When doors began to slam shut on Jews fleeing Nazi persecution in Europe, the city of Shanghai (which could still be accessed without entry visas) became a unlikely haven for numerous desperate refugees. The treaty port would eventually shelter nearly twenty thousand European Jews between 1938 and 1941, although most of these individuals were herded by the Japanese into a ghetto area in the north of the city after the outbreak of the Pacific War. In her study of this little-known wartime sanctuary, Gao Bei paints a fascinatingly intricate picture of the political forces and fluxes which ultimately contributed to the arrival of these Jewish refugees in Shanghai. Her work is underpinned by an array of hitherto under-utilised Chinese and Japanese archival sources which provide several intriguing new insights into East Asian perceptions of Jews during the late 1930s and early 1940s.
The author contends – albeit in somewhat repetitive fashion – that this influx of Jewish refugees was initially facilitated by an array of opportunistic Chinese Nationalist and Japanese foreign policies which became keenly intertwined with the fluctuating context of global power relations. The Chinese Nationalists, she maintains, had regarded these refugees as a lever in their attempts at garnering increased international financial and political support for their war against Japan. To this end, they even formulated a settlement plan in 1939 for ‘stateless’ Jewish refugees in the Yunnan Province in a bid to obtain American and British backing for their cause. However, this scheme was never implemented due to the lack of financial assistance from the United States (which was itself restricting the entry of Jews to its own shores due to concerns over unemployment and possible subversion). The Japanese, for their part, adopted a conceptually similar approach towards these refugees as they had initially regarded the latter as a tool in their attempts at wrangling political and financial backing for their own war effort. However, this stance was to change as the conflict progressed and as Japan gravitated in the direction of Germany and felt impelled to relegate the Jews (whose significance began to diminish in Japanese eyes) to a Shanghai ghetto in February 1943.
The author has a keen eye for detail and also provides the reader with an elaborate overview of various Chinese and Japanese personalities who directly or indirectly facilitated the entry of these Jewish refugees into Shanghai. Of interest, in particular, are the sections detailing the machinations of two ‘Jewish experts’ within the Japanese military (the army colonel Yasue Norihiro and the naval captain Inuzuka Koreshige) who attempted to exploit the Jews’ purported political clout and financial capital for the Japanese war effort. The policies which they had pushed for, as the author contends, were based on research conducted by the South Manchurian Railway Company (Japanese's largest wartime research institute on China) which tended to exaggerate the extent of the world Jewry's political and economic power. These two policy-makers were accordingly convinced that the Jews in China could be easily incentivised to cooperate with the Japanese if they were promised Japanese ‘protection’ in return. Equally compelling, too, are the author's descriptions of various diplomats of both Chinese and Japanese origin in Europe who issued travel documents to thousands of Jewish refugees and inadvertently contributed to their survival during the period. These individuals included He Fengshan (the Chinese consul general in Vienna) who followed the liberal visa policy prescribed by the Chinese Foreign Ministry, as well as Sugihara Chiune (the Japanese consul in Lithuania) who issued more than two thousand Japanese transit visas to Polish Jews in the summer of 1940 due to his humanitarian inclinations.
The author also makes a number of interesting observations about the differences in Chinese and Japanese perceptions of Jews. Firstly, she contends that the Chinese had tended to regard the Jews (particularly the Zionist movement) as symbols of national independence and salvation, while the Japanese had an overriding inclination to equate Jews with wealth and power. She argues, too, that while the Chinese never threatened to harm the Jewish refugees, the Japanese approach towards Jews was significantly exploitative in character for the Japanese had ruthlessly declared that Jewish survival was ultimately contingent on their cooperation with the Japanese. While this intriguing observation deserves to be explored more carefully, her book unfortunately provides scant indication as to what these Japanese threats against the wellbeing of the Jews in China really entailed. The publication is also rather opaque in its articulation of the similarities between Chinese and Japanese policies on Jewish refugees during the period. Both the Chinese and Japanese, for instance, appear to have formulated settlement plans for Jews in separate localities on the Chinese mainland during the late 1930s. The thematic similarities between these schemes deserve more precise exploration. Both the Chinese and Japanese, too, regarded the Jews as a potential tool in soliciting American support for their respective causes during the late 1930s. Again, the conceptual similarities between these strands of Chinese and Japanese thinking merit greater consideration.
While the book generally attempts to provide a sequential narrative of developments during this period, the chronology of events (especially those described within the book's middle sections) could be clearer at times. Several unanswered questions also remain at the book's end, chiefly the precise ways in which the Chinese and Japanese attempted to harness the purported financial and political clout of the Jews for their respective wartime gains. While much is made of the Japanese determination to ‘exploit’ the Jews, the specifics of how the Japanese actually attempted to solicit Jewish capital and expertise in the years leading up to the Pacific War remain somewhat blurry in the text. Also, what the Japanese really thought of Nazi ideology on Jews during the period deserves further analytical consideration. On a related note, while the author attributes the eventual hardening of Japanese policies on Jews to Japan's signing of the Tripartite Pact with Germany, the question of whether security or practical concerns on the ground may have partially accounted for the Japanese decision to herd the Shanghai Jews into a ghetto remains largely unanswered. That said, her book does indeed provide several richly-illuminating perspectives on Chinese and Japanese policies on these refugees during this tumultuous period and is poised to make a refreshing contribution to scholarship on the political forces which affected the Jewish wartime experience in the East.
