Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T02:23:19.018Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Impact of surface viscosity on the stability of a droplet translating through a stagnant fluid

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 October 2021

Natasha Singh
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, 480 Stadium Mall Drive, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
Vivek Narsimhan*
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, 480 Stadium Mall Drive, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: vnarsim@purdue.edu

Abstract

This study examines the impact of interfacial viscosity on the stability of an initially deformed droplet translating through an unbounded quiescent fluid. The boundary-integral formulation is employed to investigate the time evolution of a droplet in the Stokes flow limit. The droplet interface is modelled using the Boussinesq–Scriven constitutive relationship having surface shear viscosity $\eta _\mu$ and surface dilatational viscosity $\eta _\kappa$. We observe that, below a critical value of the capillary number, $Ca_C$, the initially perturbed droplet reverts to its spherical shape. Above $Ca_C$, the translating droplet deforms continuously, growing a tail at the rear end for initial prolate perturbations and a cavity for initial oblate perturbations. We find that surface shear viscosity inhibits the tail/cavity growth at the droplet's rear end and increases the $Ca_C$ compared with a clean droplet. In contrast, surface dilatational viscosity increases tail/cavity growth and lowers $Ca_C$ compared with a clean droplet. Surprisingly, both shear and dilatational surface viscosity appear to delay the time at which pinch off occurs, and hence satellite droplets form. Lastly, we explore the combined influence of surface viscosity and surfactant transport on droplet stability by assuming a linear dependence of surface tension on surfactant concentration and exponential dependence of interfacial viscosities on the surface pressure. We find that pressure-thinning/thickening effects significantly affect the droplet dynamics for surface shear viscosity but play a small role for surface dilatational viscosity. We lastly provide phase diagrams for the critical capillary number for different values of the droplet's viscosity ratio and initial Taylor deformation parameter.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.$(a)$ Problem set-up. $(b)$ Schematic of the droplet interface (axisymmetric about the $z$-axis) discretized into $N+1$ elements connected by the $N+1$ nodes in the $z$–$r$ azimuthal plane.

Figure 1

Table 1.Dimensionless parameters.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Value of $Ca_C$ vs $\varDelta$ for a clean droplet at viscosity ratio values $\lambda = 0.5$, 1 and 5. The dashed curves are from Koh & Leal (1989), and the dots represent our numerical results.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Streamline pattern for $(a)$ an unstable initial prolate droplet ($\varDelta =0.2$, $\lambda =1$, $Ca = 4.5$ and $t = 10$) and $(b)$ an unstable initial oblate droplet ($\varDelta =-0.2$, $\lambda =1$, $Ca=4.5$ and $t = 13$). The red dot depicts the stagnation point in the flow. The flow fields are computed in the frame of reference of the front tip of the translating droplet.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Time evolution of two initially prolate droplets having the same viscosity ratio, initial perturbation and capillary number ($\lambda = 0.5$, $\varDelta = 0.2$ and $Ca = 2.6$). $(a)$ Clean droplet: $Bq_\mu =0$, $Bq_\kappa =0$ (i.e. $Bq=0$). $(b)$ Droplet with interfacial shear viscosity: $Bq_\mu =1.5$, $Bq_\kappa =0$ (i.e. $Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0)$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Value of $Ca_C$ vs $Bq_\mu$ at viscosity ratio values $\lambda =$ 0.5, 1 and 5. The deformation parameter is $\varDelta =0.4$ and $Bq_{\kappa } = 0$ (i.e. $\lambda _{ds}=0$).

