In the opening moments of riverrun (2013), Olwen Fouéré delivers a rallying cry: ‘Calling all downs. Calling all downs to dayne. Array! Surrection.’Footnote 1 Fouéré’s astonishing solo performance is an adaptation of the last section of James Joyce’s novel Finnegan’s Wake, and its significance lies in Fouéré’s re-embodiment of the river, Anna Livia Plurabelle. Understanding the performing female body as a lived body which is fundamental to experience and the production of knowledge enables exploration of the creativity of the female body. Not only does Fouéré seize control of the frame of narration from one of Ireland’s male literary giants, but the bodily meanings generated through performance recover that which has been erased by female iconicity.
Irish theatre has long been steeped in mythic narratives, an obsession which has hindered women’s participation in the cultural fabric of society through the perpetuation of idealized and dematerialized tropes of femininity. Yet, women theatre makers have persistently and imaginatively engaged with and re-written these icons to refuse this silence. Anna Livia Plurabelle’s ‘Array! Surrection’, or resurrection, through riverrun defiantly marks her corporeal resistance and the moment ‘when the icons return to haunt the icon makers’.Footnote 2 Indeed, the icon becomes the icon maker as Fouéré awakens the audience to Anna Livia’s desires and to the possibilities for female self-authorship and a creative female corporeality. riverrun is part of the rich tradition of women’s mythmaking in Irish theatre that constitutes the focus of this book; a tradition which is invigorated by energetic opposition to inherited myths and thereby defined by the ongoing struggle to dismantle cultural and material structures that support male power and privilege.
Fouéré reshapes the contours of Anna Livia’s body to demand female expression; likewise, it is the intention of this book to forge a new paradigm, the genealogy, as a means of remodelling our understanding of the development of Irish theatre. Cathy Leeney describes ‘the stubborn persistence of patriarchally-led definitions of what is canonical’ in Irish theatre and argues that ‘simply adding women to the mix is not enough’.Footnote 3 Leeney develops this argument in her contribution to The Oxford Handbook of Modern Irish Theatre; one of two chapters devoted to women in theatre.Footnote 4
It is a pointed irony that her astute exposure of the difficulty of moving beyond the stage of the recovery of women’s work to ‘an integration of this recovery into canonical judgement, a disruption of the canon’ appears seventeen chapters into the collection.Footnote 5 My proposal of the genealogy is an explicit engagement with the male-dominated literary canon and mythmaking of Irish theatre and masculinist scholarship which have served to replicate the marginalization of women’s voices and experiences from the public sphere. I draw on feminist philosopher Alison Stone’s use of the term genealogy which is not concerned with origins, purity and bloodlines, but rather advocates a coalitional politics whereby ‘women are connected together in complex and variable ways, through historical chains of partially and multiply overlapping interpretations of femininity’.Footnote 6
The mythmaking in the plays and performances discussed in this book comprise these chains of reinterpretation. Moreover, the non-linear genealogy indicates the ‘progress’ of women’s history in twentieth and twenty-first century Ireland, characterized by periods where women’s demands for equality have been met, only to be followed by regression. A linear canon of Irish theatre has served to reinforce the apparent silence of these stalled periods by severing the connections which form a tradition of women’s theatre. Rebecca Schneider speaks to the process of reperformance: ‘striking a pose partakes of reenactment, and reenactment defers its site in multiple directions. What is cited extends not only into the past but also across complicated fields of possibility that undo any linearity that would give us, securely, forward and backward.’Footnote 7 The women in this genealogy ‘strike a (mythic) pose’ which defers in multiple directions to speak across the silences and create a (non-essentialist) body of work. In the chapters that follow, I develop the lines of confluence between these women to uncover the hidden veins of resistance and revolution embodied in their mythmaking.
The theatrical work explored extends from the start of the twentieth century, when the manipulation of myths of femininity was intertwined with the fight for an independent state and the subsequent development of the modern Irish state, to the present day where these myths linger on and have been moulded by other emergent forces such as neoliberalism and globalization in more recent decades, forces which have also spawned new myths of femininity. The performances analysed include the tableaux vivants performed by the Inghinidhe na hÉireann (Daughters of Ireland), plays written by Alice Milligan, Maud Gonne, Lady Augusta Gregory, Eva Gore-Booth, Mary Devenport O’Neill, Mary Elizabeth Burke-Kennedy, Paula Meehan, Edna O’Brien and Marina Carr, as well as plays translated, adapted and performed by Olwen Fouéré. Though the contexts differ, all the work studied in this book coheres around a self-conscious adoption of mythic narrative to critique idealized myths of femininity which support patriarchal structures and repudiate women’s cultural participation. The performances interrogate the contingent and performative nature of myth and gender to articulate women’s experience of exclusion, as well as uncovering the possibilities for expressing a creative female corporeality.
The Legacy of Mother Ireland
The stultifying legacy of idealized myths has occluded women’s cultural engagement through confinement to iconicity. In her seminal work, Women in Irish Drama: A Century of Authorship and Representation, Melissa Sihra explains how, in Ireland, ‘the social and cultural position of woman has historically been one of symbolic centrality and subjective disavowal as both colonial ideology and nationalist movements promoted feminized concepts of nation, while subordinating women in everyday life’.Footnote 8 The gendered narrative of representing woman as land can be traced back to the sovereignty figure: a pagan goddess of the land who conferred prosperity on a people through her union with their king.
