Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:10:18.699Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Regime transitions in flow past porous spheres: the competition between internal inertial dissipation and wake suppression

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 October 2026

Yulong Wang
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei 430074, PR China
Yan Cui*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei 430074, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Yan Cui, yan_cui@hust.edu.cn

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

The aerodynamic drag of porous spheres is governed by a regime-dependent competition between permeability-induced drag reduction and internal inertial dissipation. Using a hierarchical constructive solid geometry framework and pore-resolved lattice Boltzmann simulations ($0.02 \leq Re_{{p}} \leq 200$), we identify two non-monotonic transitions. First, a porosity-driven drag reversal occurs near $Re_{{p}} \approx 20$: in the viscous regime, increased porosity mitigates resistance by relieving windward stagnation pressure; conversely, in the inertial regime, the dominance of distributed internal Forchheimer resistance creates a drag penalty that offsets the benefits of macroscopic wake suppression. Second, a surface-area-driven drag crossover emerges in the transitional regime ($Re_{{p}} \approx 20 {-} 50$), where a finer internal skeleton structurally reorganises the penetrating flow to attenuate the near-wake recirculation intensity. We propose a physically based semi-empirical drag correlation that explicitly superposes viscous friction, boundary-layer development and inertial drag terms. The model captures the simulated aerodynamic responses and is validated against independent experiments, providing a quantitative framework for characterising the aerodynamic behaviour of permeable particles.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the hierarchical negative-template CSG reconstruction strategy. The porous particle is generated by subtracting the union of Ωint$\varOmega _{{int}}$ and Ωsurf$\varOmega _{{surf}}$ from the constraint domain ΩA$\varOmega _{{A}}$, where the volume of this union dictates the porosity ε$\varepsilon$, and the surface coverage of Ωsurf$\varOmega _{{surf}}$ determines the surface opening ratio α$\alpha$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Orthogonal two-dimensional projections of the topological parameter space for the 18 porous models. (a) Distribution in the ε−α$\varepsilon {-}\alpha$ plane, illustrating the independent variation of porosity and surface opening ratio. (b,c) Projections involving the surface area ratio S′$S^{\prime }$, depicting its systematic variation alongside the minor fluctuations inherent in the stochastic generation of the porous skeletons.

Figure 2

Table 1.Geometric and aerodynamic specifications of the 18 reconstructed PLGA porous particle models. The table details the explicitly controlled topological parameters: volumetric porosity (ε$\varepsilon$), surface opening ratio (α$\alpha$) and surface area ratio (S′$S^{\prime }$). The effective dimensionless permeability (Da=K/Dp2$Da = K/D_{{p}}^2$) is extracted from macroscopic creeping flow drag computations (Rep=0.02$Re_{{p}} = 0.02$) using the Debye–Brinkman solution.Table 1 long description.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Configuration of the computational domain and boundary conditions. The particle is located 10Dp$10 D_{{p}}$ downstream from the inlet to allow flow development, and 30Dp$30 D_{{p}}$ upstream from the outlet to capture the spatial development of the wake.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Grid independence verification at the creeping flow limit (Rep=0.02, ε=0.713$Re_{{p}} = 0.02,\ \varepsilon = 0.713$). The drag factor demonstrates asymptotic convergence behaviour as the grid resolution increases. The red dashed line indicates the selected mesh density (1.8×107$1.8 \times 10^7$ cells).

