Timothy Noah has written an important and superbly lucid book on one of the key issues of our time: the growth of income inequality. Although focussed on the US, many of the arguments in the book are applicable to the UK and other EU countries where inequality has been on the rise. If the post-war period in the US and the UK was characterised as one of income compression and convergence, in which differences in income and wealth shrank and the middle class grew prosperous, the opposite has been true since the mid-1970s − hence the phrase ‘Great Divergence’ coined in the present context by Princeton's Paul Krugman.
As Noah points out, between 1980 and 2005 roughly 80 per cent of the increase in pre-tax income in the US went to the top 1 per cent of households. Although the poor have become somewhat poorer, the most striking feature of the past thirty years is that the rich have become hugely richer, so much so that the income share of the top percentile group, having fallen to 9 per cent in 1970, has now risen to 25 per cent. Moreover, today, both the data sets and the techniques used to analyse them have become far more sophisticated.
A corollary is that US inter-generational social mobility has fallen, so that if you are born into a low-income group, the probability that you will remain poor is significantly higher than it was two generations ago. In short, the egalitarian gains of the post-war period have been wiped out, and the ‘American dream’ is disappearing. Not only is the USA today the least egalitarian of the OECD countries, but US income inequality is greater than in Uruguay, Guyana or Venezuela.
Why this happened is of course a subject of much controversy. Neither race disparities nor gender disparities help explain the growth of US income inequality since these, however lamentable, have remained nearly constant over the period in question. The orthodox answer is that globalisation has seen unskilled jobs go to recent immigrants or else sucked off to low-wage countries, thus placing an increasing premium on education and skills. Noah examines the evidence carefully and concludes that although this phenomenon is doubtless important, it cannot begin to explain the enormous stretching of the top tail of the distribution; i.e, the growth of the super-rich. In his phrase ‘the Great divergence is not principally a story about the poor’. The heterodox answer is that the growth of income inequality is mainly about the growth of right-wing politics.
Noah devotes several chapters to what Gore Vidal famously termed ‘socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor’, the politics of which includes not merely regressive tax and deregulatory legislation enacted by various administrations from Reagan onwards, but the growing influence of pro-business lobbies − in Washington shorthand, the power of K-Street. Arguably, of most importance is the rise of ‘financialisation’ and the culture of corporate bonuses which accompanied it. A marker of this growth is that divergences in pre-tax income − the ‘market distribution of income’ − have grown faster than those in post-tax income. Cleverly, Noah has devoted a section to examining and rebutting in detail each of the arguments advanced by the US right-wing, either denying the growth of inequality or the need to reverse it.
The author concludes with a chapter entitled ‘What to do’. Should tax rates be raised? Clearly, a starting point would be to allow the Bush tax cuts for the very rich to expire. Moreover, Noah, quoting Warren Buffett, would like to see new high-tax brackets for incomes above a million per annum added to existing ones, with the top rate of marginal tax rising to 70 per cent and designed to include income from bonuses and capital gains. Equally, he notes the regressive nature of the US payroll tax that funds US Social Security and Medicare − the logic of which, one might note, is directly applicable to UK national insurance contributions.
He wants to phase out common tax dodges for the self-employed as well as ‘the various other shelter schemes and deductions and tax credits that currently pollute the tax system’. One wishes that the book had dealt at greater length with the crucial issues of tax avoidance and evasion, the importance of which is implicit in the gap between nominal and effective tax rates he reports for different income groups.
Other measures the author advocates include increasing the federal payroll (he notes that there were a million fewer government employees in 2010 than in 1962) as well as removing immigration barriers on highly skilled labour, thus largely eliminating the college and graduate school wage premiums used by universities to justify recent rapid fee rises. These same fee rises, if necessary, could be backed by price controls on universities. Unsurprisingly, he calls for the universalisation of pre-school education, noting that only a quarter of four-year olds are enrolled in preschool programmes; uncharacteristically, he fails to note numerous studies suggesting that preschool education is a major predictor of school achievement and, as in the Nordic countries, enhanced social mobility.
Further measures include greater regulation of Wall Street, the revival and strengthening of trade unions (e.g., by repealing the Taft Hartley Act of 1948, much of which was adopted by Thatcher forty years later in the UK) and the importance of ‘electing Democratic Presidents’ − a recent study by Larry Bartels shows that under Democrats, income gains tend to decrease as one moves from poor to rich, while under Republicans precisely the opposite is true.
This book makes no claim to academic originality, but it does cover an enormous amount of ground in the best tradition of well-informed journalism. The weaknesses of this book are to be found in insufficiently detailed policy recommendations and, more broadly, in the apparently contradiction between the author's progressive intentions and the growing body of evidence suggesting the US has irreversibly crossed the dividing line between democracy and plutocracy.
The strength of the book is that it maintains a careful balance between advocacy, academic rigour and accessibility. Most important, it is an immensely enjoyable and readable book coming at a time when all of us − not just the US readership − should be deeply concerned about its subject matter. The author has done us a great service.