This figure had several functions, representing war, fertility, sex and victory, but different aspects were employed and emphasized during different historical periods. The Morrígan, a goddess of war, had a dominant position in early Irish literature but this figure, and her sexual function, was later shunned in favour of the aisling figure.Footnote 9 This popular poetic convention flourished in the eighteenth century in response to the imposition of British rule following seventeenth century colonization. The narrative follows the dream convention as the poet falls asleep and has a dream-vision of a beautiful lady who tells him she is Ireland. However, the aisling was ‘no longer a powerful or practical goddess, but a weak, melancholy maiden, romanticized and unreal’.Footnote 10 In the nineteenth century it was the more defiant figure of the Shan Van Vocht (The Poor Old Woman) who was favoured and appeared in political ballads.Footnote 11 The representation of women in myth during the early years of twentieth century Ireland was largely shaped by the political agenda of emergent cultural nationalism: the choice of myth was influenced by the need to represent Ireland’s struggle for independence. This is epitomized in W.B. Yeats’s and Lady Gregory’s 1902 play Kathleen ni Houlihan in which the eponymous Kathleen is the symbolic Mother Nation figure who is dependent on the actions of men and serves to inspire them. The possibility of locating a feminist politics in this play is explored in detail in Chapter 1’s discussion of the premiere production.
The enduring trope of Mother Ireland has defined women’s bodies as the terrain over which power has been contested, while concurrently erasing the reality of their corporeal experiences. During the Revival years of the early twentieth century and the foundation of the Irish Free State, the Catholic Church contributed to the construction of an immutable Irish feminine identity through recourse to the Virgin Mother as role model. Ailbhe Smyth’s description of ‘the realities of Irish women’s lives Mater-reality’Footnote 12 captures how this idealized figure became the ‘reality’ that shaped and supplanted the material realities of women’s lives. The legacy of these attitudes is still felt in Ireland today. In March 2018 former President of Ireland, Mary McAleese, delivered the opening address at the ‘Why Women Matter’ conference in Rome, in which she lambasted the Catholic Church as ‘an empire of misogyny’. McAleese spoke of the need for reform within the Catholic Church, fostered by gender equality: ‘John Paul II has written of the “mystery of women”. Talk to us as equals and we will not be a mystery.’Footnote 13
The perpetuation of inequality through a mystified and idealized construction of ‘woman’ underpins the Eighth Amendment of the Irish Constitution, inserted in 1983, which effectively bans abortion and denies women their bodily autonomy. Instead, the reality of women’s bodily experiences has been dealt with by evasion: between January 1980 and December 2016, at least 170,216 women and girls travelled from the Republic of Ireland to access abortion services in another country.Footnote 14 Following decades of campaigning, the Eighth Amendment was repealed by a referendum held on 25 May 2018. The resounding defeat of the amendment was evidenced by the voting figures; an almost exact reversal of the figures in 1983 when 66.9 per cent voted to insert Article 40.3.3 into the constitution, while in 2018 66.4 per cent of voters voted for its repeal.
In The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir delineates between the fixity of mythic ‘woman’ and the complexity of actual women: ‘Thus, as against the dispersed, contingent, and multiple existences of actual women, mythical thought opposes the Eternal Feminine, unique and changeless.’Footnote 15 The central concern of this book is how women in Irish theatre in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries have employed mythic narratives to expose the gap between idealized myths of femininity and women’s lived realities. I explore how these performances grapple with this tension through consideration of embodied experience, for, as Elizabeth Grosz explains: ‘Far from being an inert, passive, noncultural and ahistorical term, the body may be seen as the crucial term, the site of contestation, in a series of economic, political, sexual, and intellectual struggles.’Footnote 16 Myth can impose limiting and inflexible representations which present female identity as timeless and unchangeable, yet it is through their attention to embodied female experience that the theatre makers considered herein resist this illusion. The theatrical work discussed reveals the process of embodied mythmaking: how bodies bear the consequences of myths of femininity, while refusing the female body as passive bearer of inscription. The assertion of a creative female corporeality refuses the negative and essentialist alignment of woman and the body, and is central to repositioning women as the icon makers.
Embodied Mythmaking and the Writing Body
Embodied mythmaking considers the reiteration, reperformance and reinscription of myths on and through the body. Analysis of the theatrical work examined here attends to the ways in which bodies trace the residues of an inheritance of limiting myths of femininity, yet we can also look to the ways in which bodies might reinscribe meaning. This requires casting the body not simply as matter onto which meaning is imposed, but as the body–subject through which we experience and know the world. Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s Phenomenology of Perception addresses the bias in Western philosophy towards René Descartes’ privileging of the mind over body, a hierarchical binary which has been mapped onto man and woman, and instead suggests: ‘The world is not what I think, but what I live through.’Footnote 17 Elizabeth Grosz describes the importance of Merleau-Ponty’s work for feminism:
His emphasis on lived experience and perception, his focus on the body-subject, has resonances with what may arguably be regarded as feminism’s major contribution to the production and structure of knowledges – its necessary reliance on lived experience, on experiential acquaintance as touchstone or criterion of the validity of theoretical postulates.Footnote 18
Feminist phenomenologists, including Grosz and Iris Marion Young, have explored the implication that the lived body is fundamental to both experience and the production of knowledge: ‘The lived body is a unified idea of a physical body acting and experiencing in a specific sociocultural context; it is a body-in-situation.’Footnote 19 This approach is of vital importance to this study in its acknowledgement of the specific material, and thus historical, contexts of corporeal being.
