Under the auspices of Kurt Siehr (Hamburg, Zürich) the 9th International Seminar on “Art & Law” took place from July 6–9, 2007, in Basel, Switzerland. Originally conceived as a platform for doctorate candidates in Europe and over the last years enlarged to a platform for comprehensive discussions between lawyers as well as art historians, academics as well as practitioners, this year's seminar in Basel focused on three main issues: protection of cultural property, problems of stolen works of art (both including their international and European legal frame), and copyright protection.
The opening speech was held by Anna Schmid in her function as host and director of the Museum der Kulturen, which also served as an illustrious meeting place for these working days in Basel. Kurt Siehr followed with his paper, “Current Trends in the Field of Legal Protection of Cultural Property.” Siehr brought up the case of the planned bridge near Dresden, Dresdner Waldschlösschenbrücke, and indirect effects of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention (Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage of November 16, 1972).Footnote 1 He also considered the topics modern legal attempts to protect cultural property as a result of military conflicts (e.g., Iraq or Afghanistan); repatriation of cultural property (e.g., problematic effect of precedent, criminal procedure against Marion True, etc.); the German implementation of the UNESCO Convention of November 14, 1970, on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural PropertyFootnote 2; and, finally, the discussion about the so-called Guggenheim Principle (e.g., Louvre in Abu Dhabi). Nikolaus Linder (Luzern, Zurich) gave in his ensuing lecture a review about “Restitution Cases Heard by the Courts of Switzerland after the Second World War” and proposed an application of Niclas Luhmann's “systems theory” on those cases of restitution. Michael Franz (Magdeburg) presented the “Topical Debate about Lost Cultural Property in Germany from the Perspective of the Koordinierungsstelle für Kulturgutverluste” (Germany's central office for the documentation of lost cultural property, based at the Ministry of Culture of the Land Saxony-Anhalt in Magdeburg). From this point of view Franz—head of the Koordinierungsstelle in Magdeburg—underlined ethical as well as legal aspects of stolen cultural property in connection with Nazi persecution before or during the World War II. The next paper was “Art Treasures of Unknown Owners—Legal Problems of Handling Art Treasures Stolen and Illegally Discovered a Long Time Ago” by Sophie Engelhardt (Berlin) followed by “Degenerated Art in the Kunstmuseum Basel” by Esther Tisa Francini (Zurich, Basel) and her guided tour through the Kunstmuseum.
The second day of the seminar started with a lecture given by Kerstin Odendahl (St. Gallen) on a quaint case of arrest driven by a private corporation: “The Arrest of Public Russian Artworks in the Canton of Valais Driven by the Company Noga in November 2005—A Sequel.” A paper by Marie Boillat (Geneva), “The International Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters and Cultural Property,” highlighted the enormous practical importance of the issue. The ensuing lecture given by Eva Inés Obergfell (Munich), “Modern Art and Copyright,” opened the discussion about copyright matters and, in particular, the controversial question of whether or not new forms of conceptual art, ready-mades, happenings, or the like enjoy protection under the German copyright regime.
The afternoon was dedicated to the paper by Raphael Contel (Geneva), “The UNESCO Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions,”Footnote 3 and the development of the freedom of art. With respect to the latter, Andrews Reller (Zurich) gave a survey, “Art before the European Court of Human Rights,” and Ursula Machulla (Cologne) informed about the development of the “Freedom of Art as a Fundamental Right at Community Level.”
With a paper on “Developments of the Public Collecting Activities” Antoniette Maget (Paris, Eichstätt) opened the third day of the seminar. The subsequent presentation of Lucas Elmenhorst (Frankfurt am Main), (“Architecture and Copyright: No Underground Theatre of Light?—The Copyright Litigation between Architect and Building Owner about the New Central Station of Berlin,” considered a recent case concerning the infringement of an architect's copyright. Elmenhorst reviewed the decision of the Landgericht Berlin Footnote 4 under a legal as well as an art historic perspective. The last seminar paper, “Mortgaged Indian Gold Coins,” given by Jörg Sprecher (Luzern), also consisted of a case report on a famous recent case decided by the Swiss Federal Court.Footnote 5 The final discussion embraced the provocative thesis, “The Art Trade is Free!?” raised by Siehr and gave a general view on the future protection of cultural property including its problems of international enforcement. The 10th International Seminar on “Art & Law” took place in July 2008 in Berlin.
