers) or merely neglectful (as in the case of financial institutions and physical infrastructure). His second major theme is the underdevelopment of industrial entrepreneurship amongst Bengalis (chapter 6). The standard accounts emphasize discrimination, but Islam also points out that Bengalis had open to them alternative sources of both investment (land) and prestige (civil professions).
Finally, in his standalone chapters, Islam takes on Amartya Sen's seminal analysis of the 1943 Famine (chapter 14), his primary contention being that Sen's view of the famine, while essentially correct, is unoriginal. On the railways (chapter 15), the author emphasizes the maladaptation of the network, in design, construction and use, for Indian development.
The book is aimed primarily at undergraduate students and their instructors in economic history; graduate students and researchers will also find this a starting point for further study, though it is more thorough in its engagement with the secondary literature through the 1990s than with work over the last decade. In addition, those working on contemporary Bengal and Bangladesh will find this a useful primer on the broader context of their development trajectories.
