The title of Catherine Loomis and Sid Ray's collection of essays, Shaping Shakespeare for Performance, acknowledges the gap between playtext and performance and the many editors, critics, directors, and actors who work to bridge that gap. The twenty-three brief essays in this collection all address aspects of this gap. The book's subtitle, The Bear Stage, might seem a bit more perplexing at first, but it cleverly refers to two concepts. One is the Renaissance myth that “bear whelps were thought to be born as lumps of matter—sans teeth, sans eyes, sans taste, sans everything—that the mother bear then licked into shape” (xvi). In Loomis and Ray's conception, a playtext is like this mythological whelp, licked into shape by a variety of collaborators. The other referent for the subtitle is the conference from which the essays come: the 2013 iteration of the biannual Blackfriars Conference at the American Shakespeare Center (ASC) in Staunton, Virginia. Papers at the conference are delivered from the stage of the ASC's recreation of Shakespeare's indoors Blackfriars theatre and are extremely brief: thirteen minutes if scholars deliver a paper and use the ASC's resident actors to illustrate their argument, or ten minutes if delivered without actors. Papers never go overtime because another special feature of the conference is that, once the allotted time has expired, an actor enters in a silly bear costume and snatches the paper of the long-winded speaker, who must then “exit, pursued by a bear.”
Because of the brevity of the chapters in the collection, it is impossible to mention all of them in this review. However, Loomis and Ray have helpfully broken the book into five parts organized around themes. The first of these, “‘Edit, Pursued by a Bear’: Essays on Editing Shakespeare for the Stage and the Page,” replicates the title of the 2013 Blackfriars conference and contains three essays: Ann Thompson's excellent overview of the challenges facing a Shakespearean editor; Ann Pleiss Morris's discussion of the way in which Renaissance prologues and inductions, rather like modern-day curtain speeches about turning off cell phones, are designed to “turn [audience members] into collaborators” (20), aligned with the overall project of the play; and Cass Morris's discussion of how actors can find cues and clues in punctuation, which is often altered by editors. The second part of the book, “‘I must bear a part’: Essays on Analyzing and Playing Character,” focuses on the memorable—albeit, as Matt Kozusko argues, not “relatable” but “unfamiliar and difficult” (40)—characters that emerge through the performance of the texts. Here, the most engaging essays are by professional actors: Paige Martin Reynolds, who discusses performing Regan from a feminist perspective; and James Keegan, an ASC company member who describes his performance of the epilogue to 2 Henry IV as Falstaff. Part III, “‘Devil in a bear's doublet’: Essays on Shaping Performance,” deals with directorial choices, altering texts for performance, and the defining choices made by theatrical companies. The most fascinating essays here are historical: Danielle Rosvally's meticulously researched examination of the African Grove Theatre, which she argues “clearly challenged English stage hegemony” (136) in nineteenth-century New York; and Loomis's own New Historicist essay that provides a detailed historical survey of bearbaiting in Renaissance London in order to craft an argument about potential references in and performance options for The Winter's Tale.
The fourth part, “‘Dissembling Cub[s]’: Essays on Staging the Metatheatrical,” engages with mimesis and the audience's role in constructing the play by suspending—or refraining from suspending—disbelief. Here, utilizing close textual readings and focusing on roles probably played by actor John Sincklo, Alan Armstrong presents a compelling case that “Elizabethan companies practiced candid doubling, not troubling to disguise the fact that their plays had more roles than the company had actors” (189). Peter Hyland writes about the anonymous play Mucedorus (which opens with a bear chasing two characters), arguing that this “‘undemanding’ play [that] was very much in demand” (204) succeeded with audiences because of a tonal mutability that led to metatheatrical irony. The final part, “‘Bear the verses’: Essays on Rhetoric and Performance,” comprises three essays on rhetoric and style. Of these, the most noteworthy is Russ McDonald's concluding chapter. Equally provocative and infuriating (and somewhat tongue-in-cheek), McDonald argues for the pleasures of the text, of pragmatic literary criticism, and of uncut performances of Shakespeare. He lambasts “the reductiveness performed by the clumsy editorial hand of the theater director” (263) and blames “contemporary habits of attention” (266) for theatrical choices he sometimes calls “act[s] of vandalism” (265).
Shaping Shakespeare for Performance is a collection of essays that are thoroughly engaging, often preserving the voice of the speakers and the humor that can enliven the best conference papers. The chapters are not, however, conference papers: they have clearly been significantly expanded and revised (although, as some authors note, on the page they necessarily lack the demonstrations available from ASC actors at the conference). The collection is strengthened by the diversity of the contributors: preeminent Shakespeareans, emerging scholars, actors from the ASC company, and even a practicing lawyer. It is worth noting that the book is almost a festschrift, since several essays pay tribute to George Walton Williams IV, who was the honoree of the 2013 conference. It does have some flaws: like any collection of essays, not all contributions are equally convincing or thoroughly researched. The book also lacks a list of illustrations and comprehensive bibliography of sources cited in individual essays. Most significantly, many authors discuss “original practices” Shakespearean performance, but this trend in performance (in which the ASC is a prime mover) is never interrogated critically. Overall, however, the book is thought-provoking, useful to Shakespearean scholars, and an important synthesis of scholarly contributions at a noteworthy conference in the field, so these are minor problems that are easy to bear.