Remaining cognisant of context ensures that we acknowledge both the ways in which women are limited by, and simultaneously test, prescribed cultural limits. Young captures this tension in her description of ‘the variable movements of habituated bodies reacting to, reproducing and modifying structures’.Footnote 20 Young examines how female embodiment within patriarchal society is defined by contradiction and ambiguity as a result of women’s experience as both subject and object: ‘as human she is a free subject who participates in transcendence, but her situation as a woman denies her that subjectivity and transcendence […] [the] tension between transcendence and immanence, between subjectivity and being a mere object’.Footnote 21 Woman’s contradictory experience is further developed by Rosalind Gill who examines the relationship between culture and subjectivity within the contemporary frame of ‘neoliberal and postfeminist times’. Gill marks ‘the shift from objectification to sexual subjectification’,Footnote 22 whereby woman’s subjecthood is defined by individualism and ‘a compulsory (sexual) agency’.Footnote 23 Through my discussion of twenty-first century performances, I address this postfeminist fetishization of autonomous choice in order to examine our investments in the circulation of myths of femininity; for as Gill states, ‘This is much more than a remoulding of the body; it is nothing short of a remaking of subjectivity.’Footnote 24
The examination of embodied mythmaking through twentieth and twenty-first century Irish theatre enables the redress of Irish theatre studies’ neglect of female bodies; both their creativity and their histories. The elision of female experience and of female bodies has been perpetuated by Irish theatre, and the study of it, as a predominantly literary theatre tradition; as Anna McMullan notes, ‘the linguistic virtuosity of Irish theatre has a high textual value, and this very value encourages a primarily textual construction of Irish theatre history’.Footnote 25 Within the Irish literary theatre tradition, women’s contribution has been marked by iconicity and, furthermore, the association of woman with the body has heightened the effects of a critical neglect of bodies within a theatre tradition that affords prominence to the literary text. That said, Irish theatre studies has looked to the body with renewed interest; for example, in Performing the Body in Irish Theatre Bernadette Sweeney re-examines five Irish plays which have ‘been suppressed in some way by the dominant discourse of dramatic, textual analysis’.Footnote 26 If, following Turner and Behrndt, we define dramaturgy as ‘the composition of a work, whether read as a script or viewed in performance’Footnote 27 and extend this analysis ‘beyond the performance itself, to include the context, the audience and the various ways in which the work is framed’,Footnote 28 embodied mythmaking offers a dramaturgical framework through which to view the contributions of women in Irish theatre.
My intention throughout is to uncover a feminist reading of the work which displaces the privileged viewpoint ‘of the ideal white, middle-class, heterosexual male spectator’ and in his place locates a ‘feminist spectator who can cast an eye critical of dominant ideology’.Footnote 29 Performance analysis is central to my discussion of embodied mythmaking in each chapter. Where I have experienced performances at first hand or had access to recordings of performances, I consider the contribution of text, direction, performance and creative design in interpreting meaning. However, there is scant archival material on some of the plays while others have never been staged, so in these instances I have worked with the performance text to uncover the potential for a feminist reading of the work and its embodied mythmaking.
My focus is on how these layers of meaning shape the body as a ‘site of contestation’Footnote 30 to open up the gap between body and representation, between corporeal reality and mythic icon, thereby undoing the authority and apparent fixity of myth. Through performance, the women discussed in this book corporeally challenge and rewrite the myths imposed on them, and shift their role from bearing to creating and controlling meaning. The chapters which follow cohere around the body in process as it is presented before an audience: bodies that are revolutionary, unhomely, sacrificial and dying, haunted and, in (the final) Chapter 6, writing bodies. My approach draws on dance scholar Susan Leigh Foster’s ‘claim for a writing-dancing body’,Footnote 31 which enables examination of corporeal interventions in the cultural production of myths of femininity. Embodied mythmaking is thus concerned with how bodies are written upon but also resist forms of cultural production, and how these resistant writing bodies perform alternatives that negotiate female agency and expression.
Each of the chapters examines performances that offer bodies inscribed by an archive of myths of femininity but which also generate other possibilities. The revolutionary bodies in Chapter 1 offer the means of analysing the negotiation of change and the different feminisms at play at the turn of the twentieth century through discussion of the Inghinidhe na hÉireann’s tableaux vivants (1901), Maud Gonne’s performance in Kathleen ni Houlihan in 1902, Gonne’s play Dawn (published in 1904) and Eva Gore-Booth’s play The Triumph of Maeve (written in 1902 and published 1905). The discussion of theatrical form which emerges in Chapter 1 is further developed in Chapter 2 on unhomely bodies. I focus on Paula Meehan’s Mrs Sweeney (1997) and Mary Elizabeth Burke-Kennedy’s Women in Arms (1988 and 2002) to examine the tension between the body and the space it inhabits, and thus women’s experience of a lack of accommodation within society and onstage, through alternative forms to realism.
The pursuit of alternative forms is advanced in Chapter 3’s exploration of metamorphic bodies in Lady Gregory’s Grania (published 1912) and Marina Carr’s The Mai (1994). Metamorphosis as a process of transformation and corporeal change offers the means of refusing the unhomely experience and negotiating expression and accommodation. Resisting the curtailment of corporeal expression is central to Chapter 4’s discussion of sacrificial bodies in Marina Carr’s Ariel (2002), Edna O’Brien’s Iphigenia (2003) and the dying body in Carr’s Woman and Scarecrow (2006). These plays, to varying degrees, refuse the beauty of the female corpse and explore the trope of the ‘good death’ as a process of dematerialization and desexualization which erases female corporeal experience. Chapter 5’s analysis of Mary Devenport O’Neill’s ballet-poem Bluebeard (1933), Eva Gore-Booth’s The Buried Life of Deirdre (written between 1908–12 and illustrated in 1916–17, although not published until 1930) and Marina Carr’s Portia Coughlan (1996) explores the haunted body as a site of memory which enables the resurfacing of violent histories.
Central to all these chapters is analysis of the persistent theatrical efforts to articulate the female body in process as a means of dismantling the perfection of mythic icons of femininity: a corpus of work which traces the consequences of myths of femininity as they are felt through the body and which generates the possibility of rewriting them. Process and transformation underpin the discussion in all chapters of the book and culminate in the concluding chapter (Chapter 6) on Olwen Fouéré’s Sodome, My Love (2010) and riverrun (2013). In this final chapter I draw on Jean-Luc Nancy’s work in Corpus to advance a new framework for feminist critique of performance. His notion of ‘exscription’ addresses that which is beyond inscription and can be applied to the endeavour of reclaiming the unhomely female body which is outside of the symbolic frame. Both plays are male-authored texts – Fouéré translates Laurent Gaudé’s script of Sodome, My Love and adapts James Joyce’s novel in riverrun – but I would argue that Fouéré is the author who uses the female body as the primary text. Her performances champion a creative female corporeality and assert female authorship to question the dominance of a text-focused performance tradition. Expression of the female writing body serves to resist the imposition of myth and silence, as Hélène Cixous proposes: ‘By writing her self, woman will return to the body which has been more than confiscated from her, which has been turned into the uncanny stranger on display.’Footnote 32
The inheritance that the myth of woman as nation, another uncanny stranger, has bequeathed women writers is addressed by the poet Eavan Boland: ‘What I found was a rhetoric of imagery which alienated me: a fusion of the national and the feminine which simplified both.’Footnote 33 Both are patriarchal constructs which deny the expression of women’s subjectivity and renounce their bodies. My focus on embodied genealogies of women’s performance serves to refuse the deathly silence imposed by the perpetuation of essentialist binaries on the female body. This genealogy of women’s mythmaking constitutes a body of work animated by the suppressed realities of women’s corporeal experiences; thereby enabling a dual reconsideration of patriarchal and conceptual frameworks of the female body and the canon of Irish theatre.