Figure 6

Figure 6.Value if $Ca_C$ vs $Bq_\mu$ at different values of deformation parameter $\varDelta$ ($0.1 \leq \varDelta \leq 0.6$). The viscosity ratio is $\lambda =1$ and $Bq_{\kappa } = 0$ (i.e. $\lambda _{ds}=0$).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Time evolution of two initially oblate droplets having the same viscosity ratio, initial perturbation and capillary number ($\lambda = 1$, $\varDelta = -0.6$ and $Ca = 2.5$). $(a)$ Clean droplet: $Bq_\mu =0$, $Bq_\kappa =0$ (i.e. $Bq=0$). $(b)$ Droplet with shear viscosity: $Bq_\mu =1.5$, $Bq_\kappa =0$ (i.e. $Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0)$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Value if $Ca_C$ vs $\varDelta$ at $\lambda =1$ (green curves) and $\lambda =5$ (blue curves). The dashed curves represent results for clean droplet ($Bq=0$) and the bold curves are for droplet with surface shear viscosity ($Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0)$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Effect of the surface shear viscosity on an unstable droplet with initial prolate perturbation ($\varDelta =0.4$) at $Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$, $Ca=2.0$, $\lambda =1$ and $t=16$. $(a)$ Streamline pattern inside and outside the droplet (computed via boundary-integral equation inside and outside the drop). The flow fields are drawn in the frame of reference of the front tip of the translating droplet. $(b)$ Vectors over the droplet's surface represent the computed traction $\boldsymbol {f}_{\mu }$ from interfacial shear viscosity. The blue arrows act as a guide to the eye to show the existing fluid flow inside the droplet.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Time evolution of two unstable droplets with the same initial prolate shape ($\varDelta = 0.4$), same viscosity ratio ($\lambda = 0.5$) and same capillary number ($Ca = 2.0$). $(a)$ Clean droplet $Bq_{\mu } = 0,\ Bq_{\kappa } = 0$. $(b)$ Droplet with surface shear viscosity ($\lambda _{ds}=0)$$Bq_{\mu } = 2.0,\ Bq_{\kappa } = 0$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Effect of the surface shear viscosity on an unstable droplet with an initial oblate perturbation ($\varDelta =-0.4$) at $Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$, $Ca=3.0$, $\lambda =5$ and $t=25$. $(a)$ Streamline pattern inside and outside the droplet (computed via boundary-integral equation inside and outside the drop). The flow fields are drawn in the frame of reference of the front tip of the translating droplet. $(b)$ Vectors over the droplet's surface represent the computed traction $\boldsymbol {f_\mu }$ from interfacial shear viscosity. The blue arrows act as a guide to the eye to show the existing fluid flow inside the droplet.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Value of $Ca_C$ vs $Bq_\kappa$ at viscosity ratio values $\lambda = 0.5$, 1 and 5. The shear Boussinesq number is $Bq_\mu =0$ (i.e. $\lambda _{ds} = \infty$). $(a)$ The initial deformation is $\varDelta =0.2$. $(b)$ The initial deformation is $\varDelta =0.4$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Value of $Ca_C$ vs $\varDelta$ at $\lambda =0.5$ (blue curves) and $\lambda =5$ (red curves). The dashed curves represent results for a clean droplet ($Bq=0$) and the bold curves represent results for a droplet with surface dilatational viscosity ($Bq=0.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$).

Figure 14

Figure 14.Effect of the surface dilatational viscosity on an unstable droplet with initial prolate perturbation ($\varDelta = 0.4$) at $Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$, $Ca=2.0$, $\lambda =1$ and $t=10$. $(a)$ Streamline pattern inside and outside the droplet (computed via boundary-integral equation inside and outside the drop). The flow fields are drawn in the frame of reference of the front tip of the translating droplet. $(b)$ Vectors over the droplet's surface represent the computed traction $\boldsymbol {f_\kappa }$ from interfacial dilatational viscosity. The blue arrows act as a guide to the eye to show the existing fluid flow inside the droplet.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Variation of surface divergence of interfacial velocity $\boldsymbol {\nabla _{s}} \boldsymbol {\cdot } \boldsymbol {u_{s}}$ with axial position coordinate $z$ for the droplet's upper half overlayed with the droplet shape.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Effect of the surface dilatational viscosity on an unstable droplet with initial oblate perturbation ($\varDelta =-0.4$) at $Bq=0.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$, $Ca=2.0$, $\lambda =5$ and $t=25$. $(a)$ Streamline pattern inside and outside the droplet (computed via boundary-integral equation inside and outside the drop). The flow fields are drawn in the frame of reference of the front tip of the translating droplet. $(b)$ Vectors over the droplet's surface represent the computed traction $\boldsymbol {f_\kappa }$ from interfacial dilatational viscosity (traction vectors are shown only in the droplet's upper half). The blue arrows act as a guide to the eye to show the existing fluid flow inside the droplet.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Value of $Ca_C$ vs $\lambda _{ds}$ for a fixed $Bq = Bq_{\kappa } + Bq_{\mu }$. The dimensionless parameters are: $\lambda =1$ and $\varDelta =0.2$, and we show results for $Bq =1.0$ (blue curve) and $Bq=0.2$ (red curve). The critical capillary number of a clean droplet with $\lambda =1$ and $\varDelta =0.2$ is $Ca_C=2.185$ (shown in black dashed line).

