A striking cover image of Edith Dawson absorbed in her work as an enameler provides a visual introduction to one of the major themes of Zoë Thomas's Women Art Workers and the Arts and Crafts Movement, which focuses on the strategies adopted by women art workers in their quest for recognition as artists and skilled makers in turn-of-the-century England. Concentrating largely on activities in London, Thomas explores “the buildings and spaces women art workers repeatedly conceptualised as critical to the formation of their artistic, professional lives” (22), discussing the roles of guilds and clubhouses; exhibitions and other displays; domestic life, “At Homes”, and studios; and businesses and workshops. Thomas then assesses the impact of the suffrage campaigns in which many of the art workers were active and the changes brought by World War I and its aftermath. In the epilogue she considers the slow progress of the established arts organizations in admitting women as equal members as late as the 1960s, and the continuing relevance of the issues raised both by women artists and scholars.
Central to Thomas's research was the discovery of papers of the long-neglected Women's Guild of Arts, established in 1907 by May Morris and others as a sister organization to the Art Workers’ Guild (founded 1884) but dismissed in a few words by the Guild's historian as a minor offshoot and then forgotten. Despite the separate existence of the two groups, one revelation of Thomas's book is how closely they were linked: the Women's Guild of Arts met regularly in the hall of the Art Workers' Guild, often invited speakers from the Guild, and in 1913 asked several supportive members to become honorary associates. Not having a hall of its own, the Women's Guild of Arts left no physical trace, unlike the Art Workers' Guild with its city-center rooms, accumulation of distinctive furnishings and growing array of portraits of “Past Masters.” Study of the archive and a related collection in the United States enabled Thomas to frame a more representative picture of the larger arts and crafts movement and to suggest that women took a bigger role than is usually acknowledged. This is important because membership of the Art Workers' Guild, despite the drawback of its male-only constitution, is seen as one of the several ways to define an artist as belonging to the arts and crafts movement, which had neither an agreed-upon manifesto nor an easily identified style. It is complicated, however, by the fact that the Women's Guild of Arts appeared when the larger movement had been developing for more than twenty years. Thomas rightly points out that its history has been distorted by the usual focus of scholars on the works of “great men,” but she does not really deal with the issues of originality and innovation that are seductive to art historians and result in so much attention to the origins of any movement and less to the longer story.
Other groups now largely forgotten are also discussed in some detail. These include the Lyceum Club, founded by the remarkable Constance Smedley, which acquired its own premises and negotiated opportunities to display its members’ work in several German cities; the Englishwoman Exhibition and its regular shows in prestigious London venues; and two commercial exhibitions at Earl's Court in 1897 and 1900, organized by an enterprising Hungarian, which offered exposure to a much wider audience. Their strategy was to gather women's work together and advertise it as such, whereas the Women's Guild of Arts members preferred inclusion in mixed-sex outlets such as the Arts and Crafts Exhibition Society so they could be judged as designers and makers alongside their peers rather than risk their work being patronized as “dainty.” The decision by the Women's Guild of Arts to exhibit a separate “Lady's Bedroom” at the significant 1916 Arts and Crafts Exhibition held at the Royal Academy of Arts in the middle of the war is seen by Thomas as a volte face by a group affected by a generally awakened sense of citizenship and complicit in its own marginalization at this event. Thomas's discussion of the wartime period reveals interesting diversification in some of the women's crafts as they took up toy making to replace German imports and learned new skills such as welding and splint making.
There are many histories of the arts and crafts movement, written by architectural, craft and design historians, scholars with regional or national interests, biographers, and company historians. In the past forty years, much of the published work has been object-focused, produced by museum curators, associated with exhibitions or collections, and seductively illustrated with the products of named designers. Women Art Workers and the Arts and Crafts Movement is not that kind of book. It is an exploration of the social, business, and professional activities of significant networks of under-recognized artists and an analysis of the reasons behind their contrasting strategies in tackling the obstacles placed in their way by the assumptions of well-meaning colleagues (in the Art Workers' Guild, for example, or in Studio magazine) and wider patriarchal attitudes in society. It enlarges on, and often challenges, pioneering feminist studies by Anthea Callen, Lynne Walker, and others and will be a vital addition to the literature for anyone teaching modern history, whether focused on art and design, social and economic history, or gender studies. In addition to extensive research in public and private archives in Britain, South Africa, and the United States, it is clearly based on a thorough knowledge of the relevant theory and literature and includes excellent notes and bibliography. It is well produced, and although its forty-one illustrations are in black and white, this is fitting since most are from old photographs or magazine articles. Many are useful rediscoveries and they provide valuable evidence to back up the text. Individual scholars may wish to wait for a paperback since the price is high, but it will be essential reading and a stimulating resource for anyone working on the period and should be in the library of every institution studying and promoting history.