Mythmaking and Nation Building
A nation’s heritage is one of its unifying components, offering a sense of the past and future through a created collective consciousness of its people. Mythologies are part of this heritage, traditional stories passed down through the ages which serve to explain the world and its orders to society; as Richard Kearney notes, ‘myth is closely bound up with tradition as a recollection, transmission and reinterpretation of the past’.Footnote 34 The ongoing reinterpretation of the past forms communities which result in the incorporation of certain experiences at the expense of excluding others. This was made manifest in October 2015 when the Abbey Theatre, Ireland’s National Theatre, announced its programme to commemorate one hundred years since the Easter Rising – a rebellion against British rule. The 1916 Rising is part of the history and mythology of the modern Irish state and the intention was to ‘interrogate rather than celebrate’ the event, yet women were largely obscured from the programme: 90 per cent of the plays were male authored.
The marginalization of women theatre-makers and female narratives prompted an incendiary response in the form of the #WakingTheFeminists, campaign which has compelled arts organizations in Ireland to address gender equality at the level of policy and governance, and demands that we ‘interrogate what stories are told, who gets to tell those stories’.Footnote 35 The pressing need to dismantle the mechanics of myth, as a central structure of the nation’s storytelling, is the impetus for the performances discussed in this book.
The universal appeal of myth contains its repressive aspect as it attempts to freeze time and reaffirm a unified narrative of the past which supports the dominant ideology of the day. Laurence Coupe highlights the dangers inherent in mythic narratives: ‘Thus the drive towards completion and unity can create not only powerfully imaginative stories but also systematic violence. Myth may imply totality, but “perfectionism” is to be resisted where it becomes totalitarian.’Footnote 36 In Mythologies, Roland Barthes reveals myth’s capacity to naturalize the ideology of the dominant order. He examines myth as ‘a type of speech’ and ‘a mode of signification’Footnote 37 in order to expose ‘the very principle of myth: it transforms history into nature’.Footnote 38 Barthes focuses on uncovering the historical aspect of the signifying process to undermine myth’s naturalization as ‘myth has the task of giving an historical intention a natural justification, and making contingency appear eternal’.Footnote 39 Similarly, the performances discussed in this book seek to expose mythmaking as a historically contingent practice which embodies social structures, thereby dismantling the perfection of the Eternal Feminine.
The women discussed in this book look to two realms of mythic narrative for their inspiration and appropriation: Greek and Celtic myth. Indeed, Marina Carr melds both Greek and Irish mythic references to uncover and rewrite women’s place within both traditions. The choice of either Greek or Celtic myth is interpreted by many critics as a deliberately reactive strategy adopted by a postcolonial nation. Declan Kiberd points to the tradition of classics in Ireland as revolutionary when the collapse of the bardic schools after 1600 gave the classics, together with Irish, ‘the glamour of an outlaw activity’.Footnote 40 Furthermore, as the literature of civilization, Greek classics act as a rebuttal to the colonial construction of the Irish as uncivilized savages. This is evident in Lady Gregory’s description of the aims of the Irish Literary Theatre in ‘Our Irish Theatre’ (1913): ‘We will show that Ireland is not the home of buffoonery and easy sentiment, as it has been represented, but the home of an ancient idealism.’Footnote 41 Irish myth was deployed to assert a native culture, yet this ‘ancient idealism’ was shaped by the (gendered) ideals of early twentieth-century Ireland. Women’s mythmaking did not always align with, and frequently opposed, these motivations so examining their purpose enables us to bring the tensions between nationalism and feminism into sharp focus: Chapter 1’s analysis of performances from the start of the twentieth century reveals the complexity and range of feminist politics intertwined with, and obscured by, nationalist histories.
The Unhomely Experience
The patriarchal home, as regulated by the Irish Free State and Catholic Church, served as the framework for the project of national identity formation and rested on the purity of women. In Ireland’s Magdalen Laundries and the Nation’s Architecture of Containment, James M. Smith outlines the newly independent state’s response to what it deemed to be ‘problem’ women and children: the construction of ‘Ireland’s architecture of containment’, which ‘encompassed an array of interdependent institutions: industrial and reformatory schools, mother and baby homes, adoption agencies, and Magdalen asylums, among others’.Footnote 42
The Magdalene laundries were founded in the eighteenth century and Dublin’s Gloucester Street laundry (now Seán McDermott Street) was the last to close in 1996. The home as a space in which to contain women was bolstered by restrictive legal and ideological frameworks enshrined by the government of Éamon de Valera. Article 41.2 of the 1937 Constitution defined women’s place in the home and granted the role of mother dominance over other models of femininity:
2.1. In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved.
2.2. The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home.Footnote 43
The prison house of the home comprised both institutional homes and the private domestic space through which women’s lives and ‘duties’ were constitutionally contained. Furthermore, this ‘architecture of containment’ is upheld by conceptual as well as material frames; limiting myths of femininity are part of the assemblage that confines women’s expression and limits her freedom.
