This article began as a proposal to APSA for a new journal that would expand the scope of existing print journals, thereby allowing scholars to quickly communicate their research to a wider community in a more succinct format. This proposal reflects a desire to encourage more effective communication about political science research across subfields as well as to audiences outside of the discipline. The short, focused articles to be published in Political Science Research would give political scientists a way to speak to larger audiences free of the jargon and “inside baseball” discussions that characterize how political scientists often convey their research to the discipline.
The format of Political Science Research will allow scholars in all subfields to present their work to a larger audience in new and exciting ways. Just as a 30-page article is a different way to convey ideas than a full-length book, a 3,000- to 4,000-word e-article is not the same type of communicative instrument as a 30-page print article. An e-article has the potential to be more visually dynamic because of the electronic interface. For example, a 3,000-word e-article can be linked to a long technical appendix for a piece of quantitative research. Similarly, a qualitative study could easily link to videos and primary texts. Regardless of their subfield or methodological orientation, researchers can use the electronic format to present their findings in different ways. The electronic format also will allow researchers to provide precise documentation of their methods (via links) for interested readers. Over time, it is expected that scholars will take advantage of the electronic format in new and creative ways. In this way, Political Science Research can be a more flexible venue for research than existing journals.
From the start, Political Science Research will be an important journal. By preserving the integrity of peer review in an innovative format, Political Science Research has the potential to make political science insights and discoveries more accessible, relevant, and valuable to broader audiences.
The journal was originally proposed as “APSR-Prime” by Adam Berinsky and Arthur Lupia. In October 2012, the APSA Council remanded the proposal to the Committee on Publications for further consideration and resolution of specific issues that had been identified by the committee, the council, and others. The committee prepared a report in 2013 that was subsequently published in PS: Political Science and Politics. Footnote 1
To reflect this author’s current thinking about the journal, this proposal has been modified since it was originally submitted to the APSA Council in 2012.
OBJECTIVES
Political Science Research is a new journal that provides focused, peer-reviewed articles on topics of interest to political science. Articles will state a distinct research question and address it within an all-inclusive 3,000- to 4,000-word format. The relatively low word limit will encourage scholars to succinctly describe the value of their arguments and findings in an accessible manner. Articles will be posted online on a rolling basis. A printed volume also will be sent to authors, subscribers, and libraries at least once a year.
Political Science Research will provide a unique venue for political scientists of all subfields and methodological approaches to exchange information about new research. The journal will decrease the cost of communication among political scientists—and from political scientists to the general public—by providing a central location where audiences can access focused research articles on important topics. The journal also may increase the pace of discovery by disseminating findings as soon as they pass peer review rather than the typical months or even years after the research is accepted for publication. Ultimately, Political Science Research will increase the visibility of the discipline and provide significant benefits to APSA members.
BACKGROUND
Two strengths of political science are the diverse backgrounds and the eclectic methodological orientations of its scholars. These strengths, however, also introduce inefficiencies. When submitting articles to a leading journal, many scholars assume they should include an extended defense of their method and/or a demonstration of their understanding of the relevant literature. These efforts may be valuable and informative, but they are not always necessary for effective scholarly communication.
The guiding principle behind Political Science Research is to give scholars a new, dynamic, and effective way to present their ideas. The journal provides the opportunity to convey important ideas in a format that existing publication options do not permit: short, compactly focused research articles.
Political Science Research will provide APSA members with a unique service that cannot be obtained elsewhere. In principle, anyone can write a blog with short articles; however, none would ensure the high quality and broad perspectives that are possible under APSA’s auspices. Other associations (e.g., the Berkeley Electronic Press) publish short articles online, but they have neither the built-in brand equity nor the diverse talent pool—and, hence, the potential for broad acceptance—of APSA. Political Science Research will give scholars compelling reasons to join APSA.
PUBLICATION REQUIREMENTS
To submit a manuscript to Political Science Research, scholars must offer an original contribution that does not cover material already published elsewhere. Articles may be a maximum of 4,000 words (all-inclusive), but shorter manuscripts will be encouraged. There will be a “soft limit” on the number of tables, figures, and links to supportive materials (e.g., case studies and texts) that can be included. Consequently, published papers must contain ideas and findings that can be stated concisely.
