Paul Rahe, Charles O. Lee and Louise K. Lee Chair in Western Heritage at Hillsdale College, has written a book on Montesquieu's views on the challenges facing modern democratic republics. The text is divided into three books, parts of two of which were previously published. The goal of the study, along with a similar work by the author published in 2009, is to uncover “a political science and an account of the political psychology of liberal democratic man sufficient to enable us to recognize the plight that we are now in, so that we can come to grips with the peculiar maladies that give rise to the present discontents” (x).
Book one of the text, titled “The Modern Republic Discovered,” is comprised of three chapters. The initial chapter compares the life and writings of Montesquieu with those of a fellow French political philosopher, Voltaire. Born within five years of one another in the late seventeenth century, Montesquieu and Voltaire witnessed the British victory over France in the War of Spanish Succession. Because “both thought it essential to come to an understanding of the political regime that had so humiliated the nation into which they had been born” (17), Voltaire and Montesquieu visited England and subsequently recorded their observations.
According to Montesquieu, the introduction of artillery and firearms, the influence of Christianity, and an uneven level of prosperity prevented universal monarchy from being achieved in modern Europe. The second chapter examines Montesquieu's analysis of the rise and fall of the Roman republic. Whereas Rome's greatness was achieved by the combination of statecraft and military skill, its demise was caused by a decline in mores and a dilution of citizenship bonds. In the third chapter, the author applies Montesquieu's writings to trace the fate of Carthage, Athens, and the republics of medieval and modern Italy. What sets these regions apart from modern England is the latter's ability to self-correct its laws, according to Montesquieu.
Book two of the study, titled “The Modern Explored,” includes chapters covering principles, uneasiness, partisanship, and corruption. Montesquieu differentiates the nature or structure of government from its principles, or that which makes it act. Among the primary principles he discusses are virtue and honor. In order to achieve civic virtue, there must be adherence to laws, an emphasis on the public over private interest, and pursuit of equality. Next, Montesquieu assesses the uneasiness or tension between constitutional political liberty on the one hand and citizens' political liberty on the other. Though uneasiness could lead to occasional panic, the English “separation of powers gives direction to these popular fears. It does so by way of the partisanship that it fosters” (114). For Montesquieu, partisanship in British politics is both fundamental and far reaching, for it affects mores, manners, and character. Finally, Montesquieu assesses the impetus and impact of corruption on democratic republics and monarchies alike.
Book three of the text, titled “The Modern Republic in Prospect,” encompasses four chapters. Collectively, the information gathered here evaluates what traits will facilitate future success within republics. For England—which Montesquieu regards as a republic disguised as a monarchy—the features of geography, climate, advancement of commerce and trade, gradual reforms, and a general spirit are viewed as advantageous to long-term liberty and survivability.
In a short segment (“Aftermath”) at the end of the text, Rahe returns to the concept of corruption. He repeats Montesquieu's earlier warning that even a republic faces destruction when legislative power becomes more corrupt than executive power. Rahe concludes that it “should be evident that the future of mankind depends on the well-being of the modern republic and that we need to know more about the peculiar species of corruption to which it is prone” (241).
Apart from Rahe's own work on Montesquieu, there have been five other major single-author books on Montesquieu over the last decade. Of these, the most recent is French Political Thought from Montesquieu to Tocqueville: Liberty in a Levelled Society? by Annelien de Dijn (Cambridge University Press, 2008). Like de Dijn's study, two other books on Montesquieu compare him to other political thinkers: Paul Carrese's The Cloaking of Power: Montesquieu, Blackstone, and the Rise of Judicial Activism (University of Chicago Press, 2003) compares the views of Montesquieu and Blackstone on the rise of judicial activism, while Louis Althusser's Politics and History: Montesquieu, Rousseau, and Marx (Verso, 2007) examines the writings of Marx and Rousseau together with those of Montesquieu. While Carrese's book is closest to Rahe's in length at 312 pages, the most similar in content to Rahe is David Carrithers's Montesquieu's Science of Politics (Rowman and Littlefied, 2000). Both Carrithers and Rahe dedicate substantial parts of their studies to an analysis of Montesquieu's seminal work, The Spirit of Laws. Though not a multiauthor collection, the Carrithers study does include contributions from two other writers, including Rahe.
Rahe's present work constitutes a major contribution to the literature on Montesquieu. The book is organized well; material is meticulously cited; and the variety of Montesquieu's writings included in the tome is indeed impressive. Methodologically, Rahe separates Montesquieu's notes from his published works, an important distinction.
There are a few shortcomings in the current text. For one, Rahe identifies partisanship as one of the challenges confronting modern republics. Yet his description of the workings of partisanship in England is overwhelmingly positive. Further, Rahe promises to compare Montesquieu to other French political philosophers besides Voltaire, but comes up short doing so at the conclusion of the book. Although Rahe does compare Montesquieu to diverse French intellectuals in his other 2009 book, Soft Despotism, Democracy's Drift: Montesquieu, Rousseau, Tocqueville, and the Modern Prospect (Yale University Press), one should not have to purchase the companion text to discern their respective positions.
Aside from its explication of Montesquieu's views, the benefit of the book is to verify the vulnerability yet invaluableness of democratic republics as a type of government.