The experience of alienation and of feeling unaccommodated is augmented by women’s exclusion from the fabric of Irish cultural life. This is articulated in a contemporary context by Mothers Artists Makers (MAM), a feminist movement created by mothers who are professional members of the creative industries. The group came together in 2016, inspired by the #WakingTheFeminists (#WTF) movement and by Tara Derrington’s placard at the first #WTF meeting in November 2015, which asked, ‘Where are the disappeared women of the arts? … At the school gates now.’Footnote 44 The experience of exclusion is thus an enduring one and Anna McMullan highlights the unhomely experience in Marina Carr’s plays as one defined by the women’s lack of self-expression and cultural representation: ‘By unshackling the female figure from her traditional associations, Carr reveals her lack of place within the culture outside of the maternal function.’Footnote 45
Drawing on Sigmund Freud’s unheimlich and Homi Bhabha’s characterization of the unhomely, McMullan maps the unhomely experience onto feminist philosopher Luce Irigaray’s term déréliction which marks woman’s displacement outside of culture and the symbolic. I employ McMullan’s approach and consciously avoid defining a universal model of the unhomely experience by locating the plays discussed in their historical context. For this reason, historical background is integrated into each chapter rather than given as a summary in this introduction.Footnote 46 While following the logic of the above argument, we need to be aware that construing the home simply as a space of confinement for women may leave some feeling unaccommodated by feminism. Developing an understanding of when the home functions as an imprisoning patriarchal construct, while also acknowledging the value of gendered care work will be the fraught terrain that will be navigated in the lead-up to the proposed referendum to review the extant Article 41.Footnote 47
The theatrical work discussed here exposes the perils and possibilities of mythmaking in performance; it reveals the unhomely experience, as well as opening up more accommodating spaces. In this introduction I want to embark on the process of exposing how the imposition of idealized myths of femininity, oftentimes in conjunction with the patriarchal framework of the home, results in violence and stagnation. This then leads us to consideration of how women’s mythmaking might offer a revised conception of spaces and myths which accommodate female expression. Following discussion of these processes, we see how the attempt to negotiate new forms and reshape space underpins my proposal of a genealogy of women in Irish theatre as a newly conceived ‘home’ for their body of work.
The Violence of Mythmaking
Stasis and containment define violent mythmaking. Marina Carr’s On Raftery’s Hill (2000) unleashes a searing critique of the imprisoning framework of the patriarchal home as the cradle of the nation’s mythmaking.Footnote 48 Within the context of Celtic Tiger Ireland, the play offers a critical take on nostalgic visions of the domestic space. Act One is set within the claustrophobic confines of the Raftery kitchen and closes with the climactic moment of the play: the brutal rape of the youngest daughter Sorrel by her father Red Raftery, the horror of which we are left to imagine as the lights black out before we see the act take place. Act Two plays out much the same action as the first act and the family remain trapped within a violent and repressive cycle. The lack of any change between the acts, save for Sorrel’s worn clothes and subdued demeanour in Act Two of the premiere production, reinforces this bleak outlook.
The sense of entrapment and endless repetition is also created through the actions of Shalome, Red Raftery’s mother, who provides comic relief, though this comedy soon bows under the oppressive weight of the play. Shalome’s repeated efforts to leave the farm, ‘I’m going back to Kinneygar and to Daddy’,Footnote 49 reinforce the futility of the cyclical repetitions of the past as she never gets any further than the end of the lane. While being lead back upstairs by Dinah, Shalome remarks: ‘All my life I’ve waited for my life to start, somehow it never has.’Footnote 50 Through her storytelling, Shalome is the main proponent of mythmaking and romantic expectation in the play but her creativity is frustrated and distorted. Both her belief in the myth of home as a place to escape to and her father as a fantasy figure are exposed as delusions; home is an elusive space of refuge. The play closes with Red Raftery’s entrance with Shalome in Sorrel’s muddied wedding dress, reinforcing the women’s entrapment within tropes of femininity. The various ‘brides’ that populate the wedding scene in Act Two of Carr’s earlier play By the Bog of Cats … (1996) highlight how myth and gendered identity are performative as both depend upon repetition to achieve the force that perpetuates its meanings: it is ‘a regulated process of repetition that both conceals itself and enforces its rules’.Footnote 51 The performativity of the idealized and iconic image of the perfect bride is parodied by the variations on this ideal: the jilted wife, the jealous mother-in-law and the child as a bride of Christ. In the premiere production each of these ‘brides’ wore a veil,Footnote 52 underlining the limitations that the ‘tyranny of familial metaphors’ offer.Footnote 53
Following Shalome’s final entrance, Dinah asks Red if he caught anything and he replies: ‘Only this auld bird. I nearly shoh her.’Footnote 54 The lack of physical and financial freedom, for the women in particular, is encapsulated by the metaphor of the hunted animal; only Shalome is not shot and she is unable to escape the house. Fiona Becket suggests that: ‘The fact that there is no alternative to the familial except death is the irony that informs Carr’s work.’Footnote 55 This irony is taken one step further in On Raftery’s Hill where not even death is an available alternative to the oppressive insularity of the family.Footnote 56 Melissa Sihra has drawn comparisons between On Raftery’s Hill and Kathleen ni Houlihan in terms of the setting, characters and themes. Sihra notes that Shalome’s final entrance in the wedding dress ‘invert[s] the actions of the Poor Old Woman in the earlier drama and refus[es] the myth of an idealised Mother Ireland.’Footnote 57 The rejuvenation and rebirth of Kathleen ni Houlihan into a beautiful young queen is denied, thus exposing the myth as a dead end while simultaneously denying any alternatives.
