New York Recentered presents a bold history of urban planning in New York City. Instead of giving pride of place to the master builder Robert Moses, Kara Murphy Schlichting brings to the fore a variety of others (among them wealthy benefactors, professional planners, and immigrant working-class beachgoers) who attempted to shape New York City’s expansion beyond the island of Manhattan in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Schlichting sets her history of greater New York along the city’s coastal periphery of the upper East River and Long Island Sound, territory that encompasses the outer boroughs of Queens and the Bronx and their suburbs. It is these peripheral regions, and not Manhattan, she argues, that hold the key to understanding the making of the modern, metropolitan city.
Schlichting begins her book with examples of what she calls benefactor planning, processes by which “civic-minded capitalists” exert control over real estate and public works (16). In 1879, the piano manufacturer William Steinway of Steinway & Sons chose the isolated marshland of Astoria, Queens, as the ideal location to build a model company town. Steinway was looking to escape the labor strife associated with Manhattan, and the area’s “boggy waterfront” presented a natural border that would keep out “anarchists and socialists” (22). Steinway funded marsh drainage, landfill operations, and street grading to improve parts of the shoreline and prepare it for residential, commercial, and industrial use. He consolidated the existing rail networks into the Steinway Rail Company and promoted a variety of bridge, tunnel, and ferry projects so that his firm could have access to Manhattan’s commercial networks and capital. While he hoped to isolate his workforce from Manhattan (although how he planned to keep his workforce from using these same bridges and ferries is unclear), the company would have ready access to the urban core across the river.
Schlichting describes Steinway’s efforts in Queens as paternalistic, but she draws a distinction between Steinway’s paternalism and that exhibited by fellow benefactor George Pullman and his company town outside of Chicago. Pullman attempted to strictly control his workers’ social lives by, among other things, banning the consumption of alcohol. In Steinway’s settlement, workers had more autonomy. They could own their own homes and partake of robust cultural amenities, including a waterfront resort with a German beer garden. Schlichting’s argument that Steinway’s efforts were less coercive than Pullman’s is convincing, but Schlichting offers no comment on what effects Steinway’s settlement might have had on the larger workers’ movement in New York. The workers who gravitated to Queens might have benefited, but at what cost to labor’s push for unionization and the eight-hour workday?
Alongside Steinway’s private benefactor planning, professional urban planning from within city government also came into its own in the late nineteenth century. This trend is exemplified by the career of Andrew Haswell Green, the park commissioner who led a thirty-year campaign to turn New York into a “regionally scaled city” (48). Schlichting examines Green’s work in southern Westchester County, the future South Bronx. Here, Green experimented with planning that sought to “escape the grid” of Manhattan. The street grid system of 1811, which had paved the way for the island’s rapid growth, was portrayed as too haphazard and responsible for overcrowding and coastal pollution. Green, like Steinway, sought a new approach that would offer an “alternative urban experience that improved the city’s physical conditions and its residents’ way of life” (53).
New York State laws from 1865 to 1871 gave Green’s parks department significant new powers that he sought to apply in southern Westchester County, largely to reduce pollution in the Harlem and Bronx Rivers, which threatened area residents’ health. He sought to annex southern Westchester to New York for this reason; he had little faith that a local, piecemeal approach to pollution would be able to keep the city’s coastal hinterlands and rivers systems clean. Green’s efforts here aligned with the urban vision of a wide array of Westchesterites (businessmen, politicians, and residents) who believed that strengthened ties with the city would benefit their community. The overlapping goals of local citizens and planners resulted in the official annexation of southern Westchester to New York City in 1873. Green’s work in the peripheral region of what later became the Bronx, along with Steinway’s efforts in Queens, anticipated the much larger consolidation that occurred in 1898, when forty municipalities combined to form Greater New York, creating the five-borough city we know today. As Schlichting puts it, “the majority of the city now lay in the new boroughs” (79).
Not all of New York’s growth at the time was planned. An alternative model of improvised, bottom-up development can be glimpsed along the upper East River and Long Island Sound. There, immigrant workers craving access to nature flocked to the beaches of Westchester and the Bronx, where they erected modest bungalow camps in the early 1900s. Over many seasons, these camps evolved into permanent blue-collar suburbs with their own vernacular streetscape. Meanwhile, the antithesis of working-class suburbanization emerged on the North Shore of Long Island, as the nation’s richest citizens did everything in their power to block public access to their secluded coastline and ward off the expanding regional city—actions Schlichting describes as “defensive localism” (161).
The 1920s saw a similar defensiveness, this time over race, when African American real estate developer Solomon Riley strove to create a Black leisure scene around a beach and amusement park on the upper East River. Predictably, he faced a racist backlash from white civic groups and city officials, which put an end to his efforts.
In addition to an account of urban and suburban development, New York Recentered offers compelling insights into the region’s environmental history. Schlichting writes vividly on Greater New York’s harbor, rivers, marshlands, beaches, and parks, and even devotes a few paragraphs to the science of sea breezes. Although the city’s marshes have been lost to landfill over the years, efforts are now underway to revive them. A recent walk along the Queens side of the East River revealed to this reviewer a vast salt marsh full of lush grass, native flowers, and hundreds of butterflies. Schlichting could have had more to say about the future of such coastal reclamation projects. Her conclusion highlights the harmful consequences of exclusion (both class- and race-based) and overdevelopment but does not imagine what a more equitable and sustainable model of growth might look like. Still, with this book in hand, scholars, urban planners, and concerned citizens will find plenty of lessons to draw from.
