Defining “the real” for the stage depends on not only the viewer, but also the creator. The idea of “real” is an ever-changing amalgamation of truths, lies, and everything in between. “Real” or documentary theatre, as it is sometimes referred to in Carol Martin's Dramaturgy of the Real on the World Stage, is a continuously dynamic art form, growing and changing as technology and the world around us develops. Martin's book brings to life a collection of international examples of modern “real” theatre. The book is divided into two parts: the first comprises six essays describing different examples and definitions of documentary theatre, and the second presents seven texts that are examples of documentary theatre. In her appropriately lengthy introduction, Martin acquaints us with her definition of the real, and the constructs in which the idea of the real lives. One of her initial points—a point to which she returns throughout the book—is that, within real (or documentary) theatre, falsities are inseparably intermingled with truths. In addition to the introduction, Martin also authors the book's first chapter, which outlines the functions of documentary theatre. These initial writings help make the essays and texts that follow more digestible for the reader.
In the book's second essay, “Toward a Poetics of Theater and Public Events: In the Case of Stephen Lawrence,” Janelle Reinelt uses the 1993 racially motivated murder of Lawrence, as well as its legal, political, and dramatic aftermath, to explain what documentary theatre represents for her. Grounded in impressive research, Reinelt's in-depth analysis covers the specifics of the actual incident, its bungled investigation and resultant series of failed civil charges, and, finally, the 1997 inquest that confirmed serious flaws in the police investigation. She also discusses the subsequent documentary play The Colour of Justice (1999) and the television docudrama The Murder of Stephen Lawrence (1999)—the “art objects made out of the events” (29) of the Lawrence case.
The third essay, Wendy S. Hesfords's “Staging Terror,” focuses on the 2004 photographs of prisoner torture at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq through examination of the exhibit Inconvenient Evidence: Iraqi Prison Photographs from Abu Ghraib (mounted at the International Center for Photography in New York, fall 2004) and Brittain and Slovo's documentary play Guantanamo: Honor Bound to Defend Freedom (2004). She posits that the two pieces cause their spectators to question human rights violations and to rethink their inactivity as citizens. Hesfords's prose is so evocative that even readers who have not seen the photographs or the exhibit can follow her analysis, making this a particularly rewarding explanation of documentary theatre.
The final three essays in the book focus on documentary theatre from South Africa, Poland, and Germany, respectively. In “Post-1990s Verbatim Theatre in South Africa: Exploring an African Concept of ‘Truth’,” Yvette Hutchison focuses on the South African postapartheid Truth and Reconciliation Committee (TRC), and “the so-called TRC plays” (63) that grew out of its final reports. These plays often use the testimony of actual survivors and perpetrators of violence or stories about violations of basic human rights that are reported to the TRC. This essay is followed by “Reality from the Bottom Up: Documentary Theatre in Poland,” by Agnieszka Sowińska and translated by Benjamin Paloff. In the final chapter of Part I, “The Scripted Realities of Rimini Protokoll,” Florian Malzacher offers strong examples of theatre makers using “regular” people rather than actors to create documentary theatre. Like all the essays in the book, Malzacher's provides an important global outlook on documentary theatre.
Part II focuses on actual texts or excerpts of texts that exhibit the qualities of documentary drama described in Part I; each is prefaced by a short essay discussing it in performance and theory. The texts are Philip Miller's REwind: A Cantata for Voice, Tape and Testimony; Adelheid Roosen's Is.Man; Three Posters: A Performance/Video, by Elias Khoury and Rabih Mroués (translated by Mona Abou Rayyan); Teatr Ósmego Dnia's The Files (translated by Bill Johnston); Don't Be Surprised When They Come to Burn Your House Down, by Paweł Demirski, in collaboration with Paulina Murawska; Art, Life & Show-Biz, by Ain Gordon; and excerpts from the plays of Vivi Tellas, translated by Sarah J. Townsend. Although all are clearly superior examples of documentary theatre, I found them at times difficult to comprehend solely as written works. Since none of these performance texts is the counterpart of an essay from the first part of the book, knowledge of the circumstances they portray is limited to the short introduction preceding each, and this context proves insufficient in some cases.
Nevertheless, Martin has collected a wide range of materials that, assembled together, clearly and concisely represent documentary theatre as it is being produced and performed internationally today. The book will undoubtedly prove useful to many, both in and out of the academy.
