This book delivers exactly what the title promises—ten chapters that discuss debt, slavery, and debt slavery throughout the Mediterranean and Atlantic, ranging from classical Rome to twentieth-century Egypt.
The editors’ introductory chapter sets up the aims of the book and highlights themes of the other chapters. The editors are interested in the “interplay between economy, society and institutions of slavery.” Two particular themes stand out: the response of slavery to economic, political, and moral pressures, and the dependence of types of debt and labor on the structure of power. This chapter also provides a chronological overview of slavery that covers ancient Greece and Rome, the transition to medieval slavery, debt bondage in early modern Europe, debt slavery in Islam and precolonial Africa, the slave trade, indentured labor in the Americas, and abolition.
Kleijwegt's chapter on early Roman slavery makes a narrow contribution, noting difficulties with Finley's argument that chattel slavery in Rome only became important after the abolition of nexum (a form of debt bondage). Kleijwegt shows that imprisonment for debt continued after the supposed ban in 326 BC, and that the number of slaves captured in war after 326 has been exaggerated.
Alessandro Stanziani's chapter provides an overview of the import of Russian, Tartar, and Central Asian slaves into the Mediterranean from the fifteenth through the eighteenth centuries. His account follows three major routes over three periods—the Silk Road over the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, the Russian-Iranian-Indian route from the fourteenth century to the sixteenth century, and the trade that followed on the expansion of Russia and integration of the Mongol Khanates during the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries. This history, he argues, forces a reevaluation of the presumed decline of the nomadic powers.
Michael Ferguson argues that, during the nineteenth century, the Ottoman state intervened in the emancipation of African slaves as part of its greater expansion into previously unregulated aspects of society. This was justified by a new ideology in which the sultan was the “patron of a benevolent state.” Liberated slaves were useful to the state: “homeless, kinless, and patronless, they were the type most easily brought under its influence.”
Chapters by Lovejoy and Ojo both deal with pawnship in Africa. Lovejoy provides a broad overview that repeats themes from his earlier “Pawnship, Slavery, and Colonialism in Africa.” Ojo focuses more specifically on pawnship among the Yoruba. His evidence on the causes of indebtedness and on how pawnship affected women and children covers new ground that distinguishes his chapter from earlier works by Oroge and Falola.
Menard's chapter reviews the debate on why slavery supplanted indentured labor in the Americas. He argues that recent work by Walsh and Coombs has undermined the existing consensus that favors the relative supply of servants and slaves over planters’ preference for slaves. Rather, planters were heterogeneous, and the ascent of slavery was a “complex process, with multiple overlapping phases and significant subregional diversity.”
The chapter by Joseph Miller stands out as an excellent example of world history, describing the role of credit in the slave trade over the span of three centuries and throughout the Atlantic world.
Henrique Espada Lima traces the reinvention of forms of bondage in nineteenth-century Brasil, which occurred despite the spread of ideologies of free labor and voluntary contract. Serels concludes the volume with a discussion of the role of debt in compelling Sudanese participation in the cash crop economy.
The stated aims of the editors are to “identify the contours of debt slavery in specific historical and institutional contexts and explain why, in a given space and time, this rather than another form of bondage was conceived and put into practice.” The book achieves the first task, but not the second, which would require hypothesis testing in a large sample with a more global scope. Indeed, many individual chapters show a deliberate preference for complex narratives over parsimonious explanations with external validity. Further, the case studies are not selected to exploit any natural experiments that would give them exceptional internal validity. They are, however, illuminating descriptions of the relationship between debt and slavery in specific contexts. These will be invaluable in motivating testable hypotheses and in better understanding systematic relationships that are revealed by data.
