This book is about the efforts of two mayors to improve life in Bogotá, Colombia, through the reshaping of public space. The example of Bogotá is well chosen because, as the author and numerous others have argued, Colombia's capital was transformed from a chaotic and financially broken metropolis in 1992 to an exemplar of how a city in the global South should be managed.
The book focuses on the efforts of two mayors, Antanas Mockus and Enrique Peñalosa, who, between 1995 and 2003, helped to transform the city both in the eyes of its citizens and in those of the international community. The author, Rachel Berney, labels the two as ‘public space mayors’ and argues that they ‘transformed Bogotá socially, culturally, and physically through the regeneration of the city's public urban environment in the space of a few years’ (p. xi). While I totally agree that their three administrations were exemplary, I query whether they achieved quite as much as she claims. I would also question whether the accolade of ‘public space mayors’ covers the full range of their undoubted achievements. Their efforts to improve public space were outstanding but they also made important changes in many other respects over the nine years (three administrations) that they managed the city. They helped improve the city's finances, its policing, its education and the quality of its public administration.
The author is an urban design specialist and the strength of the book lies in the discussion of various improvements made by the two mayors to public space in the city. These include building the Transmilenio Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) system, opening new parks, upgrading major squares in the city, creating a network of cycleways and erecting three magnificent mega-libraries. These examples are discussed in some detail in a series of ‘project snapshots’. These snapshots contain mainly positive comments but are not uncritical, particularly of the Parque Tercer Milenio and the Plaza San Victorino projects. Berney's evaluation is based on interviews with several major decision makers in the city, including the two ex-mayors, on a survey of 465 people using public space that was conducted in 2006, and on a literature review.
The book is clearly written and free of excessive academic posing but I have several reservations about Berney's account. The first concerns what she omits from the term ‘public space’. This term clearly includes parks, squares, streets and transport, but should it not also include housing and public services? This is a significant omission insofar as Enrique Peñalosa set up an agency called Metrovivienda which sought to create new formal social housing estates. These, he hoped, would eventually eliminate the need for the informal self-help settlement that has traditionally accommodated most of the city's poor. These estates would not only provide housing but would create a new way of living based on access to good services, parks and cycleways. While Metrovivienda failed in many respects to achieve this noble goal, it is odd that its operations find no space in this book. Equally surprising is that there is virtually no discussion of the programmes that led to upgrading and legalisation of the city's informal settlements – arguably one of the most significant achievements of those three Bogotá administrations.
Second, the book is based on fieldwork conducted in 2005 and 2006. No doubt the author has been back to Bogotá since then, but very little is said about how the city has fared under subsequent administrations. There is a short chapter updating the situation but it is too brief to be very useful and too much is dedicated to citing the aims of Enrique Peñalosa's return to the mayoralty in 2016. The lack of an update is important because the achievements of Mockus and Peñalosa in transforming the city can properly be judged only over time. The construction of Transmilenio was a magnificent achievement but it has gone through some rocky periods since and its operation is widely criticised by its users. Similarly, Mockus's noble attempts to improve bogotanos’ driving habits did not survive intact and he is currently helping the new administration to improve driving behaviour. Even the fabric of the city's excellent network of cycleways has suffered from neglect. Good administration it is not a once in a life-time change; it is a process that must be maintained through time. Unfortunately, while Bogotá has in no sense reverted to its pre-1992 chaos, it has suffered from a degree of neglect and from one particularly disastrous and corrupt administration.
Third, the book is virtually devoid of politics. The city council is barely mentioned, nor is the role of party politics. More significantly there is no discussion why the local population did not show more appreciation of these great mayors at the ballot box. Why did bogotanos vote in the three socialist administrations from 2003 to 2015? Why was Enrique Peñalosa defeated by both Samuel Moreno in 2007 and Gustavo Petro in 2011 and why did he manage to win the election again only in 2015? The answer is that, rightly or wrongly, the poor of Bogotá did not believe that the transformation wrought by Mockus and Peñalosa properly addressed their problems. The voting patterns show that the poor favoured the Left against the representatives of continuity; voters in the poorer parts of the city did not think that the ‘public space mayors’ had done enough to resolve their concerns about employment and poverty. More should have been said in this book about the electoral response to these great mayors and used the results of the annual Bogotá Cómo Vamos polls to record the public's opinion about them.
Finally, the book refers in several places to the results of the survey the author conducted in 2006. Unfortunately, we are not told how she conducted this survey, how representative it was nor what questions were asked. Nor are we told much about its results.
In sum, this is a worthy book insofar as it discusses several significant urban space projects in a city which was greatly improved in the late 1990s and early 2000s. But given that the book was not published until 2017, more should have been done to fill in the decade-long gap between the period of field work and publication. As the author rightly recognises, Antanas Mockus and Enrique Peñalosa could not have been expected to eliminate several centuries of inequality in their nine years in office, but their major achievements can properly be evaluated properly only over time.