The content of each article must be self-contained; that is, it must be readable in its entirety without reference to other materials. An appendix can provide further detail, but the article must be comprehensible without it. An appendix can include but is not limited to explicitly referenced textual materials or datasets, formal proofs, and analyses that supplement those in the text. An appendix is not the place to develop new arguments that are not discussed in the article. However, appendices and links allow an author to provide additional substance to the research presented in the published article.
Articles written from various methodological and substantive approaches will fit well in the framework of Political Science Research. Researchers in American politics, comparative politics, and international relations who use quantitative methods could publish their results of a key analysis or a focused experiment that yields insight about a specific facet of political decision making. For example, the field experiments of Alan Gerber and Don Green on voting turnout would be appropriate for the Political Science Research format.
Scholars who study comparative politics using qualitative methods could publish a detailed treatment of a single case study. For example, Peter Swenson’s influential examination of the relative roles of labor and capital in welfare-state development in Denmark and Sweden would fit well in Political Science Research. Qualitative comparativists also could publish conceptual pieces; an overview of James Mahoney’s work on path dependence, for example, is appropriate for this format. Furthermore, qualitative scholars could publish research that is centered on a particular methodological issue. For instance, the focused discussion of Richard Locke and Kathleen Thelen’s explorations of “contextualized comparisons” that was published in the APSA Comparative Politics newsletter would fit well in Political Science Research.
Similarly, political theorists could publish several different types of articles. Footnote 2 First, they could publish short and concise pieces that engage ongoing debates in political theory. For instance, the Journal of Political Philosophy published an article by Christopher Heath Wellman titled “Debate: Taking Human Rights Seriously,” which continued an ongoing debate in that journal. Second, theorists could publish short articles that tackle questions of normative theory. Philip Pettit has written several pieces, including a 2006 article in Analysis titled “When to Defer to Majority Testimony—and When Not.” Third, theorists who focus on the history of political thought could publish articles that are commentary on the arguments of other contemporary or historical authors. For example, they could take issue with a crucial but limited aspect of another author’s publication about a particular theorist.
In time, it is expected that Political Science Research will become a major outlet for political science work. By establishing a unique publishing venue in the discipline, it will attract the best work of leading scholars in all fields of political science. However, Political Science Research is significantly different than existing journals; therefore, when it is launched, APSA must encourage scholars to rethink how an article looks, regardless of their substantive or methodological interests. What distinguishes Political Science Research from almost every other political science journal, after all, is not its substantive coverage or preferred research methodology. Rather, it is the brevity of articles and the speed with which they allow researchers to communicate important ideas.
What distinguishes Political Science Research from nearly almost every other journal in political science journal… is the brevity of the articles and the speed with which they allow researchers to communicate important ideas.
Hence, the editors of Political Science Research must educate both authors and reviewers about soliciting articles that eliminate extended reviews of previous work—which characterize much of what is published in existing journals. The editors should insist that every sentence count with a premium on transparency, clarity, and rigor.
REVIEW PROCESS
To ensure that they meet the journal’s standards of excellence and style, all articles submitted to Political Science Research will be peer reviewed and subject to editorial evaluation.
Although the details are not yet worked out, two governing principles will guide the review-process design: ease and speed. We recognize the increased reviewing burden placed on the scholarly community, and we anticipate that the brevity of submissions to Political Science Research will ease their task. Nevertheless, it is crucial that a simple and convenient system be created that allows reviewers to communicate their assessment of an article’s merits.
The second governing principle is speed. At existing journals, it is not uncommon for scholars to wait six months to a year to learn the fate of their submission—and then another year before the article appears in print. Political Science Research will strive to significantly reduce the turnaround time by streamlining the review process and posting articles online soon after they are accepted. The National Science Foundation–funded Time-Sharing Experiments for the Social Sciences project demonstrated that it is possible to obtain high-quality reviews of scholarship in a few weeks; however, potential reviewers must be assured that the manuscripts they are asked to review will be short. The brevity of the articles published in Political Science Research should facilitate a similarly expeditious review process.
EDITORIAL GOVERNANCE
Given the many types of work conducted and topics covered in political science, the editorial team will require broad expertise across subfields and methodological approaches. The lead editor will have primary responsibility for the content of Political Science Research, but a team of associate editors—each with significant decision-making authority—will have a critical role in the editorial process.