Figure 5

Figure 5.Figure 5 long description.(a) Evolution of the absolute drag factor (CD⋅Rep$C_{{D}} \boldsymbol{\cdot }Re_{{p}}$) as a function of the particle Reynolds number. Leader lines at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$ delineate the relative ranking of the distinct porosity models. (b) Relative drag deviation (ΔCD(%)=(CD,porous−CD,solid)/CD,solid×100%$\Delta C_{{D}} (\%) = (C_{{D},{porous}}-C_{{D},{solid}}) / C_{{D},{solid}} \times 100\,\%$) against the LBM solid-sphere baseline. The Rep$Re_{{p}}$ axis is plotted on a semi-logarithmic scale to expand the viscous regime. The crossover from negative values (drag reduction) to positive values (drag penalty) occurs between Rep=20$Re_{{p}}=20$ and 50, marking the transition between the drag-reduction and drag-penalty regimes.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Variation of the normalised drag ratio (CD∗=CD,porous/CD,solid$C_{{D}}^* = C_{{D},{porous}} / C_{{D},{solid}}$) with porosity (ε$\varepsilon$) across different Reynolds numbers. These trends highlight the dual role of porosity: higher porosity enhances drag reduction (CD∗<1$C_{{D}}^* \lt 1$) in the viscous regime, but amplifies the drag penalty (CD∗>1$C_{{D}}^* \gt 1$) in the inertial regime.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Pressure distribution and flow topology at Rep=1$Re_{{p}}=1$. (a) Comparison of Cp$C_{\!{p}}$ contours and streamline patterns for an impermeable solid sphere (left) and a high-porosity particle (ε=0.901$\varepsilon =0.901$, right). (b) Streamwise distribution of the area-averaged pressure coefficient, Cp(x)$C_{\!{p}} (x)$. The area average is computed exclusively over the fluid phase (excluding the solid skeleton) within a transverse circular plane of radius 0.6Dp$0.6 D_{{p}}$ at each streamwise location. The one-dimensional profiles demonstrate a distinct attenuation of the leading-edge pressure peak (x/Dp≈−0.5$x/D_{{p}} \approx -0.5$) for the highly porous particle compared with the solid sphere.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Comparison of pressure coefficient (Cp$C_{\!{p}}$) contours (a) and three-dimensional streamline trajectories (b) at Rep=10$Re_{{p}}=10$. The low-porosity model (ε=0.494$\varepsilon =0.494$) exhibits pronounced flow bypass, while the high-porosity model (ε=0.901$\varepsilon =0.901$) is characterised by deep straight-through penetration.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Streamwise distribution of the internal fluid flux at Rep=10$Re_{{p}}=10$. The dimensionless volume flow rate is evaluated over the local envelope cross-section Scross(x)$S_{{cross}}(x)$ and normalised by the particle frontal area A0$A_0$. The high-porosity model (ε=0.901$\varepsilon =0.901$) exhibits a peak flow rate more than three times higher than that of the low-porosity model.

Figure 10

Table 2.Characteristic local pore-scale Reynolds number for representative porous particles. The local Reynolds number is defined as Repore=ulocaldmin/ν$Re_{{pore}}=u_{{local}}d_{{min}}/\nu$, where ulocal$u_{{local}}$ is obtained from the resolved internal pore-space velocity field and dmin$d_{{min}}$ denotes the characteristic minimum throat diameter of the reconstructed pore network. The values are reported for two porosity levels and two macroscopic Reynolds numbers to characterise the variation of local pore-scale flow strength with Rep$Re_{{p}}$ and ε$\varepsilon$.Table 2 long description.

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a) Vorticity magnitude contours at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$, contrasting the external wake of a solid sphere with the dense internal regions of high vorticity of a porous particle (ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$). (b) Comparison of dimensionless velocity magnitude distributions. The high-porosity model (ε=0.901$\varepsilon =0.901$) demonstrates deeper penetration of the mainstream flow, characterised by the formation of high-speed internal jets.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Streamwise pressure decay inside filled porous spheres at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$. The pressure coefficient is averaged over the fluid-phase portion of each cross-section inside the spherical envelope of the porous particle, with the solid skeleton excluded from the averaging domain. The end planes are taken at x/Dp=±0.45$x/D_{{p}}=\pm 0.45$ to avoid the vanishing cross-sectional area at the geometric front and rear tips. A solid sphere is excluded from this plot because it lacks an internal fluid phase for area averaging; its drag acts entirely on the geometric envelope rather than as a distributed internal field. (a) Streamwise evolution of the fluid-phase-averaged pressure coefficient, ⟨Cp⟩(x)$\langle C_{\!{p}} \rangle (x)$. (b) Core pressure-drop fraction, defined as Rcore=[⟨Cp⟩(−0.225)−⟨Cp⟩(0.225)]/[⟨Cp⟩(−0.45)−⟨Cp⟩(0.45)]×100%$R_{\mathrm{core}} = [\langle C_{\!{p}} \rangle (-0.225) - \langle C_{\!{p}} \rangle (0.225)] / [\langle C_{\!{p}} \rangle (-0.45) - \langle C_{\!{p}} \rangle (0.45)] \times 100\,\%$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.(a) Absolute drag factor trajectories for varying surface opening ratios (α=0.3−0.8$\alpha =0.3 {-} 0.8$). (b) Relative drag deviation (ΔCD$\Delta C_{{D}}$, defined as (CD,porous−CD,solid)/CD,solid×100%$(C_{{D},{porous}}-C_{{D},{solid}}) / C_{{D},{solid}} \times 100\,\%$) against the solid-sphere baseline. The results quantitatively demonstrate that increasing the surface opening ratio consistently lowers the aerodynamic resistance across all investigated Reynolds numbers. The porosity is maintained constant (ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$).