The lack of movement and claustrophobia created by limiting myths is heightened by the incestuous relationships in On Raftery’s Hill. The eldest daughter Dinah has taken on the mantle of the mother of the household and this together with her collusion with Red grants her a relative position of power: we learn that this is maintained by Dinah’s continuing sexual relations with her father. Dinah’s union fulfils all the female familial roles, mother, wife and daughter, and therefore reinforces female dependency on Red as well as colluding with the patriarchal family model’s conferral of power. Dinah’s brother Ded describes her power in farming terms which reinforce the patriarchal economy: ‘Ud’s Dinah decides everythin round here anyway. Dinah’s Daddy’s cattle daler. You and me is only the cattle, Sorrel.’Footnote 58 The toxic masculinity which infects the world of the play results in the exclusion of men who fail to perpetuate violent patriarchal behaviour and Ded is consigned to a life outside the home in the cow shed.
The inward looking vision of the family is magnified and distended to parody the notion of the idyllic rural family. This dystopian vision of the pastoral is defined by corruption and sickness, and the stench of the decaying corpses of Red’s farm animals is continually referenced by the characters. Tony Walton’s set design for the premiere production depicted grungy walls, broken window panes and rubble falling away from the worn stone fireplace.Footnote 59 The extent to which the past quells engagement with the present reinforces how the family is stifled by conformity to gendered models and inherited ideologies. The theme of incest relates to all the families in the play and is explicitly linked to myth by their neighbour Isaac: ‘Zeus and Hera, sure they were brother and sister and they goh married and had chaps and young wans and the chaps and young wans done the job wud the mother and father and one another’.Footnote 60 In this play, mythmaking, both Shalome’s storytelling and the propagation of idealized myths of femininity, relentlessly perpetuates the oppressive claustrophobia.
The following chapters illustrate further instances where mythmaking denies movement and expression. In Mary Devenport O’Neill’s ballet-poem Bluebeard (premiere 1933), the central character Ilina’s enervated and unintentional movements reveal the restrictions placed on women’s participation in the public sphere (see Chapter 5). The defiant haunting of the ghosts of Bluebeard’s wives culminates in unleashing their revenge at the end of the play, only for their threatening energies to be dissipated. In contrast, the tableaux vivants performed by the Inghinidhe na hÉireann in 1901 (see Chapter 1) might appear to be defined by stalled movement, yet it is an immobility in tension with motion. Similarly, Olwen Fouéré’s Sodome, My Love plays with moments of stillness to communicate Lot’s wife’s control of her authorship, whilst also signalling the constraints that have to be negotiated to effect change. Movement, or indeed the tension of pending movement, indicates the prospect of rewriting myth and shaping the future.
A ‘Poetics of the Possible’
Richard Kearney distinguishes ‘between a mythologising form of politics which interprets the present in terms of a unifying past (sacred tradition) and a demythologising form of politics which interprets the present in terms of a pluralising future (secular progress)’.Footnote 61 On Raftery’s Hill brutally exposes the dangers of static mythmaking but, as in Bluebeard, there is no sense of a pluralizing future. Coupe highlights the three features of myth as ‘paradigm, perfection and possibility’,Footnote 62 and Richard Kearney and Paul Ricoeur offer two means of approaching this sense of ‘possibility’: Kearney’s advocation of myth as a verb, and Ricoeur’s suggestion that myth can offer ‘a disclosure of unprecedented worlds, an opening onto other possible worlds which transcend the limits of our actual world’.Footnote 63 Myth has proved to be a vital source for the development of second-wave feminist thought: Hélène Cixous and Luce Irigaray deploy myth with critical rigour and poeticism to dismantle the foundations of Western thought and the perpetuation of patriarchal structures. I argue that the theatrical work discussed in this book utilizes the power of myth against itself, to not only deconstruct existing myths but to also create rich and expansive mythopoeias which accommodate women’s expression.
Ricoeur acknowledges myth’s ideological role but he also points to a possible liberatory function. He expresses his belief in the positive possibilities myth offers as he distinguishes between myth as deviant expression and as ‘genuine’ myth ‘which can be reinterpreted in terms of liberation’.Footnote 64 Ricoeur’s advocation of myth as a ‘poetics of the possible’Footnote 65 incorporates the potential for creativity and imagination which Roland Barthes’s theory of myth does not. Barthes addresses the claims of tradition and ideology on myth but Ricoeur’s utopian view goes beyond this to address the creative possibilities of the future: ‘The mythos of any community is the bearer of something which exceeds its own frontiers; it is the bearer of other possible worlds.’Footnote 66 In Carr’s Midlands Trilogy (The Mai, Portia Coughlan, and By the Bog of Cats …) we see her creation of new mythopoeias and ‘other possible worlds’ which converge on the landscape as a space of female expression. In By the Bog of Cats … Hester, like her mother and the mythic Catwoman, freely roams the bog and this is juxtaposed with Hester’s sense of never having ‘felt at home’ in her house.Footnote 67 The bog accommodates shifting identities, the supernatural and the mythic realm, and the lighting in the Abbey Theatre’s premiere production, designed by Nick Chelton, emphasized this mutable landscape.Footnote 68 In all three of the Midlands plays, the central character has a private mythology which connects the landscape with the lost other. This creates a tension in the female mythmaking of Carr’s plays: it can reinforce a restrictive model of family and female genealogy but it also offers the women an alternative space of expression and attempts to house a female symbolic. Hester’s private mythology intertwines fate and genealogy in a potentially stifling manner but the mythmaking in the play also opens up ‘pluralising futures’ through Hester’s rewriting of both limiting models of femininity and her tragic ending, and through cultivating the possibilities of the bog.
