No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2004
In the run up to the 2003 APSA meetings, at which the Association celebrated the centenary of political science as an established discipline in America, I was asked by the main organizers of the meetings, Margaret Weir and Henry Brady, to propose a theme roundtable that would address conceptual and political issues implicit in the history of our discipline over the last century. It was a special pleasure to be able to secure agreement from four distinguished scholars ranging over several sub-fields from within the discipline to offer quite distinctive, yet in many ways compatible, perspectives on what Professor Farr characterized as “some of the lessons and challenges— mixed as they are, but worthy of debate— concerning the science of politics, then and now, as we look forward on our Association's 100th anniversary.”1
The participants on the APSA roundtable included Professors John Gunnell, James Farr, Rogers Smith and Ido Oren. An additional commentary on the original roundtable was given by Professor Ira Katznelson.
John Gunnell's essay begins by reminding us that “telling the story of political science has always been a crucial element in both the discipline's internal rhetoric of inquiry and its search for identity.” Gunnell then considers whether there might be said to have been paradigmatic shifts in political science that are “logically comparable” to what Thomas Kuhn took to be represented in the history of natural science. Gunnell's answer is that there has really only been one such “revolution” in the roughly 150 year career of political science as a distinct discourse and discipline, and that this change entailed both a new vision of political reality and a normative reconstitution of the idea of “democracy.” This revolution marked a transformation from an understanding of the state as “an organic people or community that preceded both the constitution and government and that gave meaning to the ideas of popular sovereignty and democracy” to one of a pluralistic account of American society “without a common unity or existence.”
Gunnell notes that this earlier paradigm of the unity of “a people” was not “disproven” or falsified on some “factual” or philosophical basis in a way that we might speak of as “progress.” Indeed, one has only to think of work as recent as that of Samuel Beer in the last decade on American federalism or perhaps that of David Easton to recognize that elements of this earlier paradigm still command the status of an image of history as well as one of potent aspiration. The provocative question Gunnell then poses for the future of political science is whether such pluralism has now become more than a “debilitated paradigm” which has “maintained itself through the medium of ad hoc accretions?”
If pluralism has been a dominating presence in the discipline of the previous century, Rogers Smith's essay is concerned with a noticeable absence in its research agenda. In looking back on a century of political science scholarship, Smith's attention is focused on race and its puzzling omission from much of the disciplinary history of American political science. Part of the explanation for this omission Smith takes to be the assigned status of race as a pre-political, or “natural datum” exogenous to politics, rather than as an identity “substantially created by formal laws and political institutions.” This highly contestable assumption, Smith suggests, remains as part of the present as well as the past history of the discipline, such that even with expansion of contemporary considerations of the role of race in politics, political scientists yet “may be failing to explore fully the role of politics in creating racial identities and racial conflicts.”
Looking back, Smith's essay explores the “explicit racism” of much of early political science scholarship of those, such as Burgess, Adams, and—though to a lesser extent—Willoughby, who shared that more organic view of the state as a “higher nation” discussed by Gunnell. These racial themes entailed specific implications of intellectual academic disregard and race-based segregation within the discipline while fostering racist policy constraints within the larger society. His essay supports the call for a broader sense of racial construction as playing a wider role in virtually all forms of politics that we study.
Jim Farr's essay echoes this concern with the direction of future research, since as he notes, the centenary of the APSA provides a “timely occasion” upon which to reflect not only on the science of politics, both past and present, but also in some cases, on its future. Farr's central focus in this context is to explore the contribution of the discipline, both then and now, to civic education. He turns first to 1903 and the very outset of the Association, and to a conception of politics as civic education. However blind they were to both the construction of race, as well as that of gender, by which they limited the rights and lives of African Americans and women, Farr's piece notes the considerable extent to which the committee of an early Association reached out to inform and shape American civic education, and to connect it to “rights and duties by way of understanding practical arts, social analysis, and history.”
Reflecting on the history of the Association, Farr notes that while “the worldview of political scientists ‘now’ has no place for views proscribing suffrage on grounds of race and gender or propagating the racial destiny of ‘civilized states’ to educate the world,” such views continue to have consequences—both practical and ideological—for contemporary politics, at least if one is to judge by “persistent patterns of civic exclusion, widespread disparities in political participation, and prejudicial opinions about race, gender, immigration or America's role in the world.” Farr encourages an APSA of the new century to imagine and to encourage pedagogical reflection on the character of a new and reconsidered civic education of use in developing, as he describes them, the skills and arts of active citizenship.
Finally, Ido Oren's essay shifts the gears of historical reflection one last time to consider the Association's historical place in the larger world, and the dialectical relationship between political science and the conduct of politics. His essay demonstrates that permeable line separating the study of an academically based science of politics and the practical conduct of American foreign policy abroad from the turn of the 19th century to post WWII, and into the later decades of the 20th century. Whether serving as government officials, advisers, or consultants, leading political scientists participated actively and at every level in government service. A separable question, however, is the putative influence on the State and on government policy of the participants as political scientists active in such service. In general, Oren suggests the record is mixed. However, when the lens is reversed and the stimulus and influence of governmental support on the state and direction of academic research within the discipline is considered—whether in favoring or funding the development of particular methods and/or areas of substantive research—Oren's conclusions are less equivocal. He concludes, in part, that “during the American Century the science of politics has been significantly implicated in the politics of U.S. foreign policy,” but that the arrow of implication pointed most in the direction of the extent to which America's national security concerns shaped not only research questions but also “favored and funded” the development of research methods. Such a conclusion remains an important, if neglected, subject of disciplinary history and suggests along with each of the essays presented yet another subject of consideration and research in the discipline's future.