Figure 14

Figure 13.Variation of the normalised drag ratio (CD/CD,α=0.3$C_{{D}} / C_{{D}, \alpha =0.3}$) with the surface opening ratio (α$\alpha$) for different particle Reynolds numbers (Rep$Re_{{p}}$), while maintaining a constant porosity of ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$. Each curve is normalised by its respective absolute drag coefficient at α=0.3$\alpha =0.3$. The data indicate that the relative drag reduction is bounded within an approximately 5 % range across all investigated flow regimes, with the most distinct sensitivity to surface opening ratio observed in the inertial regime (Rep≥100$Re_{{p}} \geq 100$).

Figure 15

Figure 14.Comparison of surface pressure coefficient (Cp$C_{\!{p}}$) distributions on the windward face at Rep=100$Re_{{p}}=100$. The contours illustrate the modification of the stagnation pressure field due to varying surface topologies at a constant porosity of ε=0.803$\varepsilon = 0.803$. The solid-sphere baseline exhibits a continuous high-pressure stagnation zone, whereas porous particles with increasing surface opening ratios (α=0.3,0.5,0.8$\alpha =0.3, 0.5, 0.8$) display progressive fragmentation and reduction of the high-pressure area.

Figure 16

Figure 15.(a) Comparison of flow entry pathways determined by surface morphology at Rep=100$Re_{{p}}=100$. Three-dimensional streamline patterns for the low-surface-opening-ratio model (α=0.3$\alpha =0.3$) versus the high-coverage model (α=0.8$\alpha =0.8$). (b) Quantitative analysis of flow penetration capability. Streamwise evolution of the dimensionless volume flow rate ratio (m˙particle(x)/m˙0$\dot {m}_{{particle}}(x)/\dot {m}_0$) along the normalised axis x/Dp$x/D_{{p}}$, where the internal flux is integrated over the local envelope cross-section Scross(x)$S_{{cross}}(x)$ and normalised by A0$A_0$. The curves exhibit a positive correlation between internal flux and surface opening ratio α$\alpha$ over the windward and near-central regions (x/Dp≤0.1$x/D_{{p}} \leq 0.1$), and subsequently cross zero at α$\alpha$-dependent locations in the leeward half of the particle. The negative values are consistent with net re-entrainment of reverse wake flow through the leeward pores.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Surface-integrated drag-budget decomposition at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$. (a) Porosity effect at fixed surface opening ratio (α=0.5$\alpha =0.5$), comparing Models 1 and 18. (b) Surface-opening-ratio effect at fixed porosity (ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$), comparing Models 7 and 16. The four components denote the streamwise drag contributions from external friction, external pressure, internal friction and internal pressure, each normalised by the total drag of the corresponding model. The decomposition illustrates a spatial redistribution of the momentum transfer. Increasing total porosity shifts a portion of the relative contribution from the external envelope towards the internal skeleton, primarily manifesting as an increased internal pressure contribution. Increasing the surface opening ratio produces a weaker redistribution, maintaining the dominance of external form drag.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Influence of surface area ratio (S′$S^{\prime }$) on drag evolution trajectories. (a) Evolution of the absolute drag factor (CD⋅Rep$C_{{D}} \boldsymbol{\cdot }Re_{{p}}$). (b) Relative drag deviation (ΔCD$\Delta C_{{D}}$, defined as (CD,S′−CD,S′=3.15)/CD,S′=3.15×100%$(C_{{D}, S^{\prime }} - C_{{D}, S^{\prime }=3.15}) / C_{{D}, S^{\prime }=3.15} \times 100\,\%$) plotted on a semi-logarithmic scale. By isolating the relative differences against the coarsest skeleton baseline (0%$0\,\%$, dashed line), the plot illustrates the ‘drag crossover’ behaviour. The fine skeleton (S′=6.34$S^{\prime }=6.34$) generates a drag penalty at Rep≤20$Re_{{p}} \leq 20$ (positive deviation), intersects the zero baseline near Rep≈50$Re_{{p}} \approx 50$ and exhibits a relative drag reduction (up to ≈5%$\approx 5\,\%$) in the inertial regime.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Quantitative characterisation of the influence of surface area ratio (S′$S^{\prime }$) on drag. The data are normalised by the baseline configuration (S′=3.15$S^{\prime }=3.15$) to highlight relative variations. The curves illustrate a three-stage trend: a positive slope for Rep≤20$Re_{{p}} \leq 20$, a nearly horizontal transitional state at Rep=50$Re_{{p}} = 50$ and a negative slope for Rep≥100$Re_{{p}} \geq 100$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.(a) Transition of the dominant drag mechanism. The contribution ratios of friction drag (CD,f$C_{{D},{f}}$) and pressure drag (CD,p$C_{{D},{p}}$) show that the fine-skeleton model (S′=6.34$S^{\prime }=6.34$) sustains friction drag dominance over a wider Reynolds number range compared with the coarse model. (b) Illustration of friction drag dominance at a low Reynolds number (Rep=1$Re_{{p}}=1$). Comparison of the dimensionless skin-friction coefficient (Cf$C_{{f}}$) distributions on the surfaces of the coarse-skeleton (S′=3.15$S^{\prime }=3.15$, left) and fine-skeleton (S′=6.34$S^{\prime }=6.34$, right) models. The local Cf$C_{{f}}$ is defined as the local wall shear stress (τw$\tau _{{w}}$) normalised by the free-stream dynamic pressure (0.5ρU∞2$0.5 \rho U_{\infty }^2$).