Like Carr, the women theatre makers examined in this book critically engage with the process of mythmaking in order to utilize myth’s ‘dual potential of creation and critique: the disclosure of possible worlds which are suppressed in our present reality and whose very otherness provides us with alternatives to the established order’.Footnote 69 It is in the mythic realm of the plays that the women locate an alternative to realism as a ‘conservative force that reproduces and reinforces dominant cultural relations’.Footnote 70 In contrast to the deadening (or possibly hysterical) realism which reflects the women’s entrapment on Raftery’s Hill and prevents exploration of ‘other possible worlds’, the women in Carr’s Midlands plays use the poetics of mythmaking and storytelling to create a space through which to forge new models of female subjectivity. The focus of Chapter 2 is an exploration of how different theatrical forms might accommodate expression of the unhomely experience: the fractured realism of Paula Meehan’s Mrs Sweeney attempts to engage with spaces beyond the boundaries of the realist stage while the Brechtian-influenced fluid performance style of Mary Elizabeth Burke-Kennedy’s Women in Arms reshapes myth and the landscape through the body. In Chapters 1 and 5 we see how Eva Gore-Booth utilizes symbolism to engage with realms beyond the mimetic stage world to advocate non-binary and non-essential gendered and sexual identities. In contrast, Lady Gregory deploys naturalism to defend the eponymous Grania as a desiring subject in tension with her mythic frame (see Chapter 3). Through a range of theatrical forms, the plays deploy ‘genuine’ myth to reveal a disjunction between the confined onstage world that the female protagonists are forced to adapt to and an alternative world which enables their expression and agency and is suggested through performance.
The notion of ‘genuine’ mythmaking is thus fundamental to my argument and I uncover the theatrical strategies which open up myth and enable both interrogation and innovation; ‘to understand myth, “fragile” as it is, as a disclosure rather than a dogma: as a narrative whose potential always evades the given order, with its illusion of truth’.Footnote 71 Ricoeur’s use of the word ‘genuine’ to describe his liberatory and open-ended myth may suggest an original or authentic myth and thus an essentialist agenda. However, his deployment of the term is more ethical in its connotations as his utopian vision resists the limits imposed by myths which look to the past and congeal meaning (and, of particular relevance to this study, significations of femininity), and thus opens onto ‘other possible worlds’. I make reference to Ricoeur’s notion of ‘genuine’ mythmaking throughout but in order to avoid the essentialist connotations inferred by the term ‘genuine’, I refer to liberatory myth in process, which encompasses both creation and critique, as interrogative myth.
My use of the term interrogative myth also draws on Kearney’s suggestion that myth function as a verb: as an ongoing process of retelling and, in the context of the work discussed in this book, reperformance. Myth attempts to suppress cultural context but it is also reinvigorated by it; old mythic worlds are retold to offer new worlds which are informed by, and reinterpreted in, the present. Thus, self-conscious awareness of myth’s incompleteness, of it as an ongoing process, offers the possibility for critical intervention. Myth as a process which counters dominant and patriarchal ideologies is central to this book: unloosing models of femininity perpetuated through myth into an ongoing process of negotiation. Myth as verb can facilitate women’s participation in the cultural fabric of society; not simply as the icons of myth, but as authors who rewrite these models. Kearney delineates between the Irish revivalists’ mythmaking in the early twentieth century which, he argues, calcified into nationalist ideology, in contrast to James Joyce’s mythmaking in Ulysses: ‘Whereas myth was a noun for the Irish revivalists it was a verb for Joyce.’Footnote 72 My analysis of riverrun in the concluding chapter expands on the limits of Joyce’s mythmaking as verb: Fouéré’s re-vision of the final section of Finnegan’s Wake is rewritten by Anna Livia Plurabelle’s body. Moreover, my analysis of the tableaux vivants performed by the Inghinidhe na hÉireann illustrates that myth was not a noun for these women: their mythmaking was very much engaged in ‘pluralising futures’ and the creation of an independent Irish state which incorporated gender equality. Yet, as detailed in Chapter 1, their mythmaking in process has been largely ignored by Irish theatre scholarship due to disregard of the ways in which it is animated by corporeal experience and female expression.
The Body as the Unhomely Archive
My exploration of embodied mythmaking addresses the resurfacing of obscured (theatrical) histories of female corporal experience, as well as the expression of a creative female corporeality. This approach raises two intertwined issues which are fundamental to my study: how to write the body and how to document the body. These questions give rise to the overarching question of this book, namely how to ‘house’ the body of women’s work in Irish theatre. In Performing Remains: Art and War in Times of Theatrical Reenactment, Rebecca Schneider interrogates performance studies enthralment to concepts of vanishing, ephemerality and disappearance to ask, ‘if we think of performance as the antithesis of preservation, do we limit ourselves to an understanding of performance predetermined by a cultural habituation to the patrilineal, West-identified (arguably white-cultural) logic of the archive?’Footnote 73 Schneider argues that ‘the logic of the archive, […] [does] in fact demand that performance disappear’Footnote 74 and thus the question is how do we address the ways in which performance remains? This book reveals the body as the unhomely presence in an archive of myths of femininity: tracing the residue and impact of these myths forms the connective tissue in a network of embodied mythmaking. The role of the body in the transmission of memory is central to my argument and it is the female writing body which facilitates the reappearance and reassertion of the archive’s remains; fleshing out a rich and unmined vein of creativity and resistance in Irish theatre.
In The Archive and the Repertoire, Diana Taylor looks to the ways in which ‘traditions are stored in the body’ and communicated in the present.Footnote 75 Taylor proposes that counter to the archive, ‘The repertoire on the other hand, enacts embodied memory: performances, gestures, orality, movement, dance, singing – in short, all those acts usually thought of as ephemeral, nonreproducible knowledge.’Footnote 76 Taylor’s assertion of the validity of embodied memory resonates with my examination of embodied mythmaking. However, Schneider warns against the binary logic which opposes archive and performance ‘as if writing were not an embodied act, nor an embodied encounter across time, and as if performance were not discursive (nor discourse performative or performatic)’.Footnote 77 Schneider goes on to outline how Taylor ‘works to situate the repertoire as another kind of archive, rather than emphasizing the twin effort of situating the archive as another kind of performance’.Footnote 78 Schneider suggests that the archive is therefore
also part of an embodied repertoire – a set of live practices of access, given to take place in a house (the literal archive) built for live encounter with privileged remains, remains that, ironically, script the encountering body as disappearing even as the return of the body is assumed by the very logic of preservation that assumes disappearance. That is, the split between archive and repertoire, a split that Taylor to some extent reiterates, is the archive’s own division.Footnote 79
Through the process of writing this book I am performing an archive; I am engaged in the act of retrieving and preserving performances in order to house their remains. Yet, as already discussed, within the fabric of Ireland’s cultural and social life, women’s experience is one marked by unhomeliness. Thus, by acknowledging ‘the archive [as] a live performance space, and the performance space [as] an archive for the revenant’,Footnote 80 the act of interrogative mythmaking examined in this book is one shaped by resurfacing and remains. However, rather than resting with claims for this work as an archive I engage with the historiography of Irish theatre studies to conceive of the work collected in this archive as a genealogy of women in Irish theatre. The genealogy offers an alternative approach to studying, anthologizing and teaching Irish theatre which offers the means to engage further with alternative histories to the male-dominated literary canon of Irish theatre.
