Martin Ashley is Head of Research in the Faculty of Education at Edge Hill University, with a background as a middle school music teacher, which includes experience at a cathedral choir school. He has been involved, in a consultative capacity, in the UK government's National Singing Programme and the Choir Schools' Association Chorister Outreach Programme, and carried out project work with the National Youth Choirs of Great Britain. How High Should Boys Sing? is the culmination of a long-term set of studies in this area of research.
Written in the first person, this book is immediately accessible and engaging, with several well-placed and illuminating personal anecdotes for which the author seems, at times, unnecessarily apologetic. At the same time, the book achieves the author's aim of providing a scholarly analysis of boys and their relationship to singing, addressing the question in the title whilst also considering some of the reasons why so few adolescent boys sing at all.
Ashley provides a wealth of information about the UK choral system, with thoughtful insights into the life of a chorister and a history of the role of boys' voices in both church and secular music. The physiology of the young male voice is clearly explicated, and the impact of the voice change process on the developing male is considered. The book also covers issues related to identity, culture, social class, image, social control, commercial and market forces.
The first section of the book embarks upon a discussion of the nature of boyhood, in the context of a changing definition of childhood, and relates perceptions of singing to self-concept and identity development. The second section places the evolution of attitudes to boys' singing into a historical, social and cultural context. The chapter devoted to physiological vocal development details quantifiable changes to fundamental frequency, vocal range, speaking pitch, and physical changes in the vocal instrument, whilst not neglecting to link aspects of the voice change process to social and emotional concerns.
In the chapter ‘Subjectivity and agency in the young male voice’, Ashley compares the subjective nature of adult perceptions of boys' singing with the reality of boys' experiences of using their developing voices. This chapter includes a straightforward (and often humorous) appraisal of earlier opinions and practices in vocal training and a deconstruction of some of the associated myths and misconceptions. A strong and timely warning is given about the far-reaching consequences of inappropriate or inadequate vocal training, particularly during adolescence, as this has implications for the health of the developing adult voice. It is here that the author begins to make his own recommendations regarding the use and training of the changing voice.
In Chapter 5, Ashley successfully navigates a potentially treacherous course in an examination of the ‘Admiration of the boy’, the nostalgic idealism of some adults towards ‘the boy’, and some of the darker implications of this. The following chapter explores the benefits of choral singing when it becomes professional work, and the demands that this imposes on adolescent singers. At this point, the question posed in the title is directly addressed.
The commercial role of choral singers is discussed, along with their image (both for the audience and from the boys' perspective) and the conflict between this and their need to appear ‘cool’ to their contemporaries. These ideas are then developed into a consideration of boys' desire for a secure male identity, and the potential hazards of using incompletely developed voices to emulate adult male vocal performance. Descriptive colour is added to this section with peer assessment of teenagers' singing, providing direct insight into male adolescents' anxieties about image and identity. Finally, there is an evaluation of recent attempts to involve more boys in singing, and suggestions for future strategies.
How High Should Boys Sing? is only one of the questions explored in this book, which has a much wider scope than the title suggests. It would be of interest to any general reader who is involved in singing, whilst providing a scholarly approach for the more specialised researcher, and would be a useful and thought-provoking addition to the library of any singing teacher, choral director or music educator.
