More than forty years after its last scholarly history, Ahmedabad is now the subject of not one but two separate urban biographies, both published in 2011 in concert with the city's 600th anniversary: Ahmedabad: Shock City of Twentieth-Century India, by historian Howard Spodek, and Ahmedabad: From Royal City to Megacity, by scholars Achyut Yagnik and Suchitra Sheth. Written by authors with long roots in the city—Spodek has visited and researched Ahmedabad since the 1960s, while Yagnik and Sheth have spent much of their adult lives there—both books bring welcome new attention to the history of the city. But, Spodek argues, it is not just those attached to Ahmedabad who should be interested in these histories. Utilizing Asa Brigg's idea of a “shock city”—a city that brings to the surface, and attempts to solve, new social and political problems—Spodek claims that throughout the twentieth century Ahmedabad was “a crucible in the development of an entire nation” (p. 16), “on the cutting edge” (p. 5) of events in India. According to Spodek, events in Ahmedabad often set the stage for national developments, whether in experiments with Gandhian politics in the 1920s or, more negatively, violent caste and religious politics since the 1980s.
Whether considering the city on its own or to draw broader conclusions, the two books offer profoundly different examples of writing Ahmedabad's history. In Ahmedabad: Shock City, Spodek focuses exclusively on the twentieth century, utilizing a biographical approach to tell the city's story through the actions of some of its most important citizens. Arguing that “from the age of Gandhi until the 1970s, Ahmedabad had a small circle of leaders who guided the city's development” (p. 16), Spodek emphasizes how politicians, activists, and industrialists in the 1920s and 1930s forged a relatively cohesive civic order, a cohesion that gave way to fractured, segregated disunity by the 1980s.
In the first section of the book, “The Gandhian Era,” Spodek explores Gandhi's role in creating a new civic order after his arrival in the city in 1915, crediting Gandhi for inspiring a new generation of leaders (many of whom were personally related) (chapter 2), more assertive politics of both anti-colonialism (chapter 3) and class (chapter 4), and a new culture of cooperation that enabled the city's major institutions to work together. The second section, “The Westernizing City,” examines the possibilities of cohesion under a new generation of Ahmedabadis between 1950 and 1980, when the city embraced the new in education (with the founding of the Indian Institute of Management, the National Institute of Design, the Physical Research Laboratory, and other institutions), economics (as industrial houses diversified their portfolios; chapter 5), and the politics of place (as popular protests forced the creation of a separate state for Gujarat in 1960; chapter 6). In the final section, “Creativity and Chaos,” Spodek traces the growing divisiveness in Ahmedabadi civic life since major communal riots convulsed the city in 1969. That shift, he argues, is due to the decline of both the consensus-based leadership style of the Gandhian era (chapter 8) and the key institutions that had earlier governed the city, whether the Millowners' Association and the Textile Labor Association (chapter 9) or the increasingly ineffective Municipal Corporation (chapter 11). The book's final chapter, on the pogrom against Muslims launched in 2002, stands as the ultimate expression of the bankruptcy of civic leadership, detailing a period when Ahmedabad's political class allowed and encouraged the massacre of the city's Muslim inhabitants.
Yagnik and Sheth's book, Ahmedabad: From Royal City to Megacity, is a broader book than Spodek's, tackling the entire history of the city from 1411 to the present and introducing a wider range of themes, actors, and developments. Emphasizing diversity and cosmopolitan ties to the wider world, Yagnik and Sheth present Ahmedabad less as a city defined by its central institutions and leaders than as a multicentered, multivocal, often messy mosaic of ideas, images, reactions, and politics.
The book is structured in three parts, with occasional thematic chapters in the first two parts giving way to a more strictly chronological organization in the third. The first five chapters cover the first four centuries of the city's history, exploring separately Ahmedabad's founding and early politics (chapter 1), social and religious diversity (chapter 2), economic and trade conditions (chapter 3), and cultural synthesis (chapter 5), as well as the political and environmental upheavals and troubles of the eighteenth century that preceded British rule (chapter 4). The second section explores the nineteenth century and all of the new influences, ideas, and movements that it inaugurated, from the onset of British rule in 1817 (chapter 6) to modern education and print (chapter 7), new images and ways of seeing the city (chapter 8), the growth of industrialization and the industrial working class (chapter 9), and the inauguration of the new politics of anticolonialism from the 1870s to the early 1900s (chapter 10). The third and final section addresses Ahmedabad from the arrival of Gandhi to the present. Here the authors note new energies and initiatives, including the inspiration Gandhi offered to activists in the city (chapter 11), the development of city services and cooperative housing through the 1930s (pp. 225–28), and new educational institutions (216–18, 246–49). But Yagnik and Sheth also emphasize the early roots (pp. 237–39, 268–79) of later violent caste and communal politics, which built up in the 1970s and 1980s through a toxic combination of spatial segregation (pp. 257–59, 285–86), corruption (pp. 260–61), and an informalizing economy (pp. 302–4). As they put it, “By the end of the twentieth century we see a divided Ahmedabad, torn apart by violence in multiple forms; and while the causes for that violence might have had deep roots in the past, its gruesome expression had much to do with Ahmedabad's experiences as a modern city” (p. 272).
Like so many urban histories of South Asia, these two books are marked by nostalgia for earlier forms of urbanism. For Spodek, Ahmedabad's golden age was from the 1920s to the 1950s, when close-knit leaders inspired by Gandhi governed a functioning city and introduced pioneering initiatives in politics, labor organizing, and education. For Yagnik and Sheth, the golden age came earlier, in the late nineteenth century's vibrancy of ideas and diversity of approaches, when—despite real and pressing problems—the changes introduced across society could be accommodated within a broad and flexible urban fabric. And yet, although pessimistic about the recent past, both books also offer some hope for the future, noting how Ahmedabadis have reshaped their city historically through a range of popular movements and are experimenting with new forms of civic action to meet the challenges of the present (Spodek, p. 246; Yagnik and Sheth, p. 306).
Offering different approaches and emphases, the two books complement one another, filling out the story of Ahmedabad, while also demonstrating the options available for writing city histories via biographies or a more mosaic approach. As such, both books will be of interest to scholars of urban history, local and national politics, and popular movements in South Asia.