Figure 21

Figure 20.(a) Contours of the dimensionless negative streamwise velocity (Ux∗=ux/U∞$U_x^{*} = u_x / U_{\infty }$) for the coarse skeleton (S′=3.15$S^{\prime }=3.15$, left) and the fine skeleton (S′=6.34$S^{\prime }=6.34$, right). The contour map delineates the recirculation zones, with the outermost thick black solid line demarcating the Ux∗=0$U_x^{*} = 0$ boundary. Internally, the isoline values show that the reverse-flow intensity (absolute magnitude of the reverse velocity) is slightly greater within the coarse skeleton. Externally, the near-wake core of the coarse skeleton exhibits higher absolute reverse velocities compared with the fine skeleton. (b) Streamwise evolution of the dimensionless centreline velocity (Ux∗=ux/U∞$U_x^{*} = u_x / U_{\infty }$). The fine-skeleton model (blue solid line) displays a reduced maximum backflow magnitude and a more rapid base velocity recovery compared to the solid sphere (red dashed line) and the coarse skeleton (black dash-dotted line), indicating an attenuation of the wake recirculation.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Transverse distributions of the dimensionless streamwise velocity (Ux∗=ux/U∞$U_x^{*} = u_x / U_{\infty }$) at Rep=200$Re_{{p}} = 200$. Rows from top to bottom represent the solid sphere, the coarse skeleton (S′=3.15$S^{\prime } = 3.15$) and the fine skeleton (S′=6.34$S^{\prime } = 6.34$), respectively. The columns display four downstream locations at axial positions specified in figure 20(b): xw/Dp=0.01$x_{{w}}/D_{{p}} = 0.01$ (immediate leeward vicinity), 0.25$0.25$ (primary recirculation zone), 0.5$0.5$ (vicinity of recirculation closure for porous cases) and 3.0$3.0$ (far-wake recovery). The thick black solid lines indicate the Ux∗=0$U_x^{*} = 0$ isolines bounding the reverse-flow regions, while the thick black dashed lines represent the geometric projection of the spherical envelope.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Kinematic and statistical characterisation of the flow at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$ for the five surface-area-ratio models (ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$, α=0.5$\alpha =0.5$). (a) Spatial probability density functions of the actual signed streamwise velocity, Ux∗=ux/U∞$U_x^{*}=u_x/U_{\infty }$, evaluated over the wake-core sampling window at xw/Dp=0.01$x_{{w}}/D_{{p}}=0.01$ and r⊥/Dp≤0.4$r_{\perp }/D_{{p}}\leq 0.4$; the corresponding spatial variances are reported in the legend. (b) Streamwise evolution of the dimensionless net internal flow-rate ratio, m˙particle(x)/m˙0$\dot {m}_{{particle}}(x)/\dot {m}_{0}$, obtained by integrating ux/U∞$u_x/U_{\infty }$ over the local fluid cross-section within the spherical envelope and normalising by A0$A_0$. The vertical dotted line denotes the particle centre plane, x/Dp=0$x/D_{{p}}=0$. Positive values represent net downstream through-flow, whereas negative values in the leeward half are consistent with net re-entrainment of reverse wake flow into the particle. Both the centre-plane through-flow and the magnitude of the negative leeward flux decrease with increasing S′$S^{\prime }$. (c) Positive and negative contributions of the signed near-wake streamwise velocity, M+$M_{+}$ and M−$M_{-}$. Increasing S′$S^{\prime }$ reduces both the net internal through-flow and the magnitude of the negative net flux in the leeward half. In the immediate near wake, the dominant systematic change is the attenuation of the negative-velocity contribution, whereas M+$M_{+}$ varies more weakly and non-monotonically.

