Books devoted to landscape painting in China seem to come along only every few decades. This is the first book-length study to appear in English since Michael Sullivan's Symbols of Eternity: The Art of Landscape Painting in China (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1979), which in turn followed Sherman Lee's Chinese Landscape Painting (Cleveland: Cleveland Museum of Art, [1954] 1962). Completed in the 1990s and revised before Harrie Vanderstappen's death in 2007, The Landscape Painting of China: Musings of a Journeyman brings together a lifetime of thinking, studying, and teaching about the art of landscape painting in China.
In his introduction, Vanderstappen sets out his basic assumptions about Chinese landscape painting based in part on early texts. Nature is both tiandi and ziran; it is the painter's task to absorb the outward appearance (tiandi) and then proceed to reach its source, its inner reality (ziran). “In other words, the artist must understand the proper relationship between the thing as it appears and the energy that specifically accounts for its appearance” (p. 1). For Vanderstappen “the natural world is singularly contained within a clearly limited array of unchangeable patterns, and these forms of basic pictorial grammar are the matrix into which all later representational language is embedded” (p. 4). On brushwork, he comments: “As an understanding of the original patterns is the key to the essential order of things, so the stroke locks in on the patterns to give meaning and image to all appearances in nature” (p. 9). Thus “nature in Chinese landscape painting derives its image from subtle adaptations of inherited patterns” (p. 11). Grounded on such assumptions, Vanderstappen calls his approach a “visual based methodology.” His descriptions and analyses stem from careful looking, and although he states that he is not writing a history of Chinese landscape painting, his chronological chapters lead to a historical understanding.
For example, the Yuan dynasty is frequently seen as a turning point in the history of Chinese painting. Vanderstappen's visual analyses lead to a similar conclusion. In his discussion of Zhao Mengfu (1254–1322), he uses an unassuming album leaf of bamboo, rock, and tree painted in ink on silk to make the case. He describes how the arrangement is a manmade one, how each element of bamboo, rock, and tree may be thought of as drawn from memory based on carefully scrutinized classical precedents, thus reconciling the art of painting with the practical standards of classical precedence. He sees Zhao Mengfu's achievement in this small work as unprecedented. “It is as if the ritual of performance is of the utmost importance and takes precedence over any other consideration” (p. 159).
Vanderstappen characterizes another important transition in landscape painting during the early Ming dynasty with analyses of paintings by Dai Jin (1388–1462) and Shen Zhou (1427–1509). In his analysis of Shen's earliest surviving dated work, Living in Retirement (1464), Vanderstappen shows that by transforming quotes from the past into autonomous “scenographs,” Shen has focused his intentions on new pictorial means. He has combined mountains from different past traditions with details taken from the tradition of genre painting to create something new. Shen is not just quoting from the past: he has shaken himself loose from strict emulations of the art of the past. He has, in Vanderstappen's words, “made a change in the rituals that are allowed to function in a landscape painting” (p. 237). Shen Zhou has fit past traditions into his own choices; he has used them for his own aims.
In his analyses of paintings by the great mid-Ming painter Wen Zhengming (1470–1559), Vanderstappen raises issues of style and connoisseurship. He uses the term “style” in reference to all of the works of Wen Zhengming and recognizes that this is a narrow definition and one that compounds the problem of connoisseurship. He analyzes four paintings by Wen, two early and two late in the artist's career, before addressing the question of style head on. Each work follows a variety of historical traditions, and each appears quite different. It is the precise definition in the execution of each work that supersedes all of the historical references. Vanderstappen is relying on defining the hand of the artist in disparate works in order to characterize the artist's style. He is relying on connoisseurship.
In his final chapter, “Musing on the Fictitious World,” Vanderstappen comes to terms with Dong Qichang (1555–1636), who in his words “has become the classic obstacle, without the crossing of which there is no secure and fully recognized entry into the intricacies of meaning and understanding of Chinese painting” (p. 276). In his careful analyses of three paintings, Vanderstappen sees Dong's pictures as questioning all previous experiences about Chinese painting. Dong has employed the standard idioms of landscape—mountains and water, trees and buildings—but has decided that they no longer represent nature. Rather he has produced a “source of labyrinthine references to the history of Chinese painting, an enigma of fame to be studied and emulated” (pp. 275–76). Dong chose forms that go back to the beginnings of landscape and thereby hit upon the very origin of the appearance of mountains and nature. In Vanderstappen's view, Dong Qichang's putting new life into the earliest ritual forms of nature became part of the structure of his work, and this explains the tenacity of Dong's influence. Vanderstappen's analyses are convincing; Dong has indeed created fictitious worlds.
The subtitle of the book, “Musings of a Journeyman,” is deceptive. The chapters are anything but musings and Vanderstappen anything but a journeyman. One may not always agree with Vanderstappen's choice of paintings, particularly in the early periods, but his analyses are acute and well worth the effort to understand what he is doing. Despite his disclaimer that he is not writing a history of landscape painting in China, the reader comes away with a clear sense of change over time. Much is owed to Robert E. Covey, Vanderstappen's last student, for his editing of the manuscript. Unfortunately neither Vanderstappen nor Covey lived to see the book published in its present beautifully illustrated and elegantly designed form.