Figure 18

Figure 18.Time evolution of an initially prolate droplet that is unstable ($\lambda = 1$, $\varDelta = 0.4$, $Ca = 2$) for three different cases; $(a)$ clean droplet $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$, $(b)$ droplet with surface dilatational viscosity ($Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$) $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 1.5$ and $(c)$ droplet with surface shear viscosity ($Bq=1.5$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) $Bq_{\mu }= 1.5,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Variation of surface divergence of interfacial velocity $\boldsymbol {\nabla _{s}} \boldsymbol {\cdot } \boldsymbol {u_{s}}$ with axial position coordinate $z$ for the droplet's upper half overlayed with the droplet shapes shown in figure 18$(b)$ at times $t=0$, 10 and 22.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Time evolution of an initially oblate droplet that is unstable ($\lambda = 1$, $\varDelta = -0.2$, $Ca = 4.5$) for three different cases; $(a)$ clean droplet $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$, $(b)$ droplet with surface dilatational viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$) $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 1$ and $(c)$ droplet with surface shear viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) $Bq_{\mu }= 1,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Time evolution of an initially prolate droplet with $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.2$, $Pe_s=1$, $\beta =0.2$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$ for three cases: $(a)$ clean droplet $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$, $(b)$ droplet with surface dilatational viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$) $Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 1.0$ and $(c)$ droplet with surface shear viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) $Bq_{\mu }= 1.0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Plot of non-dimensional surfactant concentration $\varGamma$ vs normalized arclength $s$ at $Pe_s=1$ and $Pe_s=50$ for a clean droplet ($Bq=0$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) and droplet with surface dilatational viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=\infty$) at time $t=13$. The dimensionless parameters are: $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.2$, $\beta =0.2$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$. The arclength is $s=0$ at the front tip and $s=1$ at the trailing tip of the translating droplet. The corresponding droplet shapes with $Pe_s=1$ and $Pe_s=50$ at time $t=13$ are shown alongside the plot; $(a)$$Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 1$, $(b)$$Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$.

Figure 23

Figure 23.Time evolution of an unstable, initially prolate droplet with only surface shear viscosity for three cases: $(a)$$Bq_\mu =0$, $(b)$$Bq_\mu =2$ and $(c)$$Bq_\mu =4$. The values of dimensionless parameters are: $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.4$, $Pe_s=1$, $\beta =0.2$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$.

Figure 24

Figure 24.Plot of non-dimensional surfactant concentration $\varGamma$ vs normalized arclength $s$ at $Pe_s=1$ and $Pe_s=100$ for a clean droplet ($Bq=0$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) and droplet with surface shear viscosity ($Bq=1.0$, $\lambda _{ds}=0$) at time $t=13$. The dimensionless parameters are: $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.4$, $\beta =0.2$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$. The arclength is $s=0$ at the front tip and $s=1$ at the trailing tip of the translating droplet. The corresponding droplet shapes with $Pe_s=1$ and $Pe_s=100$ at time $t=13$ are shown alongside the plot; $(a)$$Bq_{\mu }= 2,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$, $(b)$$Bq_{\mu }= 0,\ Bq_{\kappa }= 0$.

Figure 25

Figure 25.$(a)$ Droplet elongation in the streamwise direction $d$ as a function of non-dimensional time $t$ for $\varPi$-thickening surfactant (shown as red curve), $\varPi$-independent surfactant (shown as black curve) and $\varPi$-thinning surfactant (shown as blue curve). The dimensionless parameters are $Pe_s=10$, $\beta =0.2$, $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.4$, $Bq_\kappa ^0=1$, $Bq_\mu ^0=0$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$. The droplet shape shown below the plot is at time $t=6.5$ for the $\varPi$-independent surfactant. $(b)$ Variation of $Bq_\kappa$ and surface concentration $\varGamma$ with the normalized arclength $s$ corresponding to the droplet shapes at time $t=6.5$.

Figure 26

Figure 26.Droplet elongation in the streamwise direction $d$ as a function of the non-dimensional time $t$ for $\varPi$-thickening surfactants ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$ and $\varPi _c^\ast =0.5$, shown as red curves), $\varPi$-independent surfactant (shown as black curve) and $\varPi$-thinning surfactants ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$ and $\varPi _c^\ast =0.5$, shown as blue curves) with $(a)$$\beta =0.2$ and $(b)$$\beta =0.8$. For both the plots $(a{,}b)$, the dimensionless parameters are $Pe_s=10$, $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.4$, $Bq_\kappa ^0=0$, $Bq_\mu ^0=1$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$. The droplet shapes shown below the plots are at time $t=16$ for $\varPi$-thinning surfactant ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$) and $\varPi$-thickening surfactant ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$) at $\beta$ values 0.2 and 0.8.

Figure 27

Figure 27.Variation of $Bq_\mu$ and surface concentration $\varGamma$ with normalized arclength $s$ for the droplet shapes at time $t=16$ for $\varPi$-thickening surfactants ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$ and $\varPi _c^\ast =0.5$, shown as red curves), $\varPi$-independent surfactant (shown as black curve) and $\varPi$-thinning surfactants ($\varPi _c^\ast =0.2$ and $\varPi _c^\ast =0.5$, shown as blue curves) with $(a)$$\beta =0.2$ and $(b)$$\beta =0.8$. For both the plots $(a{,}b)$, the dimensionless parameters are $Pe_s=10$, $\lambda =1$, $\varDelta =0.4$, $Bq_\kappa ^0=0$, $Bq_\mu ^0=1$ and $Ca^\ast =2.5$.