Figure 24

Table 3.Quantitative statistics of the near-wake signed dimensionless streamwise velocity, Ux∗=ux/U∞$U_x^{*} = u_x / U_{\infty }$, for the five surface-area-ratio models (ε=0.803$\varepsilon =0.803$, α=0.5$\alpha =0.5$) evaluated at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$. The spatial statistics are extracted over the wake-core sampling window (xw/Dp=0.01$x_{{w}}/D_{{p}}=0.01$, r⊥/Dp≤0.4$r_{\perp }/D_{{p}} \leq 0.4$). The metrics include the spatial variance (σUx∗2$\sigma _{U_x^{*}}^{2}$), spatial skewness (γ1$\gamma _{1}$), positive and negative velocity contributions (M+,M−$M_{+}, M_{-}$), reverse-flow area fraction (P−$P_{-}$) and the conditional reverse-flow magnitude (μ−$\mu _{-}$), quantifying the preferential attenuation of the reverse flow with increasing S′$S^{\prime }$.Table 3 long description.

Figure 25

Figure 23.Hydrodynamic mechanism of pressure drag suppression at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$. Contours illustrate the pressure coefficient (Cp$C_{\!{p}}$) distribution and streamline topology. The fine-skeleton model (right) exhibits enhanced base-pressure recovery in the wake region compared with the coarse skeleton (left). This recovery corresponds to a reduction in the net fore–aft pressure differential across the particle.

Figure 26

Table 4.Coefficients of the proposed drag correlation. The coefficients marked with an asterisk highlight the sign reversals characterising the regime transition mechanisms. Applicability: filled porous spheres with ε≤0.901$\varepsilon \leq 0.901$.Table 4 long description.

Figure 27

Figure 24.Parity plot comparing the model predictions with the LBM simulation results, showing a tight distribution of data points around the diagonal (R2=0.9868$R^2 = 0.9868$, MAPE=1.3%$\mathrm{MAPE} = 1.3\,\%$).

Figure 28

Table 5.Grid convergence study and observed order of accuracy at Rep=200$Re_{{p}}=200$. The resolution index n$n$ denotes the number of lattice nodes spanning the minimum pore throat diameter dmin$d_{{min}}$.Table 5 long description.

Figure 29

Figure 25.Validation of the numerical framework: (a) drag factor CD⋅Rep$C_{{D}} \boldsymbol{\cdot }Re_{{p}}$ for solid spheres compared with the Schiller–Naumann correlation; (b) drag factor CD⋅Rep$C_{{D}} \boldsymbol{\cdot }Re_{{p}}$ for open-cell porous shells (ε=0.87$\varepsilon = 0.87$) compared with PR-DNS data from Miao et al. (2022).

Figure 30

Figure 26.Comparison of the predicted drag factor (CD⋅Rep$C_{{D}} \boldsymbol{\cdot }Re_{{p}}$) with experimental measurements of agglomerated porous particles (Ma et al.2020). The R2$R^2$ values denote the coefficients of determination between the proposed model predictions and the respective experimental datasets.

Figure 31

Figure 27.Validation of the semi-empirical drag model against experimental data for solid and highly porous spheres (Emadzadeh & Chiew 2020). The functional dependency highlights the aerodynamic divergence in the inertial regime, where the porous particle exhibits a higher rate of inertial resistance increase. The coefficients of determination (R2>0.99$R^2 \gt 0.99$) are provided for both configurations.