In their new book, Colette Establet and Jean-Paul Pascual have turned their attention to the askeri of Damascus in the late 17th century. Defined by privilege and comprising some of the most affluent persons in local societies, the askeri were a social group composed of those few individuals (and their wives and children) in the service of the Ottoman state, either as members of the military or in civil administration. The publication was conceived as complementary to the authors’ earlier study, Familles et fortunes à Damas: 450 foyers damascains en 1700 (Beirut: Institut Français de Damas, 1994), which focused on the tax-paying population (reaya) of the city. Because documentation on the askeri mostly dates from 1680 to 1682, however, the book under review concerns a slightly earlier period (by roughly ten to twenty years).
Similar to their first book, this study presents the results of a serial analysis of records of inheritance. The register includes not only probate inventories, as with the two registers analyzed in the authors’ previous book, but also account records concerning the management of the inheritance of orphaned minors, submitted by the orphans’ guardians. This is indeed fortunate: while probate inventories, recorded shortly after death, give a static picture of askeri properties, account records provide information on the exploitation and evolution of such properties over time. The combination of those two types of documents has enabled a richer and more sophisticated analysis of the data.
The sources have their own biases and limitations, which Establet and Pascual are very well aware of; after all, they have been working on records of inheritance for many years now and have in the process amassed considerable expertise. Given that some of the issues they address, such as the functioning of the loan market or the exploitation of landholdings, are very broad and complex and cannot be properly researched on the basis of records of inheritance alone, the authors leave more questions unanswered than readers would wish for. It would be unfair, however, to criticize them for the shortcomings of the archival material. Reading probate inventories and account records, creating databases with information from such sources, and analyzing the data is arduous, time consuming, and often unrewarding work. The authors’ aim was to analyze the archival material exhaustively, discuss it in depth, and explore all subjects to which it relates while taking into account its shortcomings. In this they have undoubtedly succeeded.
The book addresses central issues for the history of Ottoman elites, such as the composition of the Damascene askeri and their relations to the reaya population, their internal differentiations, the kind and scope of their economic activities and behaviors, demographic characters, styles of living, and patterns of consumption. Faithful to the methodology developed in their previous research, Establet and Pascual have submitted the data deriving from the archival material to exhaustive and multifaceted statistical analysis and evaluation. The presentation and discussion of both the data and the results of the serial analysis engages constantly with the literature, including other studies based on probate inventories. Most of all, comparisons are constantly drawn with the authors’ earlier work on the reaya.
Establet and Pascual have not restricted themselves to the questions that lie in the core of their research on the askeri, but they have followed almost every road to which information from the archival material has led them. As a result, the book under review is at once something less and more than a study of a particular social group: less, because it is structured around the information deriving from one particular source; more, because the authors have in practice expanded their subject matter to include the climate, the agricultural products, or the geophysical characteristics of the Damascene countryside as well as land tenure practices, vakıf administration, or laborers’ wages and salaries. In fact, the authors have ignored no aspect of the matters under scrutiny, whether the exact meaning of Ottoman terms found in the documents or the dynamics behind long-term developments, such as the formation of çiftliks. Unfortunately, they did not include a thematic index, which would have increased the usefulness of the book. The only help for navigating through the rich and diverse information presented and discussed in it is the—thankfully detailed—table of contents. In the following, I present in brief some of the most important conclusions that the authors reach.
The askeri of Damascus appear to have been predominantly members of the military; the most numerous group among them were the so-called “local janissaries” (as opposed to the kapı kulu, janissaries sent from Istanbul). The names and titles of the deceased and their progeny indicate established patterns of inheritance of offices. Nonetheless, the askeri were not a closed group: many of them, including almost half of the women, were of reaya origin.
Wealth was unequally distributed among the askeri. On the whole, persons involved in the judicial and civil administration, including that of pious foundations, were somewhat richer than the military. Compared to the reaya, the askeri of Damascus were on average more indebted at the time of their deaths, perhaps because of their more expensive lifestyles. In contrast, they were heavily involved in lending money, both to townspeople and to villagers. All groups lent money, though the kapı kulu were more active than others in giving loans to peasants. In addition, although the value of askeri estates did not differ much on average from that of the reaya, they were composed to a far greater extent by money in cash.
The economic activities of the Damascene askeri were diverse and, besides money lending, included involvement in commerce (mainly by civilians) and manufacture (mainly by janissaries). The askeri, however, derived income mostly from the countryside. Here again internal differentiations are not negligible. Members of the religiojudicial establishment profited mainly from lands belonging to pious foundations. Local janissaries, by contrast, tended to invest in rural real property and to be more actively involved in the exploitation of their landholdings. The latter were not freehold properties; they were farms on miri or vakıf land, the usufruct of which used to belong to peasants at the heyday of the timar system. The nonmilitary askeri derived revenues mostly from vegetable gardens, orchards, and vineyards situated in the countryside near Damascus; the military received income from landholdings in more remote villages, the economy of which was based on a combination of cereal cultivation and cattle breeding.
As concerns material culture and lifestyles, the askeri followed the way of the rich: fine and costly textiles, furs, slaves, and horses. The items enumerated in the probate inventories point to an expensive—sometimes indeed luxurious—style of living and to a degree of conspicuous consumption that many could not necessarily support. The estates of those few from among the askeri who had practiced polygamy, a lifestyle peculiar to the rich, testify to their living above their means: although those individuals had larger fortunes and left more living children behind, on the average they were far more indebted than the rest at the time of their deaths and, as a result, left smaller shares to their heirs.
In conclusion, Collette Establet and Jean-Paul Pascual, through their diligence in research, detailed scrutiny, and exhaustive statistical analysis of probate inventories and accounts of estates of orphaned minors, have opened a vista on the world of the askeri. The study, although it concerns a particular time and place, can be of relevance to, and a trove of information for, practically every student of Ottoman social and economic history and not only for those interested in Syria. The authors’ conclusions do not of course predicate the profile of the askeri in other towns of the empire, but they definitely offer inspiration and comparative material as well as provide a framework for understanding better the Ottoman urban society and economy of the late 17th century.
