Curtis M. Hinsley, coeditor of this collected volume, explains that the seventy years between 1870 and 1940 can be labelled the Age of Expositions (489). At the height of the fair phenomenon, between 1890 and 1910, twenty-two of these events occurred in American cities. While the Chicago World's Fair of 1893 was one constituent of a larger global discourse over global power relations reflected in the fairs, no other event had the same initial and lasting impact.
World's fairs influenced developments in architecture, urban planning, music, painting, consumerism and mass entertainment. The meanings of Chicago's fair have been widely researched and discussed, leading Timothy Gilfoyle in his 1988 article “White Cities, Linguistic Turns, and Disneylands” to call the event “an interpretive smorgasbord.”Footnote 1 In doing so, Gilfoyle used the event as an illustration of the various strands of urban history. Curtis M. Hinsley and David R. Wilcox also use the fair to explain the developments in a field of study, and their focus is American anthropology.
In order to investigate the complex institutional and intellectual roots and developments of American anthropology, primary documents are presented alongside new essays concerned with the wide array of thinkers, planners, dreamers and schemers present at Chicago. The book is envisioned as a dialogue between the immediate voices of the fair and views of contemporary scholars, and is largely successful in this undertaking.
Chicago's fair was a catalytic event in the professionalization of American anthropology (263). The personnel at Chicago represented a transition in anthropological theory and the event bore witness to a generational shift in which systematic, empirical work in the field became the hallmark of professional practice (491). It was anthropologists such as Fredric Ward Putnam, Frank Hamilton Cushing (each of whom has a dedicated essay) and, of course, Franz Boas who benefited from growing organizational authority and emphasis on fieldwork experiences.
Of course, no anthropologist present in Chicago knew which direction the field would take. The Chicago Fair projected future possibilities and dead ends; anthropologist Richard Wetherill arrived at the fair with dreams and a career trajectory that first appeared to rise but then plummeted, while Warren King Moorehead's ambitions flattened but finally ascended with a new century and patron (490). This is why the juxtaposition of modern essays with the primary documents is useful, because it gives the reader a glimpse of what might have been through discussions about the trajectories of the discipline.
The connection between the burgeoning field of anthropology and wealthy individual sponsors, institutions and museums is also interrogated in this collection. Donald McVicker's essay deals with “patrons and popularizers” (375). Robert W. Rydell in his 1984 classic study All the World's a Fair: Visions of Empire at American International Expositions, 1876–1916 carefully constructed the mutually beneficial relationships between world's fairs and institutions such as the Smithsonian to demonstrate how a national and transnational hegemony based on Anglo-Saxon white superiority was created (2). While the Chicago fair did lay the groundwork for museums, academic departments and expeditions, this collection adds nuance to the relationships between individuals and institutions, and the messages they sought to deliver (264). By dealing with the cultural origins of anthropology this collection is also a reminder of the interplay between the discipline and the public spectacle at the fair.
The spectacle of the fair, which was commented upon by contemporaries and has continued to appeal, is dealt with in this collection in an interesting way. A visual interlude of rarely seen images from the fair is included alongside a brief interpretation written by Hinsley, which draws attention to the way in which the fair was advertised and how the “anthropological cacophony of the Midway,” the area of exotic “Others” and commercial entertainments, was often reported (240). Hinsley reminds the reader that the humorous reportage was often at odds with the anthropologists’ endeavours. However, the racism prevalent in the display of colonized peoples as both resources and products in the Midway and other parts of the fair, and how this may have affected the field of anthropology, is never wholly dealt with in this collection.
This is a large, densely packed collection which presupposes more than a basic level of understanding about the origins of anthropology and the major debates within the field. It will be of use to scholars of the discipline, those who are looking for further biographical details, and of course those interested in the wide-ranging and long-lasting impact of Chicago's World's Fair.