A Genealogy of Women in Irish Theatre
Fiona Becket suggests that Carr’s The Mai and Portia Coughlan ‘disrupt the presumed solidarity of mother/daughter (daughter/mother) relationships that frequently underpin feminist family mythologies’.Footnote 81 In By the Bog of Cats … Hester’s matrilineal relationships similarly question the benefits of this model of genealogy and Hester denies its perpetuation by killing her daughter. Mother/daughter relationships which result in physical violence recur through Carr’s plays; they are evident in Portia Coughlan and Ariel, supporting Becket’s argument that Carr’s work ‘challenge[s] the notion that a strong feminine identity rests on the familial, female kinship, model’.Footnote 82 Carr confronts the idealized mother/daughter relationship and exposes how female genealogies can function repressively, perpetuating a closed mythic system of a patriarchal familial which denies difference and change. However, Carr’s mythmaking also opens up ‘other possible worlds’, thereby supporting Luce Irigaray’s suggestion that when female relationships are refigured outside of the familial model which grants pre-eminence to the idealized mother, strong lines of female genealogy can offer opposition to patriarchal lineage:
In our societies, the mother/daughter, daughter/mother relationship constitutes a highly explosive nucleus. Thinking it, and changing it, is equivalent to shaking the foundations of the patriarchal order.Footnote 83
The structure of this book is intended to aid the process of rethinking a matrilineal tradition in Irish theatre.
In order to assert a coalition of women in Irish theatre united by their unhomely experience and mobilized through the collective action of embodied mythmaking, I employ Alison Stone’s conception of a genealogy through which she explores the potential of Judith Butler’s advocation of ‘a feminist genealogy of the category of women’.Footnote 84 Stone outlines the bind that feminism found itself in from the 1980s onwards: namely that post-structural anti-essentialism seemed to undercut the possibility of women existing as a distinct social group. Following Friedrich Nietzsche’s work on genealogy, Stone argues for a feminist genealogy wherein ‘all cultural constructions of femininity re-interpret pre-existing constructions and thereby compose a history of overlapping chains of interpretation, within which all women are situated’.Footnote 85 The emphasis is on how women ‘are assembled into a determinate social group through their location in this complex history’, rather than sharing ‘a common understanding or experience of femininity’.Footnote 86 It is therefore essential to address the different myths of femininity within their historical framework, as well as the experiences and histories which inform the embodied mythmaking of the women in this genealogy of Irish theatre. The experiences of Ascendency class women at the turn of the century, such as Eva Gore-Booth, differ in many ways from those of the contemporary writer, working-class Dubliner Paula Meehan. The women are not united by essential characteristics, nor indeed are the myths; instead we can address the ways in which their work intersects through their interrogative mythmaking: ‘All women are thus located within chains of reinterpretation that bring them into complex filiations with one another.’Footnote 87 The women discussed in this book are mobilized around an action, embodied mythmaking, which draws attention to its socio-cultural situation. They explicitly engage in the process of breaking and creating links in the chains of reinterpretation of myths of femininity. Therefore, there are women in Irish theatre whose work I do not address but it is my hope that my proposal of the genealogy will open up the possibilities for future research that sheds new light on the (de)construction of the (Irish) theatrical canon.
The energy and dynamism which pulses through the body of mythmaking discussed in this book bears testament to women’s enduring demand for change, though what that means, both in terms of how it is negotiated, what the desired outcome is, and what is achieved, depends on the context of the period from which the play emerges. The difficulty of effecting transformation and change, metamorphosis and revolution, underlies each of the chapters that follow as power structures have proved to be resilient, though not insurmountable. Women’s progress towards equality in Ireland has met, and continues to meet, obstacles which have meant that not only has progress been inconsistently sustained, it has at times appeared to stall and threatened to disconnect a tradition of women in Irish theatre; for example, the conservatism of the decades of the Free State, the recessionary period of the 1980s, or late twentieth century postfeminism’s ‘undoing’ of feminism in the Celtic Tiger Years.Footnote 88 Yet, the performances discussed in this book speak to one another across the decades through their embodied mythmaking and my weaving together of these vibrant and rebellious voices marks my contribution to the performance of a genealogy of women in Irish theatre.
In order to rewrite history we need to reframe it and Stone’s genealogy as a coalition of difference offers an alternative to the male-dominated literary canon of Irish theatre. The chapters of this book are not organized chronologically and plays from different historical periods are placed alongside one another to offer an engagement which remains aware of their differing contexts, while concurrently drawing lines of connection. Women’s theatrical critique and rewriting of limiting myths of femininity coheres and overlaps, yet also diverges over the myths and limits that pertain to their specific context. Furthermore, the question of how the individual might make a meaningful intervention in the face of myth’s power (and the resilience of power structures) lies in myth’s communal aspect and is harnessed by the concept of the genealogy as a coalition. Some of the plays discussed here have not been performed; others have been performed but have left sparse records, while others have received national and/or international attention. Through my identification of a genealogy of women in Irish theatre, we can acknowledge how all these voices make important contributions to the ongoing and communal work of embodied mythmaking.