When a manuscript is submitted, it first will be read by the lead editor and then assigned to a relevant associate editor. The associate editor—in consultation with the lead editor—will decide if the manuscript should be sent out for review or desk-rejected. If it is sent out, the associate editor will select appropriate reviewers (also in consultation with the lead editor). Final publication will be at the discretion of the editors; the lead editor is ultimately responsible for editorial decisions, but, he or she will lean heavily on the expertise and judgment of the relevant associate editor for each manuscript.
Given the wide Political Science Research constituency, it is important to have a diverse team of associate editors that reflects the variety of substantive and methodological approaches used by APSA members. Therefore, in the start-up period, the associate editors will be chosen by the lead editor, with the advice and consent of the APSA Council. This will ensure that the editorial team reflects the varied approaches to the study of political science. Footnote 3
In addition to the editorial team, there will be an editorial board selected to reflect the diverse expertise in different fields of political science. The lead editor also will choose board members, with the advice and consent of the APSA Council.
JOURNAL HOMEPAGE
The homepage of the journal’s website will feature an interface that allows users to search for articles by topical area, month submitted, and other criteria. APSA also will publish a print version that includes all Political Science Research articles.
A message board that invites commentary will be attached to the homepage for each article. This will facilitate communication within the scholarly community about the merits of a particular article, its contribution to the field, and its linkages to other articles published in Political Science Research and elsewhere. All APSA members will be allowed to post messages. However, they must authenticate their identity by first logging into their APSA account, including their full name and institutional affiliation in any comments posted. In this way, thoughtful and respectful scholarly discussion about published articles is encouraged.
DEMAND AND POTENTIAL AUDIENCE
When this journal was first proposed in 2011, nothing like Political Science Research existed in the discipline. However, Psychological Science provides a close analogy on several dimensions. Although it was started as recently as 1990, its impact factor is already seventh highest of 120 multidisciplinary psychology journals throughout the world. Similar to this proposal, Psychological Science uses a competitive peer-review process and publishes only short articles. It currently receives approximately 1,800 submissions annually. The 20,000 members of the American Psychological Association receive a subscription to Psychological Science as part of their annual dues, ensuring a large and diverse readership.
The journal Science, which is produced by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, also publishes articles of a similar length proposed for Political Science Research. Science is known for publishing short and impactful pieces, and it is an effective venue for conveying scientific ideas to a worldwide audience. Recently, Science began a digital-only journal, Science Advances, that shares many of the same characteristics of the proposed Political Science Research. Footnote 4 Clearly, there is substantial demand for this type of journal in the scholarly community.
Indeed, since the proposal for Political Science Research first circulated, a new journal titled Research and Politics has begun publication. Similar to Political Science Research, it is designed to publish concise articles in a timely manner. Footnote 5 However, even with the introduction of Research and Politics, there is room for Political Science Research in the discipline. Research and Politics is an open-access journal that needs to generate a revenue stream, which may limit its impact. More important, although Research and Politics has an excellent editorial team, it will not have the reach of Political Science Research that, in conjunction with APSA, will work to support and advance the interests of the association.
BUSINESS PLAN
The business plan for Political Science Research was not developed in the initial proposal. At that time, the expectation was that it could be bundled with existing APSA journals published by Cambridge University Press. The APSA Committee on Publications has explored options with various publishers and has since developed a business plan, which is discussed in detail in the committee report referenced previously.
Because the articles are shorter than those of other peer- reviewed outlets, Political Science Research has the potential to make political science research more accessible to new audiences.
SUMMARY AND FINAL CONCLUSION
Political Science Research is a unique way for APSA to support and advance the political science discipline. It leverages evolving technologies to hasten and facilitate new types of communication and collaboration—among political scientists as well as between political scientists and those outside of the discipline. Because the articles are shorter than those of other peer-reviewed outlets, Political Science Research has the potential to make political science research more accessible to new audiences.
Political Science Research can generate many benefits for APSA and its members, and we hope that the association will support this endeavor. The APSA Committee on Publications report published in PS: Political Science and Politics was an important step in this direction. We are in full agreement with that report and believe it reflects progress toward establishing this important new journal